Peter Shields Inn

Had an extremely enjoyable dinner off pre fixe menu. The blackened Mshi Mahi was exquisite, presentation from appetizer to dessert was awesome. Server RJ was very attentive and professional. One of our favorite places to dine.

Really good experience. The food is unbeatable and service is attentive and professional. We were greeted with a smile and seated quickly once we arrived. Our waiter did his best to you understand and meet our dietary needs

With that said the restaurant itself needs to be updated. From the outside the restaurant looks beautiful. The inside is a different story. Our table was really unsteady and the wallpaper was in noticeably poor condition

Food was very good. Service was pleasant and good but slow. One particular server was making such a fuss over my spouse that it became awkward and annoying. Staff was just off that night. But the food is always excellent. We love it here.

Great night as always. One of the best restaurants in Cape May. RJ is our favorite waiter . Great guy and top notch service !

Great birthday dinner for my wife. We have done it every year for the last 10 and it seems to get better every year.

Excellent, excellent all the way. Loved it, cannot wait to go back. Hope it stays BYO, helps with the cost.

Great atmosphere for an upscale dining experience. Service was top notch, for the most part, same with the food. Would definitely go back and recommend to friends.

Always wonderful experience at PSI. Food and service

We enjoyed the winter Prix Fixe menu. Our waiter was incredible and the food was delicious. Highly recommend

We had our favorite server, Peter. ..excellent! Loved the harp player. Food was delicious. Wonderful birthday evening! Always recommend to our friends.

It is always a pleasure to eat at the Peter Shields. Wonderful food and service. Great atmosphere.

Awesome totally awesome.

Excellent service, beautiful view, superb food - the perfect way to celebrate!

Could not have been better. Loved the food and our waiter was perfect. Can’t wait to go back.

Great dinner and perfect evening.
Highly recommend

Always excellent!
Great/Perfect place to celebrate our 35th anniversary!
Thank you PS!

Always a wonderful experience! It is the best place we have eaten in Cape May. A little pricy but worth the extravagance. Each dish is presented well The salmon and veal dishes were exceptional as was the pasta. The service was also great!

Food was good portions were very small for the money they are charging

The experience was awesome. Great service from Dylan. Desserts were phenomenal. Sauces were sublime. Flavors exceptional.

Most elegant dinner in Cape May. We did the winter special. The food is amazing. Can’t wait to return.

Never disappoints!! Excellent food and friendly service. Perfect for a special occasion.

We've always had good experiences at Peter Shields. On this occasion we went for the 'prix fixe' - three courses for $33. Exceptional food for the price, everything we chose was first class. Our entrees, Mahi-mahi and pork osso buco, were both delicious and beautifully presented. Service friendly and prompt. Try it!

Had the winter prix fixed menu. One of my favorite meals ever

Peter Shields never dissapoints. Everything is elegant and delicious. Always enjoy our time there.

Great food and service. Bring your own wine.
Food fantastic

My wife and I love Peter Shields.
The finest BYOB on the Island.
And Chris is the best.

Unbelievable food and outstanding, attentive staff, with appropriately subdued "Happy Birthday" played on the piano. Perfect birthday experience with family.

Usually a 5+ experience. This time my wife and I thought it was good, but not great. Server had zero personality which never helps. I’m sure we’ll be back, but we both left a little disappointed.

Our favorite place in cape May, by far! Consistently excellent every visit!

Truly amazing dining experience in Cape May! Spectacular food, great service in a beautiful classic setting!

Our regular server, Petar, was his normal sensational. My grilled octopus appetizer was superb as was my wife’s buratta salad. The special strip steak was beyond expectations. As always PSI was their normal excellent

Awesome anniversary dinner - elegant, beautiful and delicious!

My favorite place always fabulous. Was excellent, our server RJ was excellent.

We never have a bad meal here. The service and ambiance is awesome!

The food was absolutely incredible. I had the lamb duo which was delicious and cooked to perfection. The desserts were good as well. The service was outstanding; attentive, knowledgable, and friendly. Another diner had the short rib and raced about it. The restaurant is BYOB and they will open and chill your wine if needed.

Delightful. Accommodated my vegetarian request without batting an eye. It’s a very comfortable, sweet place!

$28 for six tiny oysters?

PSI is a beautiful Inn. My husband and I are locals however this was our first dining experience at PSI, our hopes were high. Unfortunately, PSI missed its mark. The service was very nice and the menu selection was exciting however the taste left quite a bit to be desired. The octopus appetizer was good but not great, as it was very chewy. My husbands green salad was nice but what you would expect. I had the salmon, very good and my husbands duck was the same. We both ordered dessert. My husbands toffee pudding was actually a muffin, literally a muffin & mine was a lemon bar which was lemon curd that had way too much gelatin and was quite rubbery- neither were nearly sweet enough. Our server did ask us how our meal was & we graciously replied fine however there was no follow up from a manager or server thereafter. We brought our own wine. Our meal was $177 before tip which is quite a lot for just a mediocre dinner. Unfortunately we won’t return to PSI but definitely will continue to experience other restaurants in Cape May.

Price fix meal was outstanding value!!

food was very good, portions were a little small for the $$$, our waitress was great!!! she provided excellent service!