One if by Land, Two if by Sea
It’s a great place to take someone you really care about. It was perfect. I promise your significant other will appreciate it. Price is a little high but it is worth
Food and service were very good but the upstairs room we were seated in was externally warm. We asked to have the temperature lowered but the staff kept checking the thermostat throughout the evening but it never got cooler. Hard to pay $225 per person and sweat into your soufflé.
I checked the main dining room downstairs and it was much cooler. The heat of the room put a damper on what would have been a pleasant dinning experience. Better places in NY for the price. Disappointed that Managment did not come to the table to apologize since we had complained about the temperature and it appeared staff and managment knew there was a problem.
Our favorite....for sentimental reasons. We were married there! Everything is wonderful. The service is attentive without being stuffy and too formal. The food, wine and flowers meet high expectations.
Did not get the seat we asked for. In fact, it was totally a different floor. Wellington and the wine were still great, but octopus and lamb were terrible. I’ve been having dinners many times here but this will be my last time. Very sad to see a such great restaurant going downhill like this.
A Fantastic end to our trip to New York.
A lovely romantic atmosphere with amazing attentive staff and gorgeous food.
Highly recommend to anyone visiting NYC.
The food was excellent and somewhat eclectic - something for every taste. My one quiblle is that the desserts weren't to my taste - I like chocolate but not chocolate soufflet or hazelnut, and the other options were strawberry which I just tolerate, dulche de leche which isn't interesting to me, cheesecake which was too much after the dinner and a couple of other things that weren't for me. It's still a really nice restaurant and worth visiting. Beautiful place with a lovely garden.
It was an amazing experience! I got engaged there and everything was just perfect. The waiter was very polite and the maitres was amazing with us! The experience was incredible! I just want to thank everyone for the best day in my life.
Stunning place the food to match thank you x
Perfect ! The most romantic restaurant I have ever been.
Outstanding food and service. High price point, but worth it for a special occasion. Spent time at the bar pre-meal and the bar tender was quite friendly and charming.
The food was amazing. Service was great as well. Didn’t feel rushed. Nice romantic vibes.
Birthday dinner for my girlfriend. The ambience was delightful, the main course was delicious and they brought out a birthday dish to top it off. Very nice three course prefixed meal
Returned for our anniversary and it did not disappoint. This wonderful establishment, which was Aaron Burr’s home, has two wonderful menus (3 course priced fixe or 7 course tasting that may be paired with wine) that are simply delicious. The hostess is a lovely woman who gave us a lovely goodbye after our meal concluded is a gem. The service was exemplary and the ambiance is just breathtaking, both of which complement the food. This great spot is well worth going to and we shall return .
Over priced. Terrible service. Restaurant was 90 degrees. Place has gone downhill. Would not go back
Great experience and great food. I ordered the rib eye steak and thought the 3 course meal could be too much.
We had visited this restaurant several years ago while we were visiting NYC. It was much better than. We were disappointed by the lack of identification outside. Not even a number existed. Some man stepped out and invited us in. This to me sounds bad because who knows who is doing the inviting in. No place is really safe any more.
We did not like we had to choose either a 3 course menu or a 7 course menu. The restaurant was extremely pretentious and therefore not enjoyable. Some of the items included with good food were not something I would choose to eat. I chose the crab cake for an appetizer, but some of the side "stuff" was undesirable as with the beef wellington. I enjoy trying new foods, but not at a restaurant that is charging extremely high prices and is so pretentious.
While we were at restaurant another couple arrived and checked out things and then got up and left. In reflection we wish we had done the same thing,
The restaurant is in a strange part of town and difficult to get to. I am sure we will never return to this restaurant again. The view out of the window was quite lovely but not available for seating.
it was our 35th anniversary. Only disappointment was that the waiter never acknowledged our anniversary. Otherwise very pleasant.
Outstanding food, and a very attractive restaurant. Really impressed by the wine list -- very good selections at reasonable prices!
Amazing! Best restaurant I’ve ever dined in! So romantic!! Food was top notch delicious!!
Was very excited about finally going to this historic restaurant. Went directly from the theatre. Bar, piano player and atmosphere was outstanding. Our server was extremely inattentive. He was attentive to patrons well dressed. When spending over 500 dollars for a dinner elistlst behavior is unacceptable. My friends were very upset.
A beautiful setting for a romantic evening. A bit of a splurge, but definitely worth it. The service was excellent, and the food delicious. I had the lamb, which was tender and done perfectly. My husband had the beef wellington, which he loved.
They were great. They made my fiancé’s birthday celebration very special for her.
A special restaurant great food. Great service soecial
There isn't enough characters for me to type out all of the amazing things I want to say about this place. Our server Stephen was absolutely amazing and made our night 130% more memorable. Next time we visit NYC we will for sure stop by here again. Our only regret was not giving an even bigger tip because we are still blown away by the experience but plan on making up for that as soon as we can. Great atmosphere, lovely people and tasty food. Highly recommend!
Great food, music and ambience. We did the three course prix fixes and all courses were great!
The service was amazing. The food was ok for the price. I would have expected better executed food.
It was our first time returning to the restaurant having got engaged there 9 years ago and we were delighted that the food, service and ambience were just as special as that special day in 2009.
It was absolutely lovely - beyond expectations! we enjoyed seating next to the adjoining courtyard - very pretty
Always such a great experience. The most hospitable and attentive staff. Food is impeccable and the ambiance is always so romantic and elegant.
Tremendous ambiance -- quite, sophisticated and relaxed. A great way to make a lasting impression on your date. My Beef Wellington was outstanding and the price fix menu is plentiful and makes it all very easy.
The restaurant is always a great experience. From the greeting at the door through the “ good night” everything is a pleasure. Perfect oysters are a great starter, the veal chop my favorite. We will be back!
This is our every year anniversary place! Absolutely love everything about it.
Service was amazing, setting was very romantic, you felt like you stepped outside of NYC momentarily for dinner. Highly recommended.
2nd time there, and still a wonderful experience.
Will go again..!
lovely meal, great location.. really enjoyed the experience.....
When we revisit NYC, this restaurant is at the top of our list! We have wonderful memories of fond occasions, and plans for more to come!
A bit overrated. I had a reservation and still had to wait at the bar for a significant time. We were the only people at the bar. I ordered the lobster and it was quite dry and flavorless. I didn’t want to complain because we were on a special date night. I wouldn’t go back.
Eh not worth it
Phenomenal restaurant. The food was outstanding. I have a food allergy and the chef and server were very accommodating. The atmosphere was exquisite and the music furnished by the pianist lent to a very elegant, comfortable, and enjoyable dining experience.