Permanently Closed - NYY Steak Midtown- New York Yankees Steakhouse
Restaurants you may also like
Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC
Ruth's Chris Steak House - New York City - Midtown
Mastro's Steakhouse - New York City
Our establishment combines sporty and modern with elevated cuisine that pays homage to traditional Steakhouse fare, and a dining experience that lets you catch sporting events in style.
One of our favorite steak houses. Was sad to see it close up as we dined on their last evening. Guess that explained why the service was bad and the food wasn’t as good. Still, no excuse to not be your best for your good patrons. Disappointing to end on that note.
It's a shame NYY Steak on 51st Street is closing on Sunday, 8/26/18
Good portions of food for the price and fulfilling food. Looking forward to next visit.
Excellent steakhouse, lived up to expectations (Highly ranked on Open Table). Steaks perfectly cooked at medium rare with an excellent sauce "au poivre". Sadly we were informed that this branch is closing in 2 weeks, so you will need to hurry if you want to add this to your list of places you have eaten.
It was a terrible experience. Nobody told me that air cionditiining was not working when I called the restaurant on Saturday August 18 to change reservation time from 5:00 PM to 5:30 PM. Food was terrible. It was very hot in the restaurant. There were 2 portable fans that were working inadequately. I heard that restaurant was closing next week. That's why restaurant did not care. We are very good customers of NY Steakhouse at the midtown location and also at Yankee Stadium. We also are very good customers at the Hard Rock Cafe at Yankee Stadium. Can somebody please call me at 516-770-5926 to discuss. Thank you.
Great food and Service! Just didnt like being close to the bar.
Wow! We went here for restaurant week and it did NOT disappoint. The medium well steak was too damn good! The chicken tasted as great as the regular menu warm and buttery. The mash potatoes didn’t even makes sense why it was so good. Our waiter( ) was attentive, informative & gave us a samples of beers and wines before we made our choice.
The entire experience is one that we’ll never forget. NYY steak served us well.
Restaurant week summer 18
The Manager greeted me at the door. Had a reservation and was seated right away. The food is amazing, prices are reasonable. Our waiter Maurice was very nice and made sure to keep checking In. Exceptional service will go again.
Food was amazing. Scallops were cooked perfectly.
This was my second time dining at NYY Steak and I loved it. Their steaks are so delicious and cooked to perfection. The mac and cheese was delicious! My party also enjoyed their meals. The ambiece was perfect. Our server was fantastic and very attentive. The entire staff was friendly and welcoming. The whole vibe of the restaurant was great. I will certainly be back!
Sorry to hear they were closing. Great meal, great staff
Perfect spot for any Yankees fan that would enjoy excellent food and service!! Highly recommended.
Outstanding service, and the steaks are exceptional.
The food was delicious, and the presentation was beautiful. The chef went out of his way to be creative with the dishes. We didn't expect that.
We had suggested NYY Steakhouse to our friends from out of town who are huge Yankee fans. We thought they would love it because of the memorabilia. They also really loved the food.
Great steaks, terrific seafood dishes and also beautiful vegetable appetizers and soups. The presentation of the gazpacho was totally unique.
Good steak house. We came here for lunch with friends family. Initially wanted to order from the prefix menu I saw on their website, but the waitress said it was only for dinner. A little disappointed. But we had great lunch, although it was expensive.
For a die hard Yankees fan this place is a dream. Made reservation for my wedding anniversary. The food was amazing a bit pricey but worth every cent. My husband had the beef tortilla soup. It tasted just like a soupy taco sooo good! I had the crab cake for starters so tasty. We both had the fillet mignon which was so tender pure butter! The sides were a bit pricey but once the came out i understood why they are HUGE !!! Overall great experience, we even got a tour of the place after dinner! The place used to be a bank and the vault is still there being used as a private dining area!!!! Super cool! Will definitely recommend for a special occasion. Huge plus if you are a Yankees fan so much interesting memorabilia!!
Very polite staff. Delicious food. Moderate prices since the food was so great! Nice to experience and learn Yankee history while enjoying a fantastic meal in the heart of Manhattan.
We had a great meal and our server Ashley made it wonderful !
The NYY Steak House is a must stop if you are visiting NYC. The service, food, and management is top notch. It’s worth every penny, would recommend to friends to have dinner at least once in there lifetime.
The best place to eat in the heart of Manhattan
Fantastic experience. Food was great and just an overall great experience. Will definitely go back!
We had a delicious meal. The service was excellent. It did not take long for our meal to arrive. Everything was perfect.
Amazing!!!!! The best steak I’ve ever had once again! Plus the Yankees won!!!!
It was amazing, we went there for my husband’s birthday, and we cannot wait to go there again 😉 The service was outstanding, the food delicious and and overall wonderful evening. Special thanks to Hiren 😊
Everything was fantastic ;)
Service and atmosphere are great. Had the Dry Aged burger (along with a colleague) and it was terrible. Tasted somewhat “gamey”. Would stick with the steaks next time (which there may only a next since it is NYY related).
Bar is hectic but food is good and a bargain. Yankee cab is great for the price!
Beautiful restaurant with amazing food! Brought my fiancee here post engagement and they congratulated us with champagne at the end of the meal!!
The staff at the Yankee Steakhouse was overwhelmingly charming. They went out of their way to make sure that we had the best experience possible. I can't wait to return. Oh and the food was excellent too.
Good food and drinks and service was excellent.
We try to dine at the NYY Steakhouse whenever we are in Manhattan. We always know that the service and the food
will be excellent.
Great meal steaks cooked to perfection and we really enjoyed their duck fat potatoes and brownie sundae
The service was amazing, but the food didn’t hit the spot. I got the bison strip steak, which was the special, it was chewy and oversalted. We had a show to go to, so I made do with what I’d ordered. Loved the service and ambiance though!
Very nice high end Steak house/Sports bar.
lots of Yankee memorabilia
Very friendly staff service. The truffle parm fries were delicious!
THIS PLACE IS LIT I Love it I got to see so many contracts from different players and explore a vault in the resteraunt food is so good i wish to come back again
Wait staff excellent
Chef was wonderful as well
The food here was unbelievable.
The maple bacon that you have is better than Luger's
Permanently Closed - NYY Steak Midtown- New York Yankees Steakhouse is rated 4.6 stars by 1011 OpenTable diners.