NYY Steak will be open from 10:30AM-2:30PM and 5PM-10PM on Sunday, May 13 for Mother's Day. Reservations recommended.
Sunday, May 13, 2018
We have been regulars here for many years.
You grow to expect consistently great steaks.
Service was excellent - but the delmonico and porterhouse steaks were bland with little or no seasoning. Meat was tough and tasteless.
Second time this has happened this year.
Three strikes and you know what happens.
Nathan was awesome and the food was wonderful. Never a disappointment! Well worth the $.
I love this place! I come here a lot and usually eat/drink in the bar area. However, this time we decided to get a table. I met up with a couple friend. We order 2 Stone crabs...just 2, not 2 each, but 2 for an appetizer. When the bill came, they charged me $75 EACH = $150 for both!!! That’s ASTRONOMICAL! For 2 Stone Crabs! When I questioned it, the server (which was great, but should warn people how expensive Stone Crabs are there when people order them) said that was the price. I was completely shocked to say the least! I love the place and hated to give the value a low score, but $75 for a single stone crab is WAYYYY out of whack! I spend a lot of money there, but will be more careful next time if I go back. End result...don’t be afraid to ask for prices.
First experienced this great restaurant on Easter. Then returned a week later for my son's birthday. My three sons and I had a great meal. Our server, Mike, was very knowledgeable and helpful. Service is wonderful, and the food is outstanding. The filets are top quality and prepared exactly as requested. All four of us were very happy with our meal and will definitely return. I've been telling friends it's a great place to experience great food, excellent service, and an enjoyable experience all around. I can't wait to go back.
Superb for the Money. We have been so many times and coming back with pleasure over and over again.
the Sunday Brunch is worth it. As always the food was great and the service was
excellent. The only thing I do recommend is not to be late for your reservations.
Theur steaks are usually of course amazing;my Delmonico was not cooked as well as usual. It’s very loud in there. And it would be nice if they added some new sides maybe some nice vegetables. But overall we always enjoy our experience and have very, very good service
Fantastic restaurant, very attentive service, excellent wine collection, always willing to accommodate any way possible…..Highly recommended.
Amazing food!!! Very pricey but delicious
Everything was great!
Food was good but service was not on point tonight. This is my 3rd dining experience with them and was not happy with our service.
We went to NYY Steak to celebrate my husbands birthday with our kids. Everything was Amazing!
Food was wonderful! The restaurant had a very strong smoke smell from the casino - it was awful for my allergies. The service was great, very attentive. The bacon appetizer was AMAZING! Steak was good, but Ruth’s Chris is better. Very expensive!!
Our waitress Manuela should be the template for which other servers are trained,Oh , she gets it! Unlike your manage who lacks personality
Had the porterhouse and the wife had crab legs. Service as perfect, food was on time and the taste was worth the price. Couldn't have asked for a better start to date night. Would go every weekend if I could.
Awesome and I’m going back again
Pedro and the mushrooms were amazing! He was very attentive, understood the menu, and offered great suggestions! We will definitely return
As always very good
Great food and service.
I had a wonderful birthday dinner!
The bacon appetizer was excellent, Caesar salad very tasty. The filet was delicious. My Delmonico steak was ordered medium rare and the steak came out medium well. When I said something to our waiter he disagreed with me and told me the steak was perfect. Luckily the manager was nearby and he completely agreed with me that it was terribly over cooked and offered to replace it. The waiter was terrible and rude. I would not return there since there are other 1st class steak restaurants in the area.
Had a birthday celebration and a company appreciation dinner. The meet was absolutely tough as nails and loaded with fat we ordered the long bone ribeye and had to return it. $494 one would expect it to melt in your mouth and it didn’t.
THE SERVICE WAS OUTSTANDING.THE FOOD WE ORDERED WS COOKED AS REQUESTED.WE WILL RETURN SOON.
Amazing as always
The smoke smell is nauseating. The food was excellent. Service great. Probably won’t come back because of smoke.
We went to NYY Steak with a party of 4 and had one of the best dining experiences. Dave and Dave were our waiters for the night and were awesome! They got every single part of everyone’s order correct, were knowledgeable of the menu, and had great recommendations. My all time favorite part of the meal was the cookies and cream dessert! ABSOLUTELY AMAZING! The dessert was large enough for four of us to share and everyone loved it. The service is always great here, but this particular trip was especially awesome!
The Delmonico was tough and hard to cut with the knives provided. The lobster bisque had more croutons than lobster. This was my 3rd time dining there and my last. The Boss would not be happy!!
What a pleasant surprise! We got there early enough to enjoy the live music in the bar area, which was separate from the dining room. The dining room was very tastefully setup and didn’t have that casino feel or smell. The only thing I found odd was the fact that they didn’t have a restroom in the restaurant, you have to walk a short distance through the casino to use the facilities. Other then that we had was a great time. Definitely will go back again.
For the past 5 years I have made it a point to dine at the NNY Steak House while vacationing in FL. I would boast that they served the most delicious and moist filet you could find. Additionally, their creamed spinach was also delicious. My husband and I met friends for dinner at the steakhouse recently. I couldn’t wait for my friends to enjoy their meals. To my disappointment the filet was not tasty and tender as it should be. I left half of the steak on my plate. I tried about a tablespoon of the spinach and that had an odd taste. Needless to say, I think the quality of the food was inferior. With only one of our party drinking wine, our food bill was 303.00. I expect to pay a tidy sum for great food. This visit however was greatly disappointing and not worth the price we paid. The wait service was very good. I do not think I will return next year.
My Husband and I absolutely love eating at NYY. We have tried other Steakhouses as we also like to try new restaurants. We always end up comparing them to NYY... then returning to NYY for our next "date night." Our favorite foods: Pretzel bread is yummy. The bacon appetizer is a MUST!! We share the Caesar Salad. We both have Filets for entrees. If Wagyu Filet (I think it's Australian) is offered, my husband orders that and loves it!! We do not order sides or dessert.
The Brunch is always a fantastic experience. Excellent food paired with superior service.
Everything was amazing!! From the table we were escorted to, to the spectacular dessert presentation at the end of our delicious dinner. Kudos to Nathan and Alex for excellent service!! Great restaurant experience!!
Three out of six steaks were over cooked... took awhile to remake them. Otherwise all food was great.
Amazing! Traveled the world and has the best steak experience. NYY is by far top 5! Worth every penny! The bacon appetizer...to die for!!!
Always a pleasant dining experience and steaks, veal and lamb exceptional. Service is a 10
Awesome food! The best creamed spinach I've ever had. The escargot was a little bland but cooked properly. I ordered my steak medium rare and it came out Pittsburgh. My waitress promptly exchanged it and the manager came over and bought me a drink.
Although their hostess leaves a lot to be desired with her unfriendly/rude attitude.
The service and food were spot on, like usual.
Anniversary dinner, food was superb, service left much to be desired.
Birthday but they neglected to mention it.
We were a few minutes late due to traffic