Our server was amazing!!!
The food was way over priced.
The bar staff was to busy talking to each other. Also I ask for a glass of house wine 17.00 for a glass is to much. Our waiter was wonderful. I would give him 10 stars
Took my parents for Mother's Day supper. The ambiance is good, but the food quality is not what we expected. The steaks were cold and the side dishes were prepared hours before and were lukewarm. I am an Orlando native and have been to the restaurant twice before. I cannot remember having a meal so lackluster. The bright spot was the staff. I felt bad for them having to act like the meal was satisfactory. I would not recommend this restaurant to anyone.
First time at Old Hickory and last. Waitress was wonderful but the food was not good. My steak was very try hardly any flavor. My daughter picky eater got over cooked pasta. My mom ordered a Filet medium rare it was well done we sent it back they brought out a raw steak she didn’t even ask for another. They were nice enough to take it off the bill but for what you pay for versus what you get totally not worth. I have paid less at Capitol Grille and Morton’s for much better steak.
Wildly overpriced food. Beyond just touristy-high prices. $50 for a steak, no side, no salad? $3 add-on for a dab of steak sauce? Ridiculously expensive, and not exceptional in any way except price.
Manny’s Original Chophouse just a few miles away has better steaks by far, better side dishes, incredible salad, very reasonable drinks, and prices 1/2 of Old Hickory.
No one except captives of the resort would eat here more than once at these silly prices.
It was ok. Service was excellent
The food was delicious, surroundings cozy, and the server Brian amazingingly thoughtful as he always anticiapted everything (refills, timing the next course). We were there to celebrate Mother's Day & a birthday. It was a wonderful experience.
Cheese plate was very good. Salads so-so. The steak was good but I asked for medium rare and it was cooked medium. For the price they should get that right every time.
The restaurant was inside of the resort. So, it was very convenient for us so as to not have to leave the resort to eat dinner. The food was good but we felt that it didn’t justify the outrageous prices for everything.
Our favorite place to dine when in the Orlando area or when we have a special occasion. Well worth the 90 minute drive!!!
Service was excellent and saved the experience, if only the food measured up.
I expected a lot more from a $65 dry aged delmonico.
Soufflé for dessert was very good.
Overall I’ve had better meals for the price.
We've been there a few times. Always leave disappointed. Steaks were undercooked (again) and what they asserted was an amazing delmonico was a $65 piece of fat, way beyond marbled even for a rib eye.
Missing the wines in the wine list,
Missing the Delmonico
Everything was perfect and your Servers are absoulte professionals!
Excellent food client raved about the choice for our dinner
Our meals at Old Hickory were very good, steaks tender! Found the atmosphere to be outdated and worn, chairs uncomfortable. We were asked to wait in the bar (10 min early for our reservation) and the bar was old and dingy, unwelcoming... Even the servers/bartenders uniforms were outdated. Even though we found the food delicious the restaurant was not comfortable.
The waiter and service where very good , but the food was extremely average . The Cesar salad was sub standard , the creamed corn was soggy , the filet mignon was fair at best .Ir was very expensive for the quality of the food . We will not be going back .
The bar service great, but the food service terrible. Waited hour and half and still not served until complained.
Excellent as usual! Food was amazing, service was amazing. We enjoyed the entire experience!
Friendly service but food was average. New York Strip had a lot of gristle and salmon was cool when it arrived to the table.
There were two of us at dinner here. The restaurant layout is fantastic and we completely enjoyed our visit. The service beat our expectations by a large margin. Be prepared to spend a lot of money here. A couple of drinks, a shared dessert, steak and fish entrees and the tab was over $300. To be honest we’ll be back. When it comes to a great dining experience we will gladly pay extra. But if you’re on a budget then think twice about this one.
N/A awesome age steak
Although the food was impressive, especially the cheese platter selection and properly prepared steaks, it was the service that truly stood out. My party was well attended by all the staff members we encountered and our table servers were truly top-notch.
I would travel to this restaurant if I was not staying in the hotel. First class food and service. Can easily compete with any of the chain stake houses.
My steak was under cooked and thought and my desert took to long
Still good but shrimp cocktail and crab bisque are not a patch on what they used to be
Sorry food quality,and would never eat there again or recommend anyone to eat there,
The food and service were excellent. The cowboy cut ribeye was fantastic. It was a little pricey but very good.
Good food and service, but completely overpriced. I don't mind quality bottles of wine being marked up, but by 4x the amount is a bit ridiculous.
Great dishes excellent steak
Our waiter Brian was very attentive and took good care of us. We were celebrating our anniversary and he made sure all of the foods was to our liking. He added a special desert for our occasion for us to enjoy. The manager Benjamin came over and introduced himself. Speaking with him made our night even more special. This was our 4th time back and we will come back next year, if not before.
All of the serving staff was excellent and we had a wonderful evening. We were celebrating a birthday along with a good friend who had just flew into Orlando. Would totally recommend to anyone in the area.
The steak was sub par
The children’s meals were too expensive
$500 meal for 4 adults and 4 children was crazy
Shocking the food was not excellent
Food and server were great!
However wait time and hostess attitude very bad!!!
The service was impeccable! Not normally a big fan on resort dinning but this was outstanding from beginning to end. Bravo!
The seating was ideal. The service- friendly, timely and beyond expectation. We thoroughly enjoyed our evening. Although a little late starting because of a kitchen problem, it was more than made up for it with their personal managerial apology and outstanding service from Javier.
Javier was personal, kind and very interesting. He showed that he cared about our enjoying our evening and provided exceptional care and service. We will be back.
Amazing restaurant, excellent food ,and great ambiance.
Great food and great setting
Overall, the restaurant is pretty good. It's billed as a "high end" "classy" place, so I guess it's trying to be like Morton's or something comparable, but it doesn't quite get there. The food is good, but like everything at the Gaylord it's crazy expensive. The ambience is nice, the service is solid, and the wine list is good as well. It can get pretty loud, and the tables are pretty close together, so it's not great for intimate conversations.
It's also pretty busy, so a reservation is highly recommended. However, the staff seem a little unsure what to do with you if you show up early, so it's probably best to show up pretty much right on time for your reservation so they don't send you to the bar then forget you.
It's a good place for a business dinner, if you want to treat clients or employees to something that feels like a big, pretentious deal, and don't mind paying a premium for it.
I'll go back, next time I'm at the Gaylord, and will recommend it to others, with those few caveats.