Nearby points of interest
Nearby points of interest
About Not Your Average Joe's Randolph
Not Your Average Joe's Kitchen & Bar offers a menu inspired by American cuisine. Its menu is stylish, contemporary and includes fresh oysters, gourmet pizzas, tacos and a variety of burgers. During a daily Happy Hour at Not Your Average Joe's Kitchen & Bar, diners can also enjoy both drink and appetizer specials.
Not Your Average Joe's Randolph is conveniently located on Mazzeo Drive, minutes off the highway from Route 24. Stop in and see us after an afternoon at Mojitos Country Club, an evening at the Showcase Cinema de Lux Randolph, or after a game at TJO Sports Facility. The Courtyard by Marriot Boston Stoughton is also right up the road for any hotel accommodation needs you may have.
Randolph, MA 02368
Contemporary American, Comfort Food, American
Hours of Operation:
Sunday 11:30a 9:00p
Monday 11:30a 9:30p
Tuesday 11:30a 10:00p
Wednesday 11:30a 10:00p
Thursday 11:30a 10:00p
Friday 11:30a 10:30p
Saturday 11:30a 10:30p
$30 and under
AMEX, Discover, MasterCard, Visa
We over our XL Style Party menu for large orders for the office, team, or whole family! Visit us online to see all of our menus, including our Party Menu!
The lot outside our restaurant is public, free, and spacious!
Private Party Facilities:
Whether celebrating a special occasion with family and friends or hosting a corporate event, Not Your Average Joe's - Randolph can accommodate all of your special event needs. Choose from three different Prix Fixe lunch and dinner menus, or order à La Carte!
Private Party Contact:
Allen Frazier: (888) 460-3816
Bar Dining, Bar/Lounge, Beer, Cocktails, Counter Seating, Full Bar, Gluten-free Menu, Happy Hour, Non-Smoking, Weekend Brunch, Wheelchair Access, Wine
Special Events & Promotions:
We host all different events for the Randolph community! Happy hours? Check. Baby shower? Done. Engagement party? You got it! Give us a call, and let us know what you're looking for, and we'll figure out how we can help. We offer catering, are great for birthdays, and have a host of allergy-friendly options for anyone in your group.
We also host our own special events throughout the year as well! From wine dinners to fundraisers, beer dinners to brunches, we have it all. Check back on our website event page or on here to stay up to date on all of our upcoming special events!
Send a Gift Card
Buy now and send it instantly by email, or print a card to give in person.
Not Your Average Joe's Randolph Ratings and Reviews
Ten of us gathered to have a mini reunion. The waitress was very professional handling such a large group. The food was excellent. The highlight were the tuna wantons, sushi grade tuna served on crisp wontons. The rest of the meals were excellent as well. I had the quesadillas which were well prepared, tasty and fresh flavors. Others enjoyed a wide variety of offerings from steak tips, to rosemary skewered scallops to simple Caesar salad or grilled hamburger.
Every possible mistake was made from the time we walked in the door. Our wait resin was having s totally incompetent night. We were only 3 people. She forgot to place my entree order. After my salad, nothing. Then they rushed my order through, so rushed that they served me a cold raw hamburger with a slice of cold hard cheddar cheese. The manager saved the day. He was as nice and charming as could be. He insisted on serving us desserts that were so delicious, the main course I sent back could not possibly have been nearly as good. He saved the day!
Btw he had to call Open Table because the host evidently did not make the notification that we showed up for the reservation!
Service was quick and attentive. All of the staff we interacted with had great personalities. Not Your Average Joe's is always attentive to my daughter's Celiac Disease and has tasty options that are gluten-free. Each of our meals was very fresh tasting and cooked perfectly.
I really enjoyed my time dining at Not Your Average Joe's. The atmosphere is very nice and cozy. I appreciated that the people were patient as I waited for my 6 other friends to show up. I had made a reservation for 7 and my table was ready within 5 minutes! Loved my salad! Everyone enjoyed their food. Highly recommend this restaurant!
We came in for the Oktoberfest menu which was advertised as THROUGH 10/9. We were told when we sat down that it ended on 10/8 but that the chef did have some sauerbraten available. Two out of four people in my party came for the pork schnitzel and the one that ordered sauerbraten was very disappointed. The sauerbraten he was served was clearly a cut that the chef was avoiding serving during the festival... The other three people in our party of four were very disappointed in their meals. Our waitress was less than attentive... it was just overall not a great experience and we were celebrating a birthday. We're really going to think twice in the future about patronizing NYAJ's for a special occasions
We had a wonderful time at lunch on Columbus Day. Our server, Tenzin, did a fabulous job. She was pleasant, friendly and attentive. The food was terrific. My daughter is gluten free and the choices are excellent and delicious. A special mention to the manager Alan. There was a small confusion with our reservation but he went out of his way to make sure we were happy with our table and checked on us several times during meal. Alan provided excellent customer service and was fun to talk with. Overall great job. We will be back.
The menu seems to have changed. I could deal with that but to food was extremely salty. Both my husband and I commented on it while there but we had had an appetizer already so we brought the meals home. I just tried to eat the leftovers and they are inedible. I got steak tips and he got a pork special. It’s too bad. This chain has always been a good one.
I made a reservation here for 7pm. Got there at 6:45pm, no one else was waiting, so we were the first to wait to be seated. The waiting area filled up quickly after. THREE other parties were seated before us, plus a party that came in at 7pm for a 7:15pm reservation! I do not understand NYAJ's seating order but I do know I will not go here again or use opentable because clearly reservations are not respected.
This is a go to place for us, close to home and generally reliable for good, well prepared food at a reasonable price. I wanted to try the Buttermilk Fried Chicken on the new BBQ menu. I ordered that with mashed potatoes and green beans. The chicken was very dry, not at all moist. The coating was uneven and the pieces that I had seemed to have more bones than meat. There mashed potatoes were like cement. They were luke warm and had pretty much congealed into one big hard lump. Green beans were fine. Let's just say that it was a disappointment.
The place wasn't at all busy. Our server, who didn't do any thing wrong, didn't really do any of the little things that we have taken for granted here. She was more interested in fooling around at the reception counter with another employee and was leaning over the end of the bar watching what I guess was a TV behind the bar. Just not what we've come to expect at this restaurant location. We usually come for lunch, not dinner, and the place is much busier then than it was on this night.
We'll probably still go for lunch, but I think it will be a long time before we go back for dinner.
My previous visits were much better. Unfortunately, this time I found 2 bones in just a few bites of salmon. I was offered a new piece but we were trying to make a special engagement at Showcase Cinemas, ie; 1 performance only, and didn't have time to wait. The manager took my meal off the bill and wanted to give us free desserts as well, so the service was great. The coconut grits were smooth, not as coconut-infused as one would like, and my green beans were good quality. They did heat some pita bread for me because I can't eat their onion-laced focaccia or onion-laced gluten-free rolls.
My husband's lobster roll was pretty good, he said, but had lots of mayo. My Caesar was very good, as I love the lemony dressing but the chicken in my quesadilla tasted dry and kind of old, not seasoned or spicy as advertised.
I think the good has gone downhill in the past year or so.
We have been dining here for years....this time I was so disappointed. I ordered the Lobster Roll & asked for it to be served on lettuce instead of bread.
There was so much mayonnaise & very little lobster, that it was hard to distinguish between the coleslaw & the lobster. I tasted some of it and had the waitress take it away.
Can't believe that the price was $19!!!
Not sure what's going on there, but certainly NYAJ's I enjoyed dining at.
Sorry...just can't give it a good rating and hope my review helps with improvements.
We have been to NYAJ's in Randolph many times. This experience will prevent us from returning. The restaurant was dirty - front door loaded with sticky fingerprints and the ladies room needed serious attention. Two of our meals were over cooked and barely edible. Our server apologized. No wonder the restaurant was empty!!
The service was excellent and the wait staff as well as the manager were very attentive. I wish I could say I loved my lobster roll but I really did not find it to be all that appetizing and portions have definitely become smaller but overall a good experience.
Please sign in to record your input. Thanks!
Report this review as inappropriate?
If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate.