Oyster Bay Steak and Seafood
Oyster Bay continues to be one of the best restaurants in Cape May. I recommend Oyster Bay for drinks, bar atmosphere, apps, sandwiches and dinner!!!!!!!
Steve the waiter was exceptional. From moment we sat to the moment we were done he made sure that we were enjoying our meal. The food is very good I had the porter house veal chop and my husband had the seafood Calabrese. I would recommend having a meal there when your vacationing in Cape May
Great attended service from the hostess when you walk in to ordering your dessert and coffee.
I have to say, one of the best roast beef sandwiches I’ve ever had.
Food outstanding and service attentive and quick. Would definitely return.
Great food at reasonable prices. Good service. Location is in the middle of town
Had a wonderful dinner with my mother and sister. Our server Joanne was amazing. She was attentive, informative and gave us great service. The food was delicious as always. We never have a bad meal here!
Wonderful, comfortable atmosphere with outstanding food. Have been coming to Cape May for over 30 years and never had the opportunity to dine here. Told our server we would be back again this year and multiple times in years to come. Everything sounded yummy but we had the salmon and grouper dishes which were excellent. You will not be disappointed!!!
Exce!lent fish of the day specials, generous portions, great drinks, delicious like mousse dessert and creme brule with fruit.
We had reservations for 5:30 and we arrived early and were seated right away. The waitress was very good with presenting the specials and her service was exceptional. This is our new go to place when in the Wildwood/Cape May area. The food and drinks were outstanding!
Great veal and service was good
We were on a week long vacation and decided to have a nice dinner with our family. The food was excellent, something to appeal to everyone. We had the oysters Rockefeller for an appetizer and they were amazing.Our server was delightful too.
Food was amazing,staff was attentive but not overly so. We all loved our food. Highly recommend
Very disappointed with our server, who was not friendly and had an attitude. Food was ok, although my husband's crab cakes were better than my seafood pasta dish which had no flavor in the sauce-tasted liked it was just the water the pasta was cooked in... Very bland.
The menu is not available online we were told, although I had a menu that said it was their's from Trip Advisor???
Best restaurant in Cape May, hands down. Best service and steaks u can cut with a fork.
We dine here often, more in the off season to ensure access. Typically we eat in the back bar area, but decided to make a reservation and sit in one of the dining rooms. Food is consistently good. My pan fried crusted grouper was cooked just right (not over done), and my wife's fried tomatoes with crab and dinner salad was fresh and tasty. Service was earnest, friendly and, best of all, prompt.
Oyster Bay is not a "find" for us, but since we eat here so frequently I thought I would (finally) post a review.
This used to be a favorite of ours but our recent dinner was a major disappointment. My salad was drowned in dressing to the extent the spinach looked wilted. The server gladly exchanged it. But the chicken with crabmeat had the same issue: the crabmeat was again drowned in hollandaise sauce to the point that I couldn’t taste the crabmeat at all. And the chicken was over cooked.
So in spite of good wine and service, we won’t be returning.
Great experience! Great food & service, will definitely return!
Just a dinner with fsmily
We have eaten there before in the past when we visit Cape May the food is always great . The only problem was with parking but we were seated as soon as we arrived,so as not to go over with parking limit time.
When in Cape May we always try to dine here. Great Grouper which is why we go there.
I have been going to Oyster Bay for many years and have always found the food delicious and the waitstaff friendly, knowledgeable and efficient. The dirty martinis are excellent. I would highly recommend Oyster Bay for an awesome night out.
This was our first time at the restaurant and we really enjoyed it. My husband and I were down for a long weekend and the hostess was kind enough to take our picture together. Food, service and atmosphere are great!
My wife and I have been visiting Cape May for nearly 25 years but this was our first time dining at Oyster Bay. Both seafood and steak dishes were excellent. Service was friendly and timely. We will definitely make a return visit during our next trip to Cape May.
Waitress was very pleasant food was good and served on a timely basis. Conversation was alittle difficult as you had to talk loud to be heard
Great bang bang shrimp for our appetizer,surf and turf for dinner and don’t forget chocolate cake for dessert with coffee. YUM!!
Great food great service. Nothing negative to say.
Oysters Rockefeller ok; swordfish was very good — shrimp were a nice addition. Filet with crabmeat was good. Service fine, a bit detached. Wines by the glass, eh. Casual atmosphere, one notch above Bennigans.
This is our new favorite place in Cape May, we enjoy the comfortable atmosphere and the wait staff is always pleasent. The special grouper is my favorite! They have a great menu and delectible drink menu. Can't wait to return.
Oyster Bay always has great food, drinks, and service. Before the season gets hectic, you can usually find parking behind the restaurant. The servers are attentive and friendly, and the portions are very large. We always enjoy going here!
Too many ill behaved kids and poor parental guidance distracting from an enjoyable Father’s Day dinner. Food was average + and service was above average. Not a complete fail, but I will think twice before returning.
Nothing special. Didn’t like the coconut shrimp at all. Outback Steakhouse beats your meal. How sad. Inside very old. Bathroom felt like 90 degrees. We will not be back
Friendly, busy place with good seafood & service. Even when it looked full, they were able to find us a table for two fairly quickly.
Will go back. Celebrated 38th Anniversary. Service was very good & meals were excellent. Overall very nice experience.
Excellent service accompanied by superb food. Every aspect of our dining experience was exceptional. Great value, great food, great atmosphere. Who could ask for more. Our family returns every year and we have never been disappointed. Highly recommend Oyster Bay to all who love succulent steak and seafood.
We meet friends at Oyster Bay once a year because they insist on Oyster Bay. This is the third consecutive year. My main issue with Oyster Bay is that the food is inconsistent and mediocre. The first year i had crab cakes which were very bad. I only ate one of the two. Lots of filler and poor taste. The past 2 years i have had london broil, the first year it was decent, 4 stars, this year only 2 starts because, even though it was cooked medium, it was tough and not very tasty.
I made reservations for 8pm with my husband to celebrate our 11th wedding anniversary. We were about 15 minutes behind schedule but our table was ready when we arrived. The hostess was lovely and seated me right away while my husband parked the car. The waiter was great and very knowledgeable of the menu. I ordered the Grouper with red bliss potatoes and vegetables. The grouper was light and flaky and the sauce was delicious. My husband ordered the steak and mashed potatoes. Steak was cooked as requested and he enjoyed every bite. We had a lovely evening and will definitely recommend this place to friends.
This is one of my favorite restaurants in Cape May. You always get amazing food and service. We have been going there for years.
Food was delicious. The only reason I gave 4 stars was hardly any pasta!! Got clams and linguine; delicious but no pasta! 2 of us got the same dish! Same issue.
Excellent, fresh, and well prepared seafood. Service was excellent and nice atmosphere. Would definitely return on my next trip to Cape May.