Permanently Closed - Pig and Prince
Restaurants you may also like
All pre theater reservations made after 5:30 pm for guests attending the Welmont. Please allow approximately 2 hours and plan accordingly.
This has been one of my all-time local favorite for date nights or a night out with girlfriends. It's a shame that the place is now permanently closed. I've never had a bad meal here, may it be brunch, dinner, or from their bar menu. Their duck grilled cheese, chicken and waffles, and sticky pork were definitely unforgettable. Chef Mike always keeping things fresh and amazing! And let's not forget about their cocktails at the bar and the overall ambience of this place. This place is truly a gem and still sorely missed.
It's a damn shame that this gorgeous, wonderful restaurant has to close after all of the work they did to renovate this historic space. The Montclair town council should be ashamed that their half-assed renovation plans for adjacent spaces showed no respect for the integrity of this wonderful existing business.
Very small menu but what we had was delicious.
Great place to celebrate a special event like mothers day. The food was amazing and the drinks unique and well made, would recommend to anyone!
We had a great experience overall. Our server was very knowledgeable and attentive. The food was excellent. However, the hostess was not pleased with us because we asked to sit in a different seat than first offered to us. She showed her annoyance to our request by walking away in a huff after seating us. Very rude behavior for a hostess!
Food was interesting & well prepared. Service was fine. Drinks were great - loved the atmosphere. Definitely would come back.
Wonderful birthday dinner. There was a small party in the back room which made the restaurant louder than usual, but overall great experience.
Always nice to dine here. Happened to be a branch brook park for the Apple blossoms and stopped in with wife, son and in-laws. Very accommodating for my son.
There was a mouse running in the restaurant. Brought it to the attention of staff but wasn’t a priority
My husband and I not only loved the venue but we loved the food! They were so considerate of my allergies and helpful! The only complaint was there wasn't any food to take home :)
“Fried chicken lollipops was 2 pieces for $11. Taste like regular baked chicken. Lacked flavor and nothing like a real fried chicken. Pork porterhouse tasted like sous vide and lacked any seasoning whatsoever. What is going on there!! Chef needs to step up his game.!!
Sat at the bar and had really great service AND great fish!
The food was delicious and we enjoyed our evening out. Particularly loved the sprouts and the rabbit pasta. The desserts were excellent.
This is by far one of our favorite restaurants in Montclair. I love that they change their menu according to the season, so you know you are getting the freshest ingredients available. Highly recommend it, the ambiance is really cool and the service is superb.
The food is amazing EVERY time I'm there!!! The menu changes often enough to keep me coming back, but there's also always something on the menu that seems familiar. Jason and his staff are TOP NOTCH!!
Group of 6 out to dinner. Everyone enjoyed their meals, some more than others. Overall very good food, great service, lovely ambiance
I rarely review a place unless I have something concrete to share. The ambiance is great, service was good, but I had two issues. A) I saw a mouse running against the wall and when I mentioned it to the waiter he nonchalantly said “ oh yeah it’s cold out once in a while that happens” I say no more about that. B) the main dish arrived and my boyfriend and I had the same dish and for both of us the pasta was super aldente to the point I found it not edibale, to be fair when I mentioned it to the waiter he took it back to cook it more but it was still pretty disappointing!
The service and food have gone downhill. The menu isn't as diverse and creative and theres much more cream dishes then healthy dishes now. Sauces were overdone and service was accommodating but slow.
We loved everything about Pig & Prince, from the setting in the beautifully restored Lackawanna Train Station building to the creative cocktails and cuisine to the friendly, knowledgeable service. These people clearly take great pride in what they do.
App recommendations: Tuna Poke, Sriracha Brussels Sprouts, and house-cured Prosciutto with Burrata, Blood Orange and Hazelnut Brittle. WOW!!
Our entrees were also all outstanding: Pork Bolognese, Filet Mignon [although the presentation was very unusual, so be sure to ask about it], and Pork Osso Bucco so huge that I took a good portion of it home.
The Donut Bread Pudding with Cinnamon Toast Crunch ice cream was as crazy delicious and decadent as it sounds!
Great atmosphere! Ordered the pork porterhouse and was cooked perfectly.
Chef Carrino and crew run a tight operation. Food was fresh and just the right portion, as well as expertly executed. Service was attentive but not intrusive. One of the best ambiance’s without doing to the city. Great job!
The atmosphere, food, and service were impeccable. The tuna poké appetizer with avacado mousse was delicious. My husband got the foiegras, chilled in a turine style, and he was in heaven. The main courses; cauliflower with sage gnocchi and seared tuna were not overly stated and light. To end our meal, I ordered the pumpkin cheesecake with cranberry coulee and my husband ordered the tres foimage. Perfect ending.
Amazing. This place deserves the accolades and press it received constantly. Pork osso bucco was delicious, my brother absolutely couldn't get enough of his pork porterhouse. Doughnut bread pudding with cinnamon toast crunch ice cream was outstanding. I can't wait for the next opportunity to have a meal here.
The food was good, but needs a bit more attention to detail in flavor. The foie gras torchon was under seasoned and lacked depth. Otherwise, what we ate was solid: pheasant risotto, beef tartare, pork bolognese. The cocktail program is strong and the drinks are well balanced: grounds for divorce and Mediterranean mule.
I haven’t been back in a couple years but the menu had drastically shrunk in size.
The food was for the most part bland or not seasoned. The gnocchi was like dry breads crumbs with a bunch of things tossed with it. Not high caliber. Something about the presentation... My friends pheasant rissoto didn't look appetizing. Didn't want to taste it and my cod with black rice could have used more seasoning, even salt. Never go back, except for the drinks. The cocktails were on the money!
The interiors are great and the food was very good!
Truly disappointed in this dining experience. The restaurant has a cool vibe and upon walking in we had high hopes. We chose a bottle of wine from the wine menu and we were read the specials. The waiter came back and told us that the bottle we wanted was not in stock so we picked another bottle. We took our time ordering our appetizers and food and one of us wanted to order one of the two specials presented earlier. We were told that special was no longer available. We waited almost an hour between the appetizers and the main course and when we asked where the food was our waiter said “he’s cooking now for the whole restaurant”. We were confused since isn’t that what is supposed to happen all the time in a restaurant? The chef cooks the food for everyone? Totally bizarre. The food arrived undercooked and tasteless and the bill was not cheap. I would not be returning to this restaurant nor would I recommend it to anyone.
Highly recommend Pig & Prince. I have been there 4 or 5 times and the food gets better each time. The menu changes each season so it's not the same old thing every time. I have head pork, chicken, fish and beef on my visits and every time my meal was prepared to perfection.
I found place to be dark and gloomy, although it had a charm. It was hard to read the menu it was that dark. Food was just ok, presentation was poor for $30 a plate, definitely overpriced, not worth the value. I had Gnocchi and it was just ok, nothing special, it says sage flavour but I didn’t find any of it in my dish, in fact it tastes like Trader’s Joe frozen gnocchi. Disappointed.
I had not been there in years, I had so many restaurants to choose from but did not want to go and gave yo bring my own.
The Waite staff was very cordial, the drinks retro over priced and the food, although only appetizers were not that
Great service, very attentive but not intrusive. The menu is quite original and the flavors were extraordinary. Definitely will go back!
The ambience and quality of food is very good. However, having the caramel pasta special that consisted of 12 stuffed pasta (like ziti) pieces topped with bolognese at $32, I was feeling ripped off. Granted, the server provided the prices of all the specials. It was just that at $32 I had expected more than what amounted to an appetizer-sized portion. I know a bolognese can consist of quite a few ingredients and a long cook, but what amounted to about 1-2 cups of sauce doesn't equate to the price paid. I would be surprised if others having the same dish didn't feel the same disappointment. Perhaps P&P will take note on future items.
I've been to P&P a few times and, really, this was the only negative experience. It won't prevent me from going back. Next time I'll be more prudent and order the burger!
I had ostrich, which is kind of hard-to-find! The cocktail selections were creative and tasty.
Some dishes were excellent and a few were just... weird. Combinations that just didn't belong together as if they were trying too hard to be innovative.
The cocktails, however, were excellent.
Amazing! What a great atmosphere. Food was outstanding.
All dressed up an nowhere to go? Head over to Pig & Prince for a great dining experience. Staff is friendly and helpful. Space is beautiful. Food is fabulous.
The Pig and Prince was recommended by a family member. Unfortunately, it fell far short of our expectations. The food was average. The service was poor. It certainly was not an experience worthy chancing a second attempt.
Lovely spot for an extra special dinner with friends. I had the Icelandic cod, my husband got an entree portion of the pheasant risotto, my daughter had the gnocchi and our friend had the petite filet. We were all very pleased.
Permanently Closed - Pig and Prince offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (973) 233-1006.
Permanently Closed - Pig and Prince is rated 4.2 stars by 667 OpenTable diners.