Oyster Bay Steak and Seafood
Crab cakes were outstanding
Overall food was delicious
My husband and I enjoyed everything about this restaurant. It was our first time here and we were pleasantly surprised. Our waiter was very attentive and very well experienced. The owner of the restaurant came over to our table to make sure we were happy with the service and food. Speaking of the food, it was outstanding! I highly recommend Oyster Bay and we will definitely be back!
Absolutely, FABULOUS ! We ordered all of our favorites. The oysters rockefeller is so yummy and the encrusted grouper is the Best in town. The salmon special melted in your mouth. Ordered Boston Cream Pie for the first time. What a delicious treat that was. Thank you , Gerry , for making my birthday celebration special.
Excellent food and service. Will return next time we are in the area.
Oyster Bay jambalaya was excellent and I don't care for scallops. Cooked well ad seasoning was spicy but not fire breathing. Veal San Marco was beautifully done for my missus and if that was the last banana desert I'm allowed to have, I can think of no better one than your bananas foster.
The London broil was tough and chewy. The drinks were good.
On our annual vacation at Cape May and we always have at least one evening meal every year. Food is always delicious and service is great!
We enjoyed dinner with my family and had a good experience. Parking was easy , we were seated promptly with our reservation. The noise level was a little more than I like but not bad. Our service was good. And two of our 3 meals were delicious. The 3rd was just ok. We had dessert and coffee which were good. For the price ,our meal was good but slightly underwhelming. The staff were all very nice though.
Excellent service, varied menu and reasonable prices. This was our second visit and the Broiled Scallops and Seafood Jambalaya were as good as we remember them from last year. This restaurant will become our go-to place in Cape May.
32 wedding anniversary
The food was excellent! As was the service. Very quiet and a lovely restaurant. Must try the whipped cheesecake with bananas foster. Delicious!
Steve was our server for table of four. Very attentive, even though restaurant was short staffed. I had the seafood pot pie…excellent, and my husband had the duck and loved it. Loved the atmosphere and the food selection was very good. We will definitely be back!
Very nice staff and good food
A perfect night and I thoroughly enjoyed my salmon. My friend got the seafood pot pie and he said it was outstanding. I look forward to going back again
Outstanding food here on the final night. We tried many restaurants but this was our favorite in Cape May.
This is one of our go to stops in Cape May
We had a truly wonderful dining experience. The food was excellent and our service was exceptional. Our server, Avery, took great care to surprise our mom on her 75th birthday with a spectacular bananas foster cheesecake. We dine at Oyster Bay every time we visit Cape May; the food is consistently delicious!
Great meal! Service was excellent. We sat outside, which we prefer. Menu specials sounded fantastic. We started with the burrata app, which was brimming with roasted peppers and tomatoes as well as a big ball of burrata all drizzled with balsamic glaze. Also had a swordfish special and crab cakes—both delicious.
First time trying but certainly not the last. Great variety on menu. Especially loved the long hots and the grouper with sausage/bread crumb topping. The taste of the fish and sausage really made the fish stand out. Best fish dish I have ever had! Filet was cooked to perfection. The veal was also very tasty. For dessert the bananas foster cheesecake was delicious and so airy. Our only regret is not having tried here years ago. Staff very friendly and attentive.
Tables too close together and noise level made conversation difficult
Really enjoyed it. All the food was really good. Plan to return & try the bar menu as well.
The veal was cooked in old oil and tasted sour. Not what I expected. Others enjoyed their meals. Dessert was amazing.
Great food and service ! Thank you
I recommend this restaurant. Steve was fabulously as was the rest of the staff. Very attentive. We would return . It was our first night back to Cape May and we were so pleased.
Overall we liked the food my dinner was a little bland I usually don’t have to use salt but I had too. Waitress was great and they took us before our reservation. Would probably go back!
This is the place we take out of town guests to impress them with all that CapeMay has to offer. The food is amazing, We all got the grouper….wow, were they impressed with it all. The guys loved the bar while we shopped. Truly the best of both worlds, great bar, great food….this is our go-to!
We had some delicious appetizers and drinks. We ate outside in the front and it was a little noisy, but not too bad. We enjoyed the food and our waiter, Rick, was super friendly and accommodating. Would eat here again.
The food and service was excellent but the tables were a bit too close.
This restaurant was far overrated based on the food. We had a good waiter who was very accommodating, but there was not much else that stood out. Weak drinks and the food is really on par with a Red Lobster. Extremely overpriced for mediocre food and drinks.
Oyster Bay never disappoints. Their grouper is wonderful and the Key Lime Mousse is amazing and perfect for sharing.
The dining rooms are spacious and the decor is lovely.
Friendly staff, great food. The bananas foster cheesecake dessert is to die for. I mean it’s like the best dessert on the planet. Whipped cream cheesecake (their own special recipe) with bananas foster on it. This alone is worth the trip to the restaurant. Our waitress was friendly and helpful and made us feel welcome. It’s just a great place for a special dinner.
The wait service was not to friendly and I felt rushed.
My husband and I eat at Oyster Bay every visit to Cape May. We love the happy hour at the bar and then go into the dining room for dinner. The food is exceptional at a fair price. The service very good and the servers are pleasant and helpful. Wed can't wait to go again!
Crusted grouper was the best we have ever had!
This is my 2nd visit to Oyster Bay. Food & service always good.
A tourist trap! They have a lot of nerve charging the prices they do for the food they serve. Our appetizer, "Bang, Bang Shrimp" was so bad we couldn't eat it. Our server did, however, take it off our bill which was the least she could do. The main courses were edible thanks to the fresh fish, but not finely prepared in the least. Needless to say we skipped dessert.
Food was very good with really good service. Drinks were very good.
Oyster Bay never disappoints us. We always have an excellent meal. the people are so friendly. Great atmosphere, and food is always consistent. Couldn't ask for more!
Our party of 4 had a reservation for 7:30. We arrived early and we were seated with no wait. The service was great and all four of our meals were excellent. My only complaint was I saved no room for dessert, and the desserts sounded amazing!
Oyster Bay Steak and Seafood is rated 4.5 stars by 1352 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.