Place was fantastic! Service great, food some of the best we’ve had. Highly recommend!
Really surprised how good this was. Terrific food, especially the mushroom soup and Chop Chop salad, which has improved a lot since our last visit. Great service and fast kitchen delivery. Really nice dinner. Well done.
Excellent! The entrees were especially good. Great downtown location, bar area and dining room. Service and pace of meal were perfect.
Loved Palomino. Especially for a special occasion. Seems like the old fashioned supper club atmosphere.
Our server was attentive and very friendly. The food was delicious.
Arrived at 6:15,which we thought was plenty of time to catch an 8:00 show. The service was slow and our food did not arrive until 7:30 which required us to eat in about 10 minutes. We had two couples so two bills which were calculated incorrectly but did not have time to correct. Food was good, but disappointed overall.
Dinner before Eagles Concert. Good service and all 4 of us enjoyed our meals. Great Crème Brule . Noticed that the food has improved over our last visit. Place was full but we were pleased how we were to get in and out on a timely basis. It is an old stand by for our Colts games.
I chose this restaurant for its proximity to the Hyatt Regency and the IRT. We saw a play about Venice Italy and then had a wonderful Italian dinner. Our 2 friends joined us to celebrate my wife's birthday that was recognized nicely by the restaurant staff with a complimentary ice cream dessert. We enjoyed the mussels and clams and I had the Paella for the entree. It was the second best paella I've ever had. We had cocktails and our friends joined in with wine and beer. My Old Fashioned bourbon cocktail was the best ever!
Everyone enjoyed all their choices. No complaints, only compliments were shared.
Very enjoyable and satisfactory in every category. Service was attentive without being intrusive.
Pleasant dining experience with friends, good food, good wine.
Service was ok, not great. Felt pushed to get out of there. Not because they were busy, but maybe because it was empty.
This was our second time here. I thought it was interesting that when I tried to make reservations it would only let me do the 7:15 time and nothing later but when we got to the restaurant there were lots of empty tables the entire time we were there. So not sure what that was about. Our server was excellent and our food was good.
We went to Palomino because it is one the best Italian restaurant`s in the Midwest in our opinion. The staff is always friendly when you go, the wait staff is very kind, the kitchen staff is amazing, and the food is outstanding. It is defiantly a place I would recommend if you are going out on a date, an anniversary date, or just a casual night out.
Excellent from start to finish! Food and service was outstanding! Brittany was our server and she did a wonderful job.
Good food below average portions great service
Our server was outstanding and so was the food!
We came in during lunch service so it was quiet. Food and service was great! Thanks to the kitchen staff. The mushroom soup was great, both tiramisu and lemon sorbet that we had was absolutely delicious!
Outstanding, we’ll be back!
Great experience! We were in town for a convention and had a reservation for 7pm for a group of 10. We were seated promptly upon arrival and received excellent customer service the entire night. There was a great variety of menu options and the food was fantastic and served fresh. I loved the rotisserie chicken and the mushroom soup. The restaurant had great ambiance and was very clean. I would recommend for anyone for date night, for a business meeting, or for any size group. I will definitely eat at Palomino again.
The service was very slow. The food was very good , but none of our steaks were hot . One of my guest received his dinner entree a full 10 minutes after the rest of us .
Only complaint they forgot to substitute a few of our potato dishes.
Service was a little slow but it seemed there was only one waitress for a few tables. On a positive note there seemed to be several managers and team members helping her with food delivery, water refills etc so our food was hot and we did not need for much. We also were a relaxed group so I imagine that didn’t read as though we were trying to be mindful of the lunch hour.
We have dined at Palamino's many times. This is the first time we have been disappointed in the meal. Service was great and attentive.
We had a great meal at Palomino. They had great daily and weekly meal specials/featured dishes. My favorite part of my meal was the prawns. They are incredibly delicious. My only complaint was that my steak was slightly over cooked, and was a bit charred on the outside. Other than that, it was delicious.
Amazing food, Outstanding service! Will definitely go back.
Went for my husband's birthday and we had a very nice and relaxed meal. Food was great, service couldn't have been better!
The food and service was outstanding!!
Didn’t realize it was a limited Valentine’s Day menu with a fixed price but the Steak, Lobster, and Shrimp combo was very very good. Their bruschetta is fire.
The croutons on the caesar salad were as hard as rocks & I could not eat them. The dessert that consisted basically of deep fried doughnut holes was mediocre. The steak was flavorless but tender, however the the lobster tail, prawns, & vegetables were outstanding. This Valentine menu was not up to the standard of the Thanksgiving menu.
First Valentines Together so we chose a Palomino’s a a nice quiet “romantic” place for a first of many.
Reservation was on time, food was as expected and service was good
We always come back for more. Some other places, you'll occasionally get bad service or so-so food, but this place is always good, with attentive and reliable servers. We will keep coming back.
We did the lunch combo! What a bang for your buck! The food was incredible and great portion sizes. It was quick for lunch. The service was a little lackluster but I think it was just because we were the first table of the morning.
Appetizer/crackers burnt, steak full of gristle. Brought out new crackers for dip when we complained- they were oily. Comp'd steak and dessert for all of us to make up lacking food. Server was attentive and did her best.
Tyler, our server, was outstanding and the food was delicious. The Devour Indy menu was really nice.
My husband had a great birthday celebration at Palomino!
Treating my dad to lunch after he spent the night at my mom's beside as she is recovering from meningitis. Sarah B. Was our server and a pleasure
Service was exceptional!!!
Palomino has been one of my favorite restaurants for year. Sadly, with our most recent visit on 1/28/18, I can truly say, it ain't what it used to be.
We were seated in a cozy booth near the back of the restaurant. To our right was a wooden shelf that ran the length of the wall. This shelf was so dusty that we were able to, as others had, write a message to one that might care, to "Please dust me!"
Our server did not speak English very well. He would ask if we were ok, and then walk away before we could respond. He had two tables with six people each, so, once those tables took off, we really didn't see him again, except to get the bill. We were lacking for refills of tea and lemonade.
My spouse got the braised short-rib and the accompanying asparagus was absolutely blackened. Please note that the MANGER brought the meal out that way and did not say two words about it. I got the Ragu Carne and there was a pitiful amount of beef and the noodles were overcooked and glued together.
Our server did not return until he came with the check and asked if everything was ok. We told him about the asparagus, but did not offer a replacement, or to reduce the bill for the inedible food.
Palomino isn't an inexpensive place to eat, and there is nothing worse than paying a lot for a terrible meal. We probably won't be back any time soon, unless I hear that things have taken a turn for the better.
After debating on whether to say something to the manager, we decided against it, since she had brought out the food as it was, so if she wasn't taking notice, then it was unlikely anything further would happen.
In addition, it was a very slow evening, so there was plenty of time that the manager could have walked around and checked on tables.
Table of 3 took 2.75 hours to finish our meal
Service was quite slow
Told the gelato we ordered was peppermint but said sorry here is chocolate as well
Ok night just nothing special