Food was delicious. Had the French braised beef onion soup which was so good, I’d go back just for that!!
Never had a negative experience in the multiple times I have gone. Keenan was an awesome server who was personable, knowledgeable, and overall nice guy.
The bread and dipping oil were the best part of the meal!
Food is always good, love the variety. Service has been exceptional, very friendly
Always a great meal and great service. I've been to this location many times and have never walked out without a smile on my face
Kristen (sp) was the real reason for the high rating!
Once again NYAJ did not disappoint. Our meals were very good and service was great. Will definitely go back before PPAC again.
We love dining at Joe's. The food is consistently good, and the wait staff are excellent. The only reason I didn't give 5 stars for overall, is that we had a bit of a wait on drinks. The bar staff was backed up with orders, apparently. I appreciate the birthday gift I get each year from Joe's!
NYAJ is one of my favorites. However, on this visit the service was lacking. Thank goodness the food was great. Would still go back, probably just an off night
Our lunch was mediocre at best. The tomato basil soup which has always been my favorite was watered down. My husband's BBQ meatloaf was overcooked as were the carrots. The meatloaf needed a steak knife to cut through it. My wedge salad with steak was spoiled by tough, gristly steak. We have been disappointed with NYAJ's enough times now, especially at this location, that we may have to reconsider a return visit.
Ambiance was casual and service was great!
Great place for a casual meal. Good selection of food and drinks. Great service as well
Used open table. Arrived on time. Additional 15 minute wait for table. Service was attentive. Food was great. Good beer selection
The service was great, I was disappointed with the food. Just not as tasty as it has been in the past
Our Manager was exceptional, we have been there before and he was then also!
I don't know his name, but he is a wonderful person and manager! Thank you!!!!!!
I don’t expect much when I go to Joes anymore. When they first opened it was pretty good. Not so much lately. The best thing they have is the bread and oil they give you at first.
Went there two days ago on a date with my girlfriend. I didn’t want to go there, but she did.
I’ll start by saying the service was great! Don’t remember her name, but our server was very attentive. It was busy at the time, but we still got excellent service. The drinks were also very good.
The food, not so much! I ordered a pork chop with risotto. I asked for it to be well done. It wasn’t. The risotto was SO dry, it could’ve passed for stuffing. $20 meal wasn’t worth $10.
Absolute last time I go there for anything other than a pizza. Two thumbs down for Less than Average Joes!
We had a 6:30 reservation yet we were put on a list when we arrived on time. We waited 25 minutes before being seated. It didn’t seem to matter that we made a reservation at all. The sirloin steak was cut up in pieces when served yet we ordered and paid for a steak. It was more like tips than the full sirloin. Waitress never asked if I wanted a 6 or 9oz glass of wine and was charged $15+ for a glass. Disappointed this time out.🙁
great experience, generous portions, great drinks, couldn't finish all the food. have been there several times and always outstanding.
Love NYAJ. Food is great! Never disappointed!
The BBQ meatloaf was fantastic. The chicken Parm was sub par, quite rubbery and disappointing. Overall the experience was good.
Always good fresh food. Comparable food to Federal Hill.
I don't know why I bothered to make a reservation because when we arrived at our appointed time the hostess put our name at the bottom of the list. I gave the service poor because of the hostess not the server. When you have a reservation the restaurant should not serve 5 parties before you.
Great food, good prices, good service
We have been going to Not Your Average Joe's for Years. The manager was incredibly attentive and the food was fabulous. The last few times we have been, we have not seen the same manager, the food has not been as good, and the service has been slow. We are going less and less often.
If it wasn't the best Salmon I have ever had it was pretty damn close to the best.
Always enjoy our dining experience at Not Your Average Joes! Enjoy their bread and spiced olive oil in particular. Also their simply grilled dishes, especially the salmon, and choice of two sides is something we really enjoy! Their Key Lime Pie is the best I’ve ever had!! Great food - good service!
We had a delicious barbeque meatloaf meal with grilled carrots & mashed potatoes....comfort food! My spaghetti squash with veggie sauce was creative and interesting, but a bit salty. Our key lime pie was sweet and a perfect ending to the meal. Our server was very sweet & capable and we had a nice casual night.
The restaurant was extremely busy due to loss of power in nearby neighborhoods. But our server was excellent and the food was great. Chicken in chicken piccata a tad too tough, but otherwise perfect!
Appetizer,came out then with in 2 minutes,meals came out,felt rushed ,server was very nice but just w
If it wasn’t for the service and manager I’d never go back how can they serve a $20 Niciose salad on a flat plate anyway I’m not downing the food and I’ll be back but Joe’s get yourselves back to where you started and serve your wholesome fresh food .. I’ll be back because of the outstanding service hopefully your food will be as good
Whenever I go I am confident that I will get good food! And I do!!!!
All four of us ordered the chicken parmigiana on "sneak preview" night. It's going on the seasonal menu on Oct. 18, and I just want to say that I hope it goes on the regular menu forever! It was OUTSTANDING! Three out of four of us ordered it with mashed potatoes, instead of the pasta that it came with and all of us were very happy with our choices. Not Your Average Joe's does NOT disappoint. They go out of their way to accommodate you in every way possible and their food is DELICIOUS! I highly recommend them!
We have been enthusiastically supporting nyaj for decades. This visit was a disappointment. The food was mediocre at best. The manager removed the charge of my Caesar salad. It was by far the weakest, sorriest Caesar I’d ever had. Zero anchovy flavor. Zero taste to the dressing. Droopy lettuce. Zero croutons. ( in its place was served a strange piece of pizza crust ... imagine a discarded dry edge of crust. That’s what it looked like). The October fest sauerbraten was passable. Spatzel served was late, it was rather cold and also blah.
Service was ok but not what it once was. I’m hoping this experience was an anomaly.
Made a reservation and they were right on it. The girls that greeted us were very sweet and very helpful. The waitress that served us was very knowledgeable and made sure we were happy with the arrangement, in which we were. The food was great, especially the freshly baked bread and oil/dip for it.
This visit was for the Octoberfest / beer dinner, which was excellent in every way…..the pace of the meal was perfect, the beers were all very good to excellent and the staff was outstanding with lots of laughs and good conversation it was a great time.
Great Oktoberfest Beer Dinner. Will be back next year!
Actually went this time for the oktober fest menu. Pork schnitzel was nice and battered and mustard sauce was very good.
Food was awful. Steak tips full of nerves and fat, bernaise was sour and the Coconut Rice was dry.
I usually love Not Your Average Joe's. I tend to use them for business lunches and dinner with my wife from time to time. This is the second tough experience we had in a row. It might just be this location. We had a $25 card we used because management responded to our issue the very last time we were here with an invitation back. My wife didn't want me to say anything because of that fact while we were there. Her meal, steak tips, were way too charred and there were what we can only describe as pieces of bone in her meal. It appeared like pebbles. She removed them but we were turned off by it. We will most likely not go to this location soon but still like NYAJ. I personally would like a few more entre choices on the menu.
We met a niece there, who was in from New Hampshire. It was so nice to chat over a delicious dinner and wine & to be able to hear each other, easily. We had an excellent waitress & the food, as usual, was phenomenal!