Treat Mom to a special Mother's day at Olive Lucy's! Please join us for a lovely dinner with a wonderful Prix Fixe dinner at 49.95 per head.
Sunday, May 13, 2018
Great vibe walking into the restaurant. Getting seated was pretty efficient. Not sure if they were under-staffed, but table service was slow and not particularly attentive. Pork chop was perfectly cooked, probably a little too heavy on the blueberry sauce, and the mash was very sweet. If you like a restaurant with a 'buzz' you'll enjoy this, however I would not return as I didn't feel the menu prices were reflected in the food overall quality and service experience.
Great surprise find! Very nice menu. All of us thoroughly enjoyed our meals.
Great atmosphere and delicious food. Definitely made for a fun environment for dinner with friends.
This was our first time at Olive Lucy's and it won't be our last. We were greeted in a friendly fashion. The ambience was just beautiful. We got a high table by the window ideal for people watching and admiring the decor. The food was too die for... You must try the lobster empanadas... Omg. The service was great. I had mentioned my husband's birthday in the reservation and they surprised him with this amazing FREE dessert enough to feed an army... Ice cream, fruit, pound cake, whipped cream, etc. It was beautiful and delicious. I can't wait to come back. We have a new favorite restaurant. And... With appetizers, dinner, coffee, before tip it was well under $100 for great cuisine.
Good food and service. I read reviews that the noise level was not bad, but I must disagree. On a Friday night at 8:00, my friend and I could not hear each other across the table. Try going during lunch or off ours to enjoy.
We loved the restaurant. I had the short ribs which was utterly sublime. My wife also thoroughly enjoyed her fish. The overall menu is quite appealing, the interior is attractive, and the service is excellent. My only gripe is that the noise level is loud. Perhaps they could install some noise dampeners. Otherwise, Olive Lucy's Kitchen Table gets a solid "thumbs up."
First timer, loved it and will return!
The avocado salad with grilled salmon was perectly seared.
Excellent all around
The tables are rather on the small side, however, as a party of 4, they did put us in a table for six after us asking several times. The atmosphere is attractive, but the openness makes it very noisy. The food was all right, but I didn’t think it was spectacular or special for the price.
Olive Lucy is always a great experience. The food and service is great. One of our favorite Morristown restaurants. Bring a great wine and enjoy!
Tonight we started with our favorite Lobster Empanadas, followed by the Med. Salad, and entrees the excellently prepared Blackened Scallops and Lucy Pork Chop.
Place is cute; service is great! Our waiter knew what to recommend and what was in it etc. the problem was with my dish - blackened spicy scallops - description sound amazing but what I got was 4 medium size scallops that weren’t cooked all the way and had very little blackened or spicy flavor at all - was thoroughly disappointed. Mussels Portuguese were amazing! The short ribs ok and chicken was ok too.
Everything about this restaurant is excellent except for the volume level of their house music which made is very hard to hear my guests even though it was a week day dinner and the restaurant was 3/4 empty. The Chef prepared my fish absolutely perfectly which I truly appreciate!
Excellent meal. First time there and everything was great. Will be sure to return again.
Have been here several times and have never been disappointed :)
This was my second visit to Olive Lucy's. It is FABULOUS!!!! I
I need to go more often. Amazing food and decor.
The fried calamari was awesome crispy and tender the lobster mac and cheese was also delicious. I had the short ribs which were great and my husband paella which he loved!
Best paella I've ever had, even better than that I've had in Spain.
This was our first time visiting. Food was good, staff was great. Downside was it was very loud making it difficult to have conversation. Even though I made reservations well in advance, they squeezed us into a small table against the wall. I probably should have asked to be moved from the start -my bad- but the staff couldn't even reach to serve me or refill my water-they should have known better.
Delicious food. Friendly staff. Great date night spot. Lots of tables squished in but I don't mind but may be a turn off for some people.
Food was delicious and service was pretty good. Appetizer portion sizes are small so you probably need one per person. Entree portion sizes were great not too big or small. The dessert was also good. I’m sure I will go again.
We went after a concert at the Mayo Center on a Sunday. Wasn't busy, but we've heard it can be very noisy when full. Music was eclectic - enjoyable variety, just a bit too loud. Other than that - we loved it here! Food was fantastic. We shared an appetizer of shrimp and garlic and a beet salad - both terrific. For dinner, I had the scallops on spinach and vegetable risotto, which was delicious. My husband had the pork chop with blueberry compote over whipped sweet potatoes. If the bone from the chop was edible, he would have eaten it the chop was THAT good. For dessert, we shared a slice of pecan ice cream pie. The perfect way to end a wonderful meal! The staff was attentive and friendly - great service! We will be back!
Great food, eaten here many time. Nice decor and ambiance- Service usually is better.
Food was prepared and presented well. Some of the food was a bit spicier than anticipated. Service was excellent as usual. I prefer the low tables to the high tops.
We thought the service was quite good and so was the food. However we thought it was pricey for sharing a salad and just 2 entrees, no dessert, and it was bring your own wine.
Wonderful little restaurant with fantastic food. Attentive service.
I thought my steak was pretty bland and expensive for what it was. Overall, disappointed in the food.
Enjoyed the restaurant very much. One of my favorites in Morristown. Only complaint was the cod. Suspect it was frozen not fresh. Otherwise excellent.
Great food , workers are great and very friendly . Beautiful decor and very comfortable . 5 star over all
Food was fantastic! Service very good. It is LOUD. So be prepared. And it’s BYOB (a plus). Come hungry
Food was great and the people were awesome. Friendly and cozy atmosphere.
Service horribly slow. Busboys grab plates from you while you're still eating. Food good, but noisy atmosphere.
The food was good, but not for the price. The restaurant only offered a pre fixe menu(this was four days after Valentine's Day). The entrees were good, but app and dessert were not worth the cost.
Absolutely loved this restaurant. I went with my boyfriend the Saturday after Valentine's... WOW this place will be hard to top! They had an entertainer walking around and singing love songs throughout the restaurant, it really helped to set the mood. My boyfriend and I both loved our entire meal, the food was really delicious. I can't eat dairy and the staff was very accommodating which I don't always find at other restaurants. A+ and strongly recommend checking this place out for your next special occasion - well worth the $$.
We went to the last reservation and by 8pm they had turned off the music and repeatedly came over to ask if we were done with our food yet
I’ve been there twice the last 2 months and both times my dinner was delish. Love the decor and service is always great. Keep up the good work!
Service is was great. We were grabbing dinner before a movie and were served in plenty of time to make it to the show. Food was good. Desserts were a little too sweet for our taste but were very inventive. Nice atmosphere, gets a little crowded on Saturday night. Go early.
We had a gift card given to us to try this place as it was a favorite of a friends .. Certainly did NOT disappoint. Food was great, service was great -- only small complaint is the bench cushion seating needs to be refreshed. I had to sit on my folded coat to not sink in my seat!
Can't wait to go back
We had so much fun. It was a wonderful experience as soon as we walked in. We met Lucy’s cousin who told us about her and showed us her picture on the wall. We were honored to be seated at the owners table. Perfect spot for seeing the whole room. Our Server Freddy was amazing and couldn’t be more accommodating. The food was incredible. 4 of us had the paella the other 2 had scallops. No one chased us out and it was a wonderful evening. I highly recommend it!
The service was great, however, my meal was awful. I had the encrusted salmon and it tasted like mayonnaise was just smeared on top and the vegetable was broccoli which had not taste. The appetizers and salad were very good. I love salmon and eat a lot of it out and have to say that unfortunately, this is one of the worst salmon dishes I have ever eaten. I won't be rushing back.