Nearby points of interest
Restaurants you may also like
Nearby points of interest
About Permanently Closed - O'Donoghue's Bar and Grill
This restaurant is permanently closed.
O'donoghue's Bar and Grille is an American, Irish bar and restaurant that offers a range of hearty and gluten-free items on the menu. This traditional Irish sports bar offers crowd favorites in the appetizers section such as chicken tenders, onion rings, shrimp cocktail, mini shepherd's pie along with non-traditional seafood items such as salmon and shrimp rolls. O'donoghue's Bar and Grill's special Tri-color platter is a favorite with diners with its selection of shrimp rolls, chicken wings and sausage rolls that come with their own sides.
O'donoghue's Bar and Grill also offers Irish favorites that go down well with American diners as well. Popular items in this section include chicken pie, shepherd's pie along with corned beef and cabbage which boasts prime Angus corned beef seasoned with parsley cream sauce. The sandwiches section includes the classic chicken sandwich among others. This restaurant has closed down.
Marco Island, FL 34145
Irish, American, Seafood
Hours of Operation:
Dinner Nightly: 4:00pm - 9:30pm
$30 and under
AMEX, Carte Blanche, Diners Club, Discover, JCB, MasterCard, Visa
Private Party Facilities:
We have the capability of utilizing the back portion of our restaurant as a private room for functions. There is also a fully stocked bar that can be dedicated to your party. On certain occasions we can utilize the entire restaurant for a private functions.
Private Party Contact:
Gavin Donaghy: (239) 389-0032
Banquet, Bar Dining, Bar/Lounge, Beer, Late Night, Outdoor dining, Private Room, Takeout, Wheelchair Access, Wine
O'Donoghue's Bar and Grill - Permanently Closed Ratings and Reviews
We genuinely liked the food and the atmosphere. The middling review is due largely to our waitress, unfortunately. She was slow and very impersonal. No eye contact whatsoever, or greetings when she eventually managed to bring us our food/drinks. Took forever to get any attention at all upon arriving (at least 10-15 minutes) and her demeanor throughout was unpleasant. The other servers and the bartenders seemed much more friendly and efficient, we were just unlucky to be stuck with ours.
A fun place to eat with friends. We started with the Loaded Irish Nachos, they were very good and very filling. A great choose of beers at reasonable prices. I had a Harps. My friends had Mini Shepherd pie(S) a good choose after the Nachos. My wife had the Rueben Sandwich. I had a Corn Beef Sandwich. We all enjoyed our food. If you go on a weekend night make a reservation for they have entertainment at 7:00 PM and the place fills up early. The service staff is very good but the kitchen must be small since they can get overwhelmed.
We went to this restaurant on a whim, looking for something casual, well glad we did. I had the Shepard pie, very tasty, my husband had the prime rib special, he also like it. Our waiter was very nice and attentive, if you are in Marco Island and looking for some place casual try it.
We had a party of four and we all had the Saturday night special, Prime rib. We all agreed that it was the best Prime rib we had had in a very long time. Due to the NCAA final 4 the noise level was elevated but bearable. Best place on Marco for a pint of Guinness.
Great location in a very happening area of Marco Island. The food was okay but more "fill" than "can't wait to eat". Maybe better for young people who are looking for a quick meal than an actual dining experience. Staff was absent most of the time. Hard to get a drink refill. They may have been understaffed that evening as all the restaurants on the island were at capacity. We will give it another try this season.
We went for dinner on a Monday nite. The crowd was small but service slow...inattentive. Beer selection was very. good..prices very reasonable. We shared fish and chips which were very good. The hand cut fries were fresh and hot, not warm and soggy like most fries. Fish was hot and crispy and had a nice mild flavor. The dipping sauce could have been more flavorful. It was a little bland. Coleslaw was too creamy/oily. Salads were fresh. We would go back again even though the service was pretty slow. We liked the food and I am willing to give the service another chance.
We enjoy coming here almost every Sat. evening. Fine food, excellent waitress etc. Onc area that my wife and I comment on every time is the hostess could be friendlier. She could smile and welcome the guests. She comes across as very unfriendly and this probably is not her.
We had a great lunch there. Terrific food. The Dinner however was disappointing. The "pork tenderloin" was not tenderloin but in fact was pork loin. Lots of difference. Noise level seemed a bit loud even for a pub. The live music was fine but don't try to have a conversation while they are playing.
We arrived and met our friends and as we were seated were informed that any dishes that came with potatos were not available nor were there any rolls!! No potatoes at a so called Irish Pub! That's right there signature dish which is Sheperds Pie not available, boiled dinner, nope !! I asked if the potatoe famine had hit Marco and if not why not run up to public and buy some ?! Since there were five of us and we knew we would not be able to get in any where else we stayed. Mistake. !!! The service was awful ! We needed to ask the bus boy numerous times to get our waitress. When we asked for another drink,ketchup etc....she never returned and when she did we would ask again !
Very LOUD live Irish music - you couldn't have a conversation at your table! Food was bland. Four onion soup tasted like it came from a can; reuben sandwich sat on the plate too long before it was delivered - very soggy on one side and not very good. Wait staff appeared overwhelmed and not attentive. Restaurant decor tired and old. Had high expectations of good pub food, watching a great hockey game, and relaxing. Instead, we ate quickly, and left as soon as possible. There are plenty of other options on the Island - would not recommend this establishment.
We had reservations although the restaurant was pretty empty. Hostess was nice and sat us right away. We waited with our menus while two waitresses sat and talked with customers at the bar and at a nearby table. After being ignored for 10-12 minutes we got up and left.
Service was awful, soup and salad cane after the dinners, no spoons were served with the soup, no ketchup or mustard served, I had to get up and get from the service table after a passing waitress, not ours refused to bring some saying 'I'm not your waitress'. The musicians was so loud you could not hear the person next to you. The food was good and I know they are getting settled in to their new location but I won't be back this year.
Please sign in to record your input. Thanks!
Report this review as inappropriate?
If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate.