We went to the last reservation and by 8pm they had turned off the music and repeatedly came over to ask if we were done with our food yet
I’ve been there twice the last 2 months and both times my dinner was delish. Love the decor and service is always great. Keep up the good work!
Service is was great. We were grabbing dinner before a movie and were served in plenty of time to make it to the show. Food was good. Desserts were a little too sweet for our taste but were very inventive. Nice atmosphere, gets a little crowded on Saturday night. Go early.
We had so much fun. It was a wonderful experience as soon as we walked in. We met Lucy’s cousin who told us about her and showed us her picture on the wall. We were honored to be seated at the owners table. Perfect spot for seeing the whole room. Our Server Freddy was amazing and couldn’t be more accommodating. The food was incredible. 4 of us had the paella the other 2 had scallops. No one chased us out and it was a wonderful evening. I highly recommend it!
The service was great, however, my meal was awful. I had the encrusted salmon and it tasted like mayonnaise was just smeared on top and the vegetable was broccoli which had not taste. The appetizers and salad were very good. I love salmon and eat a lot of it out and have to say that unfortunately, this is one of the worst salmon dishes I have ever eaten. I won't be rushing back.
Great ambiance, trendy but intimate enough for a date. Love that it’s byob. Unique dining choices.
Salmon dish was under cooked, potatoes were cold. Not impressed.
Had a reservation after a 7:00 movie across the street. Was looking for a light meal and could not have been more pleased with our selection. Salad and the Mussels Portuguese to start . The mussels were delicious with the perfect amount of heat from the jalapeño, could have dunked an entire basket of bread in it. Instead waiting for the Steamed Swai Filet, which was light and delicious. Husband had the Mariscada and enjoyed it. Waiter was attentive and he was happy to explain ingredients and how a dish was prepared.
This place reminds me of Fresco in Montclair. It attracts a young noisy crowd who isn't so much interested in (or even recognizes) what a place rated so highly should deliver in the way of cuisine. (According to Yelp and Open Table, Lucy's is rated 4 - 4 1/2 stars. That's two stars too high in my book.) And it's overpriced for what you get. My paella special was "pfffffft" and my wife's chicken special doggie-bagged it home with us. Right now it's taking up space in the refrigerator. I'll be tossing it in the trash tomorrow. My buddy's pork chop special was enough to feed a 12 year old, and his wife's salmon was...well, all she ever orders is salmon so I don't even bother asking any more. If you want to go for Portuguese go to the Ironbound. Peas out.
Enjoyed the evening at Olive Lucy's - a vibrant restaurant with excellent food and a huge variety. Majority of options are Italian - but the short ribs were fantastic! Several specials also tempted us this evening and we tried 2 and were happy we did. We both agreed we will be back. Louder than I would like and quite crowded but not rushed and all in all a great night.
We hadn't been to Olive Lucy's in a while but decided to take some out-of-town guests. I love the atmosphere of this place (though a bit too loud). Everyone was happy with their food from paella to mussels to pork chops and chicken. The main issue was the absolutely terrible service. Our waiter was clearly spread too thin. The kitchen was also out of whack. Our party of 6 ordered before the table of 10 behind us and yet their food was served well before us. Also, only 4 people at our table got their meals together and the other two were a full 5 minutes behind leaving everyone waiting and food getting cold. Then the last two meals were not even brought out together. I really like the food, but I have to say the service is a really big turn off. I probably won't run back too soon.
Service was very slow,but the waiter was good.My portion was small,but tasty.Good dessert.
Food and service(Lou) was outstanding. We will be back.
Good blend of Portuguese and American cuisine. Stylish, fun and comfortable decor. Good service. Excellent food. Will go again.
As always, Steve, Pat and the staff delivered a terrific experience. Tasty food, exceptional service, and terrific ambiance. Thanks, again, for a memorable evening!