Came here with the wife to celebrate Valentine’s Day since every single spot was booked on the day. Good thing we did because that truffle pasta my wife had was to die for. I had the beef brisket pasta which she had on our first visit here and it did not disappoint. Don’t forget to order the grilled octopus and buratta Bc you’re not living if you don’t! Susanna was also very sweet and remembered us on our first visit here.

Great service and delicious food!!!! We will definitely be going back!

Great experience! Food is always delicious and service was excellent.

Incredible carbonara
Average pizza
Great burger

Would dine here again

If you go there ask for Eva to be your server. She is amazing and made my night infinitely better. I wish I was a better writer so I could more accurately describe how wonderful she is.

We went here for "outdoor" dining and it kind of was...the restaurant has cleverly built a non-heated addition to the main restaurant and opened the windows/doors fully between the inside and the outdoor addition. The outdoor addition was packed. We were seated next to an open window so it was okay, but seated in the middle I don't think I would've been comfortable. However, the servers were nice and accommodating, the food was good and we had plenty of time to sit and relax. The restaurant must be wonderful in the spring when people can sit outside on the sidewalk - it's a very cute place.

It was my first time out dining since COVID started. Definitely a great place to start! My friend is vegan, so they were kind enough to serve the ham on the pesto pizza separately. Impeccable service and food! The truffle pasta and pizza shared was a pleasant amount for me and my friend (both women). Will return!

Amazing experience, food, cocktails, personnel, this place is amazing! Great vibes!

The food at Olio e Piu is great! The ricotta bruschetta was fab and the cacio e peppe was delicious.

Our server Suzanna was helpful and made some good recommendations.

It felt a little crowded from a covid standpoint but they had plastic dividers up.

Pizza was soggy and extremely salty. Sea bass special was drenched in butter. All very unnecessary. The salad was delicious, as was the tiramisu.

Squid ink pasta was delicious, so was the wine. Super nice waiter too

One of my favorite restaurants in NYC and the never disappoint! Highly recommend.

Great food, great outside dining and one of my favorite Italian restaurants in NYC!

Amazing food and friendly, efficient staff!

One of the best Italian restaurants in the village. Great food great service and we love your waitress Susanna. We will be back soon.

Spaghetti carbonara was Amazing! Service was outstanding, sorry I do not remember our waitresses name but her suggestions were excellent! First time here will definitely be back!

Great ambiance and perfect place to stay warm while outdoor dining. Food was average—- good but not great.

Everything was excellent! Olio's Old Fashioned and the pasta carbonara were our favorites!

Such great outdoor set up. Amazing service

Great food, great service, and setting was perfect for ensuring a warm dining experience.

Fantastic food and service, the space was very well insulated and cozy.

Eva was an absolutely amazing waitress!! She did a lovely job serving us this evening. The food was wonderful- highly recommend the ricotta bruschetta & fritto misto.

Great food and great service.
One of the best restaurants in new york

Clearly violating COVID protocol.

Amazing time

The food was pretty good, but nothing to die for especially for the pricing. The service was really quick which was a plus, but the “outdoor” seating for covid is super cramped and definitely not social distanced so I’m not really sure how they’re getting away with it.

Amazing outdoor dining setup! Staff were very warm and friendly and food was great! Brunch here made our Saturday afternoon!

Thank you Alex - you're the best!! Eva was a fabulous server. Another A+ dining experience.

I really enjoyed the carbonara pasta, go to dish when you go here. Outdoor dining was very nice the only complaint I had was that it was a bit tight and they left one door open so half of the inside was cold while the other half was hot but I will definitely be coming back for the pasta, I also had a lovely waitress. Support local businesses! 9/10

Great, space and yummy food!! I would love to go back soon.

Awesome!!!

We had outdoor dining which was a bit chilly due to being seated next to a window...food was great though and staff were attentive

should put tables a bit more spread out but enjoyed the dining experience!

The host was very nice changing our table in a crowded place, the server was also very sweet! Food was just okay for the price. Place was warm.

Everything was great! The service was attentive. Food and drinks were amazing! Given the pandemic, this restaurant was a wonderful option as the doors were open to ensure airflow while not compromising on the dining experience.

Olio e Più is consistently fantastic. The food is great the service is attentive and the atmosphere is cozy. I also love this restaurant for the people-watching.

Go here for my anniversary 2 years in a row now. Great place.

Loved everything about it

Consistently good food and super warm atmosphere.

Thankfully sat in the outdoor section by the street - next to open French doors & a window. Minimal separation between tables that they tried to compensate with plexiglass partitions. If you stand up - you are much taller than the partitions. It's shocking that the other "outdoor" area hasn't been shut down by inspectors. Tables were crammed together/plexi partitions & inadequate ventilation. A real "Covid tent".
I support our NYC restaurants & want them to survive in a big way - but can't vouch for the safety of this location at this time in the pandemic.