We proudly serve only Pureland Premium Black Angus Beef. Richly marbled for robust flavor then aged to tenderness perfection, it’s simply the finest available. We have many different seafood selections for you to choose from as well. Come & see for yourself what all the excitement in West Chester is about, especially at Pietro’s Prime.
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Contactless payment available
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Grilled Ahi Tuna Steak
Colossal crab meat, shrimp cocktail, tuna tartar, lobster claw cocktail
While I understand COVID has created staffing shortages, this was just bad. $50 cowboy ribeye cooked medium came out purple in the middle and the waiters response was “well this is how steakhouses do it”. The quality of the cut was Bolton shelf for. $50 steak.
We sat at the table (party of 5) for 20 minutes, only served water, waiter took 15 minutes more to bring bread and drinks. Would walk by ever 3 seconds but not to check in on us. Food took 55 minutes to come out. Took another 25 minutes to get a bottle of beer. It showed up as I was taking my late bite of the meal.
When the waiter finally came over to ask how our meal was, you know instead of a real steak house where they ask you to cut into the meat before the walk away, we were done. We said check please
$300 meal that would have tasted better in a diner for 1/4 of the cost.
Add this to my don’t go back there list
Btw, the pace was dead so being busy couldn’t be an excuse
This is medium steak btw.
If when referring to value you’re looking for lower prices Pietro’s Prime is not your place. The food is slightly higher priced but I will say I believe you get what you pay for. We have been there four or five times now and every time the service has been outstanding.
Food was fantastic. It was a little loud and not even full so I'm sure it cM get very loud.
First time there and will definitely be back! Our waiter Steven was awesome!
Another date night at Pietro’s. Great food and great service.
We had a wonderful lunch @ Pietro's Prime on a Saturday afternoon. Our server, Andrew, was delightful. The French Onion Soup was the BEST I've ever had... we will definitely be back.
Filet was very good, lobster bisque had too much of a tomato base
Noise level was terrible we couldn’t have a conversation at our table of three without yelling
The burrata cheese with roasted sun dried tomato pesto appetizer was so delicious. I recommend this restaurant to my friend and she loved it. We will definitely be back!
A little expensive for amount of food and quality. I asked for a filet to be hot pink center, so they put in med. plus... it came out med. rare. A good steakhouse needs to know how to cook their steaks properly. Caprese salad had tomatoes that weren’t up to par for being in season. I did enjoy the carrot cake. But probably will not return .
Delicious food! Very attentive service. Nice ambiance. Excellent experience all around…
Will enjoy going back soon!
Appetizers/food a bit slow to arrive but food was excellent and so were surroundings
Placed in the back room which is super bland.
Our waiter was outstanding!!!!
All good except steak was underwhelming.
Excellent food and service! The best steak I’ve ever had!
Outstanding service and food - a gem in the Borough of West Chester!
Had a great meal. Love eating here. Made an early reservation to have a quiet meal as one in our party has difficulty hearing in loud places. Which worked great to start, but it got noisy near the end of our meal as they filled up.
Food was excellent and came out hard and timely. Our waiter Andrew was exceptional. Highly recommend the bone in filet and also the PEI raspberry oysters were delicious! The only downside was the tables were pretty close to one another and they were out of the lump crab meat because it’s very difficult to get right now. My husband got a small lobster tail instead and it was cooked to perfection and very fresh. We will definitely be dining there again! The bar scene was hopping, we did not stop in, but it looks fun.
Great night out and great food
My first time here and it is my new favorite!! Everyone is so friendly! The food was just amazing! From the fried calamari and jumbo shrimp cocktail appetizers to the tiramisu at the end! We got the sliced filet and it was just amazing!! Kudos to the chef!
Always great food and service!
Great martini list, great regular menu and wonderful specials. Really good service.
We celebrated our mom’s 84th birthday together and every detail was outstanding! Thanks to our server Steven too who made us each feel like the guest of honor! Thank you, Pietros!
Overall good experience. Excellent service. Three out of four meals were very good, tuna steak was terrible. Most side dishes can be shared by two.
Nice meal at the bar.
The food was great, the service was terrific the noise level was awful.
Our server had to practically scream the specials to us and even then not all 4 of us could understand her.
Speaking to someone right next to me was also difficult. Sorry about this we’ve been here before with the noise was annoying but this time it was out of bounds
Think we’ll restrict visits in the future to outside seating
The entrees were delicious. The steak melted in your mouth. Pass on the tuna app. Drinks big and satisfying. Our waiter, very attentive and great sense of humor. Loved him! Live music!
Our server, Ski, was awesome... she really made the night nice!!
Obnoxiously loud table in the front room that drowned out every table in the dining room. We asked to be moved to the front bar window table just to get away from the noise, but it was reserved. Another table of 5 asked to be moved, and the rest of us at the other tables had to lean in or yell at each other, and lean over to hear our server Mike, and yell back just to be heard. Mike was great trying to work over and around the noise. We love Pietro’s but considering the noise level the last 2 times in last 3 weeks, we’ll have to reconsider Friday and Saturday nights at Pietro’s.
It would sincerely help if they invested in acoustic tiles for the ceiling!
Food was amazing, service was great. Wish there was more of a private room available to dine in. Space felt pack and, felt myself having to move and adjust a lot
Very good food and service. Recommend dining inside to avoid traffic noise as well as anyone smoking nearby.
We made the best of the birthday dinner for my husband. Service was very slow, as it appeared they were short staffed. Adult children and husband were hungry and the wait for dinner, let alone extra bread, did not sit well. Food did arrive hot but not impressed with portions. Room was boring and dated with zero ambiance. Overall, an average meal for an expensive price.
House signature ribeye was bone dry and extremely tough. For a very well revered steak house we were expecting phenomenal steaks, but these were probably the worst we’ve ever had in our lives. The appetizer and soups were really good, but for $200 for 2 people there is absolutely no reason we should have a subpar (at best) main course. Our experience was so off putting that I don’t think we will ever go back.
Absolutely fabulous! Thanks for an excellent birthday dinner. Enjoyed the bottle of Tapestry as well!
Amazing! I took my mom for her birthday, and everything was EXCELLENT!!! Fried calamari, the special salad of watermelon with mixed greens and feta cheese, mom got the Delmonico 18 oz steak, and I got the 12 oz special lobster tail!! We also ordered the onion rings, along with the steamed asparagus!! Every last bit of it was amazing!! Oh, and we also got a complimentary dessert for her birthday, and we chose the peanut butter pie...which as you can imagine, was EXCELLENT!!!! I don't think I will eat for the next 3 days!! I would HIGHLY recommend Pietro's Prime to anyone and everyone!!
The food and service was great however I was not expecting to have others seated so close to us, especially with Covid and in general, I wouldn’t want to sit that closely to someone. We should have asked to move but all the tables seemed close to each other.
Great dinner date at the bar!
Made 7:30 reservations. The couple in front of us were walk-ins who were seated right away, meanwhile we waited for 20 minutes to get seated (we arrived on time at 7:30). The wait staff must have been short handed. The waiter was really nice but didn't get our order in for drink for 30 minutes, our appetizers took an hour, and they kept forgetting the bread which came at the end of the meal instead of when we sat down. For the price of Pietro's, whose food is always amazing, the service was not worth the spend.
We LOVE Pietros. Everything about it is awesome: the food, ambiance, service. We really enjoy eating here.
Food and service was amazing as always! Thank you Lauren for great drink and thanks to Gabriel for awesome table service…
Went to PPs to celebrate our 48th wedding anniversary. PPs did not disappoint. Except for the somewhat loud music, everything was perfect. Would highly recommend.
Pietro's Prime offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (484) 760-6100.
Pietro's Prime is rated 4.5 stars by 2038 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.