As usual, the food was excellent and the service very professional. We have never been disappointed at Oyster Bay!
The food was excellent. The atmosphere was inviting. The bar area was vibrant. The cocktails were very good. The prices are a little high, but we are not in Cape May very often so it's worth it.
We were in town for a ladies retreat and decided to give Oyster Bay a try. We were not disappointed !
Our meal was delicious. Tried roasted duck breast with asparagus and mashed sweet potatoes. The glaze was a special touch. I definitely plan a return visit!
It was our first time and we will definitely be back. We were in the restaurant not the bar area but that looked like a happening place. Food was outstanding- cooked to perfection. Our waiter was excellent.
Always a great meal. Awesome food and awesome service and not so loud like most other restaurants I’ve been to
The atmosphere was very nice and cozy. We ordered the shrimp cocktail for our app and they did not clean the shrimp. This made me worry about our main course. Overall the main course was good however, my husband ordered his steak medium and it can’t out basically raw. We are not ones to complain so we did not. The service was very good. Parking was horrible!
Great food and atmosphere. My husband had the salmon special, it was very good and well seasoned. Everything was delicious with the exception of the crab cake which tasted a bit storebought and creamy texture rather than a lump crab cake. All other dishes including the mango marscapone dessert and shrimp appetizer were exceptional. Would highly recommend
Great vibe, had the oyster sliders which were delicious, just a fun place to be casual and have some apps and a drink
Ambiance, menu selection, food and service all great. Parking lot is a whole different story. It is undersized, unpaved, unlined and underlit. It is full of deep potholes and mud puddles. Count yourself lucky if you get out without a sprained ankle or a damaged vehicle. Worth dining here but park elsewhere.
We always enjoy our meals at Oyster Bay. The atmosphere is cozy and the food is delicious!
Oyster Bay is one of our favorite restaurants . My husband and I had a wonderful Valentine's celebration dinner. We both had appetizers and fish specials of the night. Everything was delicious and the staff made it a perfect evening.
Excellent have never have been disappointed . Great service and food.
Everything was excellent. Always enjoy going there. Selection changes from time to time but is always good. If you have never tried it you must put it on you short list.
The food is the best in Cape May. Owner/Hostess very nice person. Guest are treated like royalty..
Great food, even better service. We were lucky enough to have our favorite server, Mary, again! Oyster Bay has never disappointed!
Last two times we’ve visited Oyster Bay, the food was subpar. Menu is fairly limited so you’d assume everything would taste great but that has not been the case. My husband had chicken pasta dish and chicken didn’t seem thoroughly cooked. I ordered the filet mignon and crab dish noted on menu as a “20 year staple” and it was uneventful. Desserts were good though! We love the vibe and location so we hope Oyster Bay steps up their game a bit.
The overall experience was very very good. We had a reservation and they sat us right away upon arrival. The server was very pleasant and helpful with the menu. I had a spicy shrimp and eggplant appetizer that was delicious. I kept the theme spicy and went for the Cajun seafood over linguini. Everything was perfect. Restaurant was quaint and very nicely decorated. I would highly recommend this restaurant.
We had eaten at the bar before - too crowded and noisy for us. Restaurant was excellent - service, food, and decor. We'll be back.
Can count on a good meal here Year round. Specials are creative and tasty. Thank you!
Made reservation for after the Christmas Tree lighting in Cape May. Arrived early and decided, with the hostess ok, to sit at the Bar. We love to eat at the bar. The bartenders are very attentive and they all check on you to see if you need anything. We can have the full menu there plus a look at the bar menu too. We had the crusted grouper and enjoyed every bit! We came back the next night and had The calamari and the cheeseburger flatbread and of course desert both nights. Love it here!
Great food..nice ambiance...a little pricey though...
Always a perfect meal at this restaurant. Very friendly staff.
Steve was a terrific attentive server and we thanks him for his work.
The parking was impossible the night we were there. Some spots should be reserved for diners; it seemed like most must have been taken up by bar patrons.
The calamari was the best I've ever had. We enjoyed our meals. We will definitely be back.
Service was lacking sat at table first no one came for 10 minutes so we went to bar area. Was still slow to get acknowledged but one we did service was very good. Excellent apps
Awesome food. Very reasonably priced. I had the sweet potato risotto.
It would have been nice if they read the special note to put a candle on whatever dessert was ordered. I had to ask in front of the birthday recipient.
Seated right away in this attractive restaurant. Food and service was excellent
Everything from the apps to dessert was really excellent. Waitress was prompt and efficient. We will definitely return.
This is the second time we've dining here and both times have had superb food and excellent service. Seating is spacious so you can have quiet conversation. Menu is fairly diverse with good selections. Prices are moderate. Staff and management are very friendly.
Went for a 92nd birthday celebration.... great access, staff was awesome and the food was very good! Our compliments to the chef!
Oyster Bay never ceases to please us. We've been there about a half-dozen times, and it's our favorite restaurant in both Cape May and anywhere. The food is wonderfully prepared and seasoned to perfection, and the ambiance is welcoming. The drinks are also expertly created and always tasty as well. From the warm smile of the Hostess, to the friendly and cheerful attitude of the Waitstaff, we always feel at home when we visit there.
We had our anniversary dinner here, and we would go back again, good service, good cocktails, good food!!
Great meal this was our second time eating here and our meal and service were outstanding Would definitely return and reccomend this restaurant.
Although I come to Cape May several times a year, this was my first time to Oyster Bay Steak and Seafood. The art in the front dining room was beautiful. The specials were very nice...the Oysters were awesome. And my steak cooked to perfection. This restaurant is a hit.
Food was very good except for my risotto which was runny.
My husband really enjoyed his duck I had a steak which was good not great. Very noisy and hard to hear one another speak. Service was good
We always like to make a visit to Oyster Bay when we are in Cape May. I was slightly disappointed in my meal this time. My husband had gotten a special, and I had gotten a filet mignon. When our dinner came out his was piping hot, unfortunately mine was slightly warm. I never send anything back, don't know what goes on in the kitchen. I couldn't finish my steak because it actually got cold. Needless to say I wasn't too thrilled with my dinner. We will go back and try it again, maybe it was just a hiccup in service.
Wonderful food. Great dinner. Both of us ordered surf and turf and it was wonderful. Made a reservation and table was ready upon arrival. Very classy but comfortable restaurant.
One of the best meals I have had in cape May. Great place, Great atmosphere and all folks were fantastic.