The best romantic restaurant I’ve ever been. My girlfriend was very happy for the surprise I made for her, doing a reservation here. Keep up the good work!
Everything was amazing and we would definitely recommend to anyone looking for that special place to go.
My husband & I came here for Valentine’s Day. The ambience is perfect for couples, very romantic and charming. But the food is only okay. Definitely not worth the price we paid. I think I’d recommend going for a drink, but skipping dinner here.
Everything perfect about this place!
Food mediocre at best. Ambience would have made the experience better if we weren’t placed in an add-on room to the side of the main dining room. Service was awkward, hovering around our table continuously. The restaurant lost our umbrella and the hostess showed no hint of apology for it. Dessert was the only redeeming factor.
This truly is a wonderful dining experience. Everything was perfect. Food, ambience, the service - it lends itself to the perfect night out. Truly the most romantic gem in NYC.
Way over priced for the meal - prefer to eat at Eleven Madison Park in the bar, it’s the same price but way better food!! However, it’s a pretty set up so there’s a cost associated with this aspect...
This was our first dining experience here and I must say I was very impressed. The ambience was unlike anything I have ever seen, amazing. The food was great. I had the signature dish known as the "Beef Wellington". The staff here is very nice and friendly.
The food was exceeded all expectations, and the service was prompt and top notch!
If you want to have stomach pain you should come here . The food tastes so bad, the presentation and taste disgusting. I was can’t believe it it’s was over priced and everything what we ordered with my friend it’s was hard to eat. Even we was so hungry. I was can’t wait to leave this place. And interior on photo much better than in real life.
Amazing place. Went there with the wife 20 years ago and it is just as good now as it was then. It's our special place. Love it
This is a lovely restaurant. Beautiful setting indoors and a lovely small courtyard garden to view while dining. The food was delicious and service excellent. It is a pricey restaurant so I would recommend it for special occasions.
Excellent food, excellent service, overall a great night out
Took my girlfriend to celebrate our anniversary, the service was great and the ambiance is really amazing. Very romantic spot. Would suggest being seated downstairs if possible. Food was good but not amazing.
Food was okay, but the ambiance was amazing
One If By Land Two If By Sea is TOTALLY AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! My girlfriend and I LOVED IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Romantic ambiance, great food, average cocktails ,slow service.
well... my girl wasn't touched.
Professionalism, courtecious and love from the entrance to the table, it’s a display of love
What a special place! From the welcome warmth of the front room fireplace to the cozy dining* area with it’s windows on the lighted gardens, you can feel the history (Aaron Burr, smuggling tunnels, underground railroad, fire-horses and harlots) and enjoy the impeccable service of fabulous food. Try the Norwegian salmon or the rack of lamb, and the freshest beau soleil oysters. Truly a great romantic restaurant (yes, they had a single tapered candle) and well worth the price.