Fantastic Food Fantastic Experience!

Don't miss this gem. Great atmosphere and cuisine.

Food was amazing, Gilbert is fantastic as the owner and Wilnaj is above excellent as server as is all of the staff!!

Amazing experience, service, and food! Was the highlight of our trip. Highly recommend.

Terrific staff and excellent food

Rafael was an excellent manager and host. This place does not stick to just the usual Italian pasta offerings - the creative and well-prepared food was incredible.

Our server Christian was hands down the BEST server we’ve ever had! He was knowledgeable and polite, made our experience there! Food was delicious too!

Great food, service and ambiance.

Superb quality preserved over many years

We have been eating here for over 20 years and it never disappoints!! Thank you Gilbert and team for all your hard work, attention to detail and quality!

I had enjoyed this restaurant years ago on a business trip and was pleased to discover it every bit as good.

Best Italian on Miami Beach! The new space is amazing!!

We started off at the bar for a happy hour drink. The bartender and cocktails were great. We then got seated food and staff were fabulous. It was our anniversary the staff brought over a complimentary piece of Taramusu and
About 8 staff members sang to us. I will absolutely go back.

Food is delicious. Homemade Italian food like I remember as a child. Servers are excellent.

Very good service, the staff was engaging, friendly, and attentive. The food was authentic and we enjoyed everything that was served, including the delicious homemade pasta and desserts.

Hands down the best meal we had on Miami Beach bar none. Fantastic food, fantastic service, a Magician that was AGT worthy, super ambiance, just a pure pleasure to dine at.

Absolutely delicious and terrific service

Always the best - never disappoints.
Gilbert and his seasoned staff are pros and know how to take care of their guests.

This was our favorite meal on our visit to South Beach. The manager, staff and our server (older gentleman) were very friendly and professional. Service was impeccable. We enjoyed an appetizer special which was an enormous tiger shrimp and Caesar salads. My husband thoroughly enjoyed his pasta dish and I absolutely loved my Papperdelle con Astice! The lobster was substantial and the house made pasta and sauce memorable. Although full, I was determined to finish every bite! We didn’t have room for dessert but the display looked wonderful. We returned on our last day for the happy hour. The pasta stuffed with veal in a brown butter sage sauce and the seafood stuffed ravioli are an absolute must. Osteria del teatro will definitely bring us back to South Beach! Thank you!

Loved the food and service! Definitely will be back

This used to be a very good Italian restaurant. I remember that most anything you ordered was really nice tasting, This time I was disappointed with the pasta dish we ordered, both the taste and the aspect were substandard. Let's hope they improve the kitchen.

Excellent meal and service. The owner personally greeted us and our server was friendly and very accommodating.

The best Italian food on South Beach hands down!!!

Management was running all over. No one really seemed in charge. Food was good, plating can be better.

Wonderful, authentic Italian restaurant in the heart of South Beach

Words cannot express the reputation of professionalism the attention and the quality of service and the food was everything and more than I expectedThis is truly top of the line and THE BEST when it comes to hospitality Thank you very much Gilbert the owner raphael outstanding Pablo the server and staff

Wonderful dinner. Huge portions, consider sharing. No room for dessert (our only regret cause they looked divine). Waitress brought us a free dessert anyway! Large range of creative options. But the BEST is the table magician, Alexander!!! Not intrusive... but let him entertain you after ordering while you await your meal to arrive. He’ll blow your mind. Up close he does phenomenal magician. Been talking about it ever since.

excellent ambience and the food was outstanding service was a little off with not explaining items available properly

This is Italian food as it is served in Italy..accomplished, complex but not odd flavors and only the freshest ingredients. Our two pasta dishes were outstanding--my fettuccine with wild shrimp easily the best pasta dish I've eaten since our last trip to Italy. The squid ink ravioli was a close second. Great wines, stunning desserts and friendly service. The setting is charmingly Italian...wonderful spot.

Gilbert, Carlos and team do a consistently great job in a welcome classy spot. Ray K

Excellent food, very attentive staff, perfect atmosphere. Will definitely be back!

Probably one of my favorite places in Miami Beach. Feel welcome right when you walk in. The hosts and wait staff are friendly and knowledgeable. Love the homemade pasta! 2nd time here and will return again.

We dined 2/11/20. The food was wonderfully prepared. Service and attention to our table was excellent. The experience was consistent with the reviews that we had read elsewhere. I am fundamentally opposed to a mandatory service charge as it discourages good service but this was not the case for this establishment. I would highly recommend this restaurant.

Horrible!!!! No air condition
Side of pasta was a joke and they charged extra. See pic

The food was amazing and the service very professional and attentive.

One of the best restaurants we have enjoyed in Miami or anywhere else. Manager was very attentive & insured everything went well. Beware, serving portions are large. We could have split both the appetizer & entree. We took home leftovers.

I found it very noisy. The waiter rushing around doesn’t help the ambience. The waiter to my table and the table next to us at the same time. I guess he felt his time was too valuable to repeat the specials twice. He was very annoyed when asked to repeat specials.
My appetizer mussels was brought out from the kitchen cold.
Our main dishes were fine, but we didn’t stay for coffee and dessert.

We returned to Osteria del Teatro yesterday for another memorable evening. The quality of the food and the expert preparation combine to offer a distinctive dining experience. You can add to that a top notch service staff. Christian was our servicer last night and he and his team were gracious and attentive. The owner, Gilbert, greeted us as we arrived and took a moment several times during the evening to check on our table. The pastas are homemade and cooked to perfection. We have tried a number of them and while all are delicious, our favorite is the fettuccine with tiger shrimp in a pink and creamy lobster sauce. The menu includes meat and fish entrees; and there is a full bar and a respectable wine list. Be sure to save room for dessert - the Tiramisu is fantastic!

As always, we had a delicious dinner and a pleasant evening. Staff is very nice and efficient, as well as the wonderful owner!!
Look forward to next visit there!!

Great service and good food. We ordered penne a la vodka, puttanesca and sea bass and they were all delicious. I loved that the fish was served with lentils. The bread basket was great and tasty. The staff was friendly and the location is right on Collins and there is parking everywhere around.