We had a wonderful meal before attending the Pinstripe Bowl. Our waiter Steve did a great job of describing menu items and steaks. Steaks were cooked to perfection.
We came here to eat before the Pinstripe Bowl. It was a bit pricey but the food was really good! We recommend the Signature Bacon appetizer. The service was great and we were even able to leave and come back to the bar later. Great experience!
I rarely complain. The nicest part about the dinner was the Yankees won, the drinks were good and the ambiance was different than any other steak house we had been to; it was in Yankee Stadium. Other than that it was awful. The service was terrible, the food was terrible. The staff was clearly not on their game the night we went.
I was truly disappointed and will not return.
I met my friends before one of the home play-off games at the restaurant. We had a ver nice meal. The staff is very friendly and it was a terrific evening. Especially, since the Yankees won!
Over all the first time experience there was good. The place was comfortable but the seating was tight and it was a bit loud and hard to carry a conversation. The ribeye steak was what I was hoping for and it was perfect! We started with french onion soup and I was a bit disappointed with the taste of that, but the spinach salad was excellent! Our service was terrific and I was glad that we were not rushed through dinner. I would recommend this place for anyone wanting to enjoy a special occasion dinner here, it was kind of pricey but but expected for a NYC steakhouse. I would come back again!
Went for a Yankee playoff game ....Packed...Very busy...Seated promptly...Bacon slab overdone...Delmonico Steak was pretty small for the money, creamed spinach tasteless...The server brought out two Delmonico steaks one got my wife medium and got me medium rare...I asked her did she have them right and she assured me yes...Well guess what WRONG ....
Just ok. Been to a lot of steakhouses and my expectations were high. Steak was OK. Service was very good. As expected prices were high, which would be fine if steak was awesome.
Best food at the stadium but not the best steak around.
Overall a very good experience once we were able to get in. Our reservation was for 4:30 (gametime 7:38) and gates were not open. I was told to wait in line at Gate 6. After waiting 35 minutes I finally found someone (after speaking with 8 various staff members) to escort us through the line and in the stadium. Specific instructions directing us to a designated entrance would have been nice. Not the great experience I was hoping to have with my client.
How do they not have this process down by now???
Premium price for poor execution...your customers are affluent and have choices....
Yankees Wild Card Game! Amazing food, amazing service... when Didi hit the game tying 3 run homer, servers cooks and customers all went crazy! Was an amazing atmosphere.
Great steaks !!! Hands down. The food is always excellent. Amazing wine list. Wonderful waitstaff. If you’re going to go to Yankee Stadium, you must have dinner here first. The only downside is it’s always extremely loud it, you always need a reservation, and the Hostess staff is usually preoccupied, don’t care, too busy not caring or just don’t see you to even bother to give you a table. They know that they’re the only game in town and they have their noses as far up in the air as possible. It’s sad in this day and age that you have to spend hundreds and hundreds of dollars to go to a baseball game only to be ignored at the steakhouse that’s going to cost you another few hundred. There’s team support, then there is getting ripped off by the stadium.
Friendliest hostest and awesome server!
Great food and awesome venue!
Cannot say enough.....food was delicious and service was beyond anywhere else I have eaten....
Great food. Steak and crabcake were excellent. A little pricey, but we were the Yankee Stadium and expected it. Did not rush us, but was not slow either. Must try at least once, well worth it.
Gift card from our children. Fun time. Good food! We'd go again. Portions were large and we shared the entree and the salad.
The food is delicious but this restaurant is very expensive. My sister and I have had dinner here before but our bill this year was higher than its ever been. We like to treat ourselves once a year but at $400 for that two of us it may have been our last year!
Really enjoyed the bacon especially. Way tooooo noisy.
comfortable place to have a good meal before and during the game
Been to NYY Steak many times after Yankee games...always great service, great food, great wine and great atmosphere. This was our first trip where we found our usual buffalo mozz. appetizer "upgraded" to burrata...just beautiful. You can count on us to visit NYY Steak many more times in the future. 9In fact, we visit your site in Manhattan whenever in the neighborhood).
Great place to eat before or after a Yankee game.
Amazing!!! I had lunch here with a few clients and he staff was great. The food was delicious and the options were perfect.
we had two young children with us and the manager offered them ice cream for dessert which was a very nice gesture.
thye made us feel special.
It was great to eat a nice dinner at yankee stadium it was the first time I been to the new stadium They had great pictures on the wall of past Yankees the surf and turf was delicious but the home made chocolate cake for dessert was off the hook
Excellent pregame meal and the service was great. It is pricy but what isn't when you go to a professional sporting event these days. No question I'll be coming back.
had delicious Lobster Tails. The service was good. The atmosphere was relaxing
Our server was busy talking with the bar tender and we sat with dirty dishes for some time. My son never got his side dish and we were pressed for time so we let it go. The food was good but the service at our table not so much
This place, located within Yankee Stadium, was absolutely outstanding, in all aspects of service, food quality, food presentation, appearance, and cleanliness. The only negative aspect of this experience was the cost of dining. Be prepared to spend $100 per person, including tip, for 1 appetizer, 1 entree, and 1 side; no drinks.
Outstanding food and service throughout. It is a bit pricey but the quality is spot on. I've been there many times and it was flawless...again!
Staff was friendly, professional, efficient. Service was excellent, without being overbearing or intrusive. Comfortable, attractive ambiance, with lovely table settings, blue leather armchairs, white tablecloths. The food was delicious.. Chipotle butter and blue cheese butter were wonderful touches for the warm, soft, pretzel dough rolls. Filet mignon cooked to perfection. It needed nothing for flavor. Cheesecake was a generous, delicious portion. Garlic potatoes the creamiest I've ever had. We didn't want alcohol, but the iced tea was brewed fresh and ice cold. The restaurant was full, but the noise level was perfectly comfortable for conversation. The entire experience was enjoyable beyond our expectations.
Great pregame meal! Interesting people watching. Great service
This was my second time at NYY Steak and the experience was just as good as the first. We were celebrating my husband's birthday prior to going to the game and our server Curtis was extremely efficient and knowledgeable about the menu and made recommendations that did not disappoint. I requested a different table than the one we were assigned and were immediately shown to one with a better view (not that there is a bad seat in the place, we just wanted one adjacent to a window.) Curtis and the other young man attending our table anticipated all of our needs, filling glasses and clearing the table as soon as our courses were done. The food was wonderful, everyone at the table was very pleased with their meal. My filet was done to perfection; my only regret was that I couldn't finish it, a result of having indulged too much in the seafood tower appetizer, pricey but worth every bit of the expense. It's a treat to dine there but it is a fantastic venue to mark a special occasion.
The service was excellent. The food was fabulous. Great pregame dinner very relaxing. Would recommend this to a friend.
This was 4th trip to NYY Steak. It is most definitely one of my top places to dine. Highest quality of meat and fish prepared extraordinarily by the chefs. I recommend window seating by the bar.
After an initial experience when it first opened that did not go well (multiple kitchen errors), this time everything was fine. The food came out quickly and was very good. The salads are very large and can easily be shared. The sides are decent size also. A bit of a wait (a lot of late arrivals -- it is Yankee Stadium and you do have to park), but overall a good experience.
My son and I were traveling to NYC from San Francisco, he goes to college here. We had a great meal before the Yanks-Red Sox game. Had a great conversation with the couple seated next to us who graciously shared their appetizers with us. Food was incredible, we will be back!
I gave my husband tickets to see the Yankees for his birthday and we had dinner prior to the game. We sat at the bar and had a fabulous dinner and the service was outstanding.
Perfect t way to top off a Yankees win!! Great dining experience along with winderful food and drinks! Thank you
Eating at here at the stadium always makes the game that much more special. And you never miss a thing with all the tv's.
It's my favorite restaurant. Food is magnificent. Large portions and great taste.
Made a reservation for 6:30. Got seated at 7:00. Bathroom facilities inadequate for size of restaurant. Food good but for the price, you should get nothing less. Great prelude to the ballgame. Very noisy. Excellent steaks. Shrimp cocktail - best jumbo shrimp cocktail year after year.