One if by Land, Two if by Sea

Le recensioni di One if by Land, Two if by Sea delle persone che hanno visitato e mangiato al ristorante. In base alla valutazione recente.

1. M

   Maurice

   New York8 recensioni

   3.0

   Visitato 1 giorno fa

   1. Complessivo 3
   2. Cibo 3
   3. Servizio 3
   4. Atmosfera 5

   My criterion when I evaluate a restaurant is whether I would go back a second time. In this case the answer is no. There were several issues First, they offered us seating in a dark part of the room where we could barely see one another. The preferred tables were reserved for other customers who had not yet arrived. They did seat us in a different section that was somewhat better lit. The prices of everything we ordered were inflated. After being charged $155 for a 3 course meal we were charged $12 for a bottle of sparkling water and $12 for a cup of tea. I was given an option of either English Breakfast or Earl Gray. I asked for the Earl Gray and was served a cup of peppermint tea without the lemon I requested. A glass of Sancerre was $21. The food was no better than average. My Beef Wellington was served well done when I requested medium rare. My wife’s rack of lamb was “okay”. Appetizers and dessert were very good but the main course was a disappointment Finally, the recommendations for the tip included the tax in the calculation. This was stated clearly on the check but the tip should be based on the cost of the food only. Service otherwise was very good, the room was beautiful, and there was live, lovely piano music that added to the romantic atmosphere. In sum, the food was not a good value and I felt that the additional charges were excessive.
   

   È utile?

2. J

   Joe

   New York1 recensione

   5.0

   Visitato 2 giorni fa

   1. Complessivo 5
   2. Cibo 5
   3. Servizio 5
   4. Atmosfera 5

   Best experience and restaurant in NYC! Highly recommend!
   

   È utile?

3. L

   Leah

   Orange County3 recensioni

   5.0

   Visitato il giorno 11 maggio 2025

   1. Complessivo 5
   2. Cibo 5
   3. Servizio 5
   4. Atmosfera 5

   Food and service was exceptional, ambiance was remarkable!
   

   È utile?

4. W

   Walter

   Greater Boston15 recensioni

   5.0

   Visitato il giorno 11 maggio 2025

   1. Complessivo 5
   2. Cibo 5
   3. Servizio 5
   4. Atmosfera 5

   Excellent as always … beautiful interior and great food!
   

   È utile?

5. T

   Thomas

   New York1 recensione

   4.0

   Visitato il giorno 9 maggio 2025

   1. Complessivo 4
   2. Cibo 5
   3. Servizio 4
   4. Atmosfera 5

   staff was respectful and professional ... warm and friendly greeting when i arrived ... another memorable visit to One if by Land, Two if by Sea - looking forward to my next visit
   

   È utile?

6. c

   caroline

   Chicago1 recensione

   5.0

   Visitato il giorno 7 maggio 2025

   1. Complessivo 5
   2. Cibo 5
   3. Servizio 5
   4. Atmosfera 5

   Fantastic dinner, our server Sasha was so thoughtful, attentive, and warm. She was a big part of what made the evening so special!
   

   • 
   • 

   È utile?

7. K

   Klisara

   New Jersey1 recensione

   5.0

   Visitato il giorno 1 maggio 2025

   1. Complessivo 5
   2. Cibo 5
   3. Servizio 5
   4. Atmosfera 5

   Had an amazing experience. Such a beautiful and elegant place. I can really say that was very romantic and had an intimate ambience. Big chandeliers, candles and flowers- such a vibe. We really had a blast. Sasha was very professional, sweet and helpful with every question we had. Will be back again for sure! It’s a bit pricey but very worth it for a special occasion.
   

   È utile?

8. C

   Cheryl VIP

   Atlantic City14 recensioni

   5.0

   Visitato il giorno 27 aprile 2025

   1. Complessivo 5
   2. Cibo 5
   3. Servizio 5
   4. Atmosfera 5

   Excellent food, very attentive service, nice ambiance. Recommend: tempura, agnolotti, Beef Wellington, tile fish, crème brûlée, tiramisu and soufflé.
   

   È utile?

9. R

   Ronald

   New York2 recensioni

   5.0

   Visitato il giorno 27 aprile 2025

   1. Complessivo 5
   2. Cibo 5
   3. Servizio 5
   4. Atmosfera 5

   I took my family to celebrate my anniversary-I'd taken my wife here 19 years ago to propose. It was fantastic then, and it's fantastic now. I remembered the ambience as being muted and romantic-it hasn't changed, notwithstanding my family was dining rather than just my wife and I. The service was impeccable-the wait staff spot on in attending to needs without being overbearing. The food was amazing: The chef's tasting menu of 3 items allows for you to choose from various items, from which my family had different selections. We were able to taste many of the different choices, and without exception they were all delightful and an experience. All of us thoroughly enjoyed ourselves. Many thanks to you all.
   

   1 persona ha trovato utile questa recensione

10. W

    William

    New York1 recensione

    5.0

    Visitato il giorno 26 aprile 2025

    1. Complessivo 5
    2. Cibo 4
    3. Servizio 5
    4. Atmosfera 5

    Wonderful experience. Fantastic food and ambiance. Only complaint would be to allow a la carte ordering
    

    È utile?