Old Mill Toronto

Food was tasty and service was prompt and servers friendly. Covid protocols were observed . However, lighting in the room was too dark. Overall experience was fairly positive.

The experience was wonderful. I have always enjoyed the brunch buffet. I was a little disappointed in the vegetarian hot options. Also, the number of salads etc was greatly reduced. A little pricy for the reduced amount of food. However, will happily return.

It was a wonderful ambience for a family gathering and everyone enjoyed the amazing food choices as well as the excellent service!

Christmas early with my daughter

Although not a very extensive menu, the food was outstanding! Beautiful room excellent service and wonderful ambience. I would highly recommend

Difficult to see such an amazing restaurant so quiet. No doubt Covid-19 has taken its toll on many places now. It does require some much needed love and caring inside. I grew up in that neighbourhood and enjoyed the activities of fine dining, weddings and social events. However, the food was incredibly wonderful and the staff still performing their jobs as the true professionals they are and were back in the day! With help from satisfied customers over the years, this place deserves to be brought back to the splendour it has always given everyone, both staff and customers. And because the staff has kept up the traditions of fine dining, I highly recommend this establishment! Let’s help them out and prove that The Old Mill is still a grand place to enjoy an evening with family and friends!

Disappointing
Server was nice
Very limited menu no very expensive for the entire experience - Venue atmosphere variety and quality

Example - ordered red wine served it in white wine glass…. Has to wait for one red glass to be found. The only one they had.

So much potential for this place to create a unique quality experience

Comfortable and quiet and nice ambience - good service and not rushed

Tables were all in one corner of the restaurant with a low ceiling (not enough air to circulate), close to each other while the rest of the restaurant was empty. The part of the restaurant with a high ceiling was not in service. We did not feel safe and asked staff to give us a table away from the crowded area. They did, but the ambiance was not there, it looked strange and abandoned. The table should have been spread evenly with a safe distance one from another. It was a little depressing experience.

$$$ but we’ll done ! Plenty of food !
We were there for lunch !

Food was delicious. Ambience was perfect. The servers were very attentive and timely. Overall, my husband and I enjoyed a wonderful dinner.

Overall the restaurant was excellent. The staff was friendly, accommodating and attentive.
The only drawback was that the coffee was way overpriced. $4 a cup and then we were not told it was bottomless and were charged each time our cup was refilled!! They need a children's menu as well and more options on the menu especially to accommodate gluten free or vegetarian diets.
The ambience was quiet and cozy with wonderful decor.

Wonderful ambience and excellent live entertainment. Service was attentive and food was served quickly. A very enjoyable evening !

Overall——Old Mill is always a nice place to go for brunch. Food was good but coffee was and usually is always lukewarm

Friendly and accommodating staff, excellent food and wonderful atmosphere. Thank you

Our group of 6 were here for a Sunday dinner. The seafood papardelli was fantastic! (The croquettes received mixed reviews.) The service was great, the staff were very attentive, yet not overly so. This was my first visit to any restaurant since the start of the pandemic, there was lots of spacing between tables. Overall a very enjoyable evening.

We enjoyed everything about the restaurant, food, and service.

Excellent service and it was a wonderful family time👍😘

First off parking is not good. Lot says parking for Old Mill Inn and when inside we were told we had to go pay $2 an hour.

When we checked in they wished us happy anniversary. It was our 40th.

Side caesar salad served in small soup bowl making it very difficult to eat. Should have been served on a plate. Asked for plate and waiter brought it. Much easier.

Lamb shank was excellent and salmon good.

Asked for bread with meal and bread is not offered.

Ordered wine and waiters kept glasses filled. Service was great.

It was our 40th wedding anniversary and surprised that no complementary champagne or dessert given.

Lovely experience. One of my favorite places. 5:00 dinner sitting very low attendance--good time, now, for a quiet, reflective dinner. Service very good with"personalized" attention. Food very well prepared. Good to be back.

Pleasant environment for a sit down meal, but the restaurant seems to be understaffed. Had to wait over an hour and a half for the food to arrive. Missing items/ingredients in my order.

Felt hectic and rushed. Food was lovely.

The fixed menu was not great, very expensive for the quality of the food. My prime rib was overdone and the Yorkshire’s were too

Planning on doing every thanksgiving lunch here. Great food and service. I would highly recommend.

The Old Mill is much how we remembered it from our last visit, some 11 years ago. No buffet due to COVID restrictions but frankly, table service was a better experience.
However, the place is in need of a decor update.
The food was plentiful and well worth the cost.

Good food, slow service. The area did not look full, but maybe there was a wedding

Waited over 15 minutes before a waiter came to our table. When one finally did he was quite rude told us he was just here to bring water and that he wasn't our waiter and we'd have to wait for our waiter to come before we could order. Waited another near 10 minutes for our waiter and then the wait time for our food to arrive was very long. Used to love going to the Old Mill but it's been like this the last couple of times. They really need to address this lack of service and rude staff. Would usually rave about this place but not anymore.

It was great to be back at the Old Mill. We had the thanksgiving menu and it was incredible. I’ll be back for tea and Christmas !!!

Lovely traditional setting, quiet service, great for a family occasion.

The service and attention to our group was excellent.
It felt like a special occasion. We were in a quiet corner which allowed me to hear others in the group.
We are planning on returning for brunch during the Christmas Season.

Thank you,
Susan Jones

Food and drinks were way overpriced.
For the price the value is certainly poor.
Service and atmosphere was good.
I won’t be returning any time soon.

Old mill restaurant was a really lovely experience. The decorations were fantastic and the food outstanding. Service was great. We had two birthdays to celebrate and our server Lionel brought the creme brûlée cheesecake which was fantastic and he even put a candle on it. The whole experience was terrific. We plan to go back again soon.

We enjoyed the ambience and service was very good .
Was just a bit disappointed to find out that what was on the menu on the internet from open table and website was not the same when we got there . Price was very high from what we were expecting when we checked on the website.

The service, ambience, facility and greeting is always good. It is just the food that is very ordinary both in quality and in presentation.

We were celebrating our anniversary in Old Mill today as we got married in here. The food was amazing and we enjoyed the pretty patio so much. But the experience from the service was not very well today - There has been nobody came taking order proactively until a long while, including ordering a drink and the meal. And when we got the tea, there was no tea spoon provided, when we got the steak, there was no steak knife provided, so we had to ask for it. Lastly, when getting the bill, we were being asked at least twice about what we had ordered in order to get the bill correctly. So the overall service was not good. Again the food is amazing as always but sometimes service may ruin the brand so there seems to have some improvements needed here.

Old Mill seems to be back up to its former standards, which is nice to see. Service was attentive, although our server wasn't very familiar with the new menu which was a bit unusual and couldn't adequately describe what some of the dishes were.

The dining room was a bit cold, but due to being in between seasons, this makes sense.

It felt comfortable to dine indoors, there weren't too many people in the dining room and all Covid protocols were followed.

Overall, pleasantly surprised with our lunch and very glad we ventured out after not having been in a long time.

A quiet spot for a special evening. Attentive service.

It was our first and last time, food was mediocre at best and the service was the worse.

Food and service was great. We sat in the dining room and it was very dark.

Excellent food. Menu somewhat limited, but excellent.