We were seated early for our reservation but had to wait over 10-15 minutes for our drink order to be delivered. Glass of wine and a martini.
Food was wonderful but service was lacking.
Delicious food, great service, prices are reasonable. My only complaint is that the restaurant is very loud.
Terrific food and incredible service. Perfect spot to go before a show at the 5th Ave Theater!
Fantastic food and service! The half price bottles of wine on Wednesday was a very pleasant surprise! Will definitely make a return trip.
Very nice visually and the food was great. However, even though I told the server (and he told the chef) that I cannot eat gluten or dairy, the dish came out with cheese on top. Staff then removed that dish and I instead ordered a salad which was very delish! Server was great - attentive but not overly soon.
Palomino does a decent lunch over at the express side, but the sit down side is okay at best. The kids menu salmon could be a great value if it was cooked all the way - come on it is for kids! I’m pretty sure the spaghetti sauce was from a can! My girls wouldn’t touch it after taking a few bites. Good thing the bread was free refills. My steelhead was okay but drenched in so weird sauce. Overall go elsewhere. My girls wanted spaghetti but unfortunately they got chef boy r dee!
The location is perfect which is why this place is always full with plenty of customers. We came before a show and liked how close it was to the theatre. Our waiter was great and took our order pretty quickly. They then had other servers bring the meal which allows the food to get served quickly and not dependent on the waiter who is busy tending to other customers. The actual food was just fair (beet salad had minimal beets, dressing, pistachios but tons of greens that were way to big for single mouthful. The stuffed sole was just okay, not much flavor and the texture was somewhat dry and mushy all at the same time). Overall good location with good service. If they could get the food right it would be worth coming to when not going to a show.
My Mom was celebrating her 80th birthday--they treated her like a queen!! Great service, Great Food, Great fun!!
Excellent server. Great prices and food. Manager stops by tables. Perfect before eve and afternoon theatre. Great HH and parking is validated free.
The server was great. The ambiance is nice. Not our first time here but had been a while. Our appetizers, the meatballs were still fridge cold. They were nice and took them back and gave us fresh ones. They were also nice to take them off the bill. The 2nd batch was also cold. Didn’t complain, we just sucked it up and ate them.
One friend never received his Caesar and was still on the bill. Two of us ordered the special which was the pork chop. No taste, dry and chewy. He left most of his. We didn’t complain as we had a show to catch.
Overall it was a bad dining experience. After spending over $309 with our group, we won’t be going back. NOT WORTH IT!
Always a great experience
Fantastic experience. Delicious food and great service.
Really great service. Everyone was very friendly and our waitress was a great help in making suggestions for our meal selection.
We were late but the staff was kind and able to accommodate our reservation. Waitress was kind and while efficient dinner make us feel rushed!
This is the stable of our pre-theatre experience. I recommend this establishment without any hesitation. The food is excellent with the service attentive but not intrusive.
This was my first time at Palomino. The food was delicious, but the service wasn’t the best. Our waiter offered my friend 3 refills of soda but didn’t once offer me a refill of mine. Also, he spilled sugar all over my arm and hair when prepping the donuts tableside. Not sure what I did to deserve this subpar treatment. The only difference between me and my friend is that she’s white and I’m Filipino. I want to believe that this was an isolated incident. Perhaps he just needs to check his implicit bias.
Great food & exceptional service. Very timely for theater reservations.
Excellent dinner and service. We met some friends for dinner before the theater. Lovely time.
Great spot for our Friday team lunches. The tables are big and round, so everyone can socialize. The food is good, has options for everyone including vegetarians. Service is friendly and quick.
Food arrived at different times, and arrived tepid in temperature, and way too expensive. Sorry, but we will not be back.