Server Christine was wonderful, food was delicious, timing was perfect!
Usually we love it here but not this time. There were 6 of us for a birthday dinner. Food wasn't up to normal standards and we waited a while for things. Our waitress was great though.
This is in my neighborhood , close to home. I've said this before, at lunch the food and service are really good. In the evening, for dinner, not so much. Place wasn't busy but the server was distracted by something. 4 people ate and 3 ordered the cheeseburger special. Fries came cold, one of us asked for hot and the server brought 1 hot portion. Tiniest burger I've seen since Joe and Nemo's. A couple of other requests from the server and she totally forgot.
As I said, lunch is good but this is the last time we'll go for dinner.
Even if it is busy, wait is usually only about 15 minutes. Food is consistent and creative. Prices are very reasonable. Bread and olive oil very tasty.
Typical good food. A smaller version of the other NYAJs. Sandy provided excellent service and got us out quick. (We had to get back to pick up our daughter from soccer).
Highly recommend this place
Very nice local eating establishment
Ideal spot for a family get together. Varied menu, decent food.
We went for Easter brunch. The eggs Benedict was delicious and so were the mimosas. It is our favorite place to eat. Love their Monday one buck shuck too.
The bread & oil is delicious. However, we got the chicken parmigiana. The chicken tasted like it was frozen. Not good at all. If I go again, maybe I’d get a salad.
NYAJ's Randolph is our "go to" neighborhood spot. We're always pleased with the food and service!
Great overall dining experience. It's a good idea to have reservations even if you are going early. It's easy to make it online.
Been going here for 17 years, convenient, and we’re always happy
Nice quiet neighborhood restaurant would recommend highly
Another great night at Not Your Average Joe's. Thank you Lexx, you were fantastic
This has become a regular go to place ! Highly recommend
Allen the GM and Sasaya were great! We’re very pleased to have a great restaurant like this around us.
Loved our waitress!!!
Family outing after shopping
It was busy, appetizer came out after meal was delivered. Salad came out at same time as meal. Huge bummer but mngr comped the app for mistake. Food was mediocre, tasted great but was not hot. Waitress was very nice.
We went there during the blackout. They sat us pretty clean se to our reservation for 6 even though they were banged out. Waitress was excellent. Food was well prepared and varied menu appealed to all. Round tables were good for conversation.
They did not honor the reservation, and didn't seat us timely. We will not be back. We ended up getting a seat at the bar after half hour and almost missed the movie because they didn't honor the reservation.
Everything was great
This is our favorite place to go. Chill at the bar, split an app and a pizza.
Joe's is always great - very dependable - we've likely been to a Joe's well over a hundred times in the last twenty years
All food is made from scratch. Menu changes on a regular basis.
Waitstaff is very professional
Brought out of town guests on Saturday night. Everyone loved the pizza
The service was excellent! The manager went out her way to accommodate my party of seven, and the food was great!
It was my wife’s birthday that we shared with friends. Our waiter was training a new waitress and they were very good handling our requests. The shrimp and scallop fettuccine with lobster sauce was excellent as was the haddock and steak tips with wedge salad. The complimentary carrot cake was very good.
I really like Not Your Average Joe's but I was not impressed when I went to the Randolph location. We were seated in a booth for 7 people which not ideal. Thankfully, we were accommodated and got moved to a better table. It was nice that the waiter gave us two appetizers on the house, but they took a long time to come out. We also had to tell our waiter to take it off the bill because it was put on there. The food did not taste that great because I think the restaurant was rushing food to each table, which was unusual. I will continue to go to this restaurant, but I will probably go to the location in Westwood instead.
I’d like to rate five stars but “outstanding” is a strong word. Overall was very good, though. I was disappointed they didn’t have what I had had previously. The pork shank was no longer on the menu. That was a favorite of mine. I chose the meatloaf hoping it would be a dish they could be most creative with and it was delicious., but still meatloaf. My husband had broiled scallops that were delicious. Service was on point, though we were never asked how our meal was. Bring the pork shank back!
We had a party of 11 with reservations at 8:30PM. We were seated when we arrived at 8:15PM without any problem. The food was very good and the service was outstanding particularly since we were a large party. Would definitely recommend Not Your Average Joes to anyone who wants a good value meal accompanied by excellent service.
We went there for Valentines dinner . We may presentations and we’re seated within about five minutes after arriving . The waiter did not know too much information about what was on the Valentine’s Day menu . Salmon was dry and spinach under cooked . Fillet medallions were excellent. Alcoholic beverages were great . First time at this particular location was little disappointed .
We always have a wonderful meal. It’s our favorite place to go....
Have been longtime customers of NYAJs and have always enjoyed the experience.
The food was good, it came out quick and the server was great but its too cramp that you will hear other tables' conversation which you don't want to hear. I hate knowing people's issues in life. As I said above, if you like a quick bite then go to this restaurant.
My husband had the pecan crusted salmon, it was very good. His roasted Brussels sprouts were very under cooked, he didn’t eat them because they were raw. The mash was good.
I had the New Bedford sea scallops. They were good, I have had better there, I always order the same thing.
The salad was on the Valentine’s Day menu. Beets, poached pears and goat cheese, greens. It was very good.
I enjoyed my meal very much. I have an allergy to accommodate and they were fantastic about it.
We enjoyed a birthday celebration with our friends. The waiter was very good and the special menu offered for Valentine's Day was excellent.