Nine One Five was fine, but given the other options in Key West, would not recommend and will not be returning.
Best. Pork. Tacos. Ever.
The service was fantastic as was the food. Great atmosphere with a cool upstairs bar.
Our server made great recommendations for both wine and food. Fresh pasta with black truffle was terrific as was gravalax. Roasted beef salad was filled with delicious flavors
The classic Key West historic house setting was charming, but it was the inventive food and spot-on service that brought us back for dinner two nights in a row, even though our hotel was surrounded by fine restaurants. Nine One Five elevated ordinary shrimp fettuccini to a truly exquisite level and added spicy twists that made their vegetable sides even more delicious. All of the dishes were tweaked to rise above typical expectations: carmelized sugar topped the key lime pie which was served with fresh citrus segments and house made sorbet. Amazing.
Great food & flavors. Good wine list. Nice setting away from the hustle and bustle of the other end of Duval Street.
Delicious entrees like seared scallops with risotto and wild salmon with ancient grains. Extensive choice of wines by the glass and bottle. Reservations a must during busy winter season.
Four of us were dining out several nights during our recent stay in Key West and our dinner here was the best of all. We shared all of the dishes (three appetizers, two salads, 2 entrees and dessert) and every dish was great. Service matched the quality of the meal and sitting outside on a beautiful night was icing on the cake.
This is my favorite restaurant in Key West - lively, fun vibe with excellent service and delicious food. We were seated at a table outside to enjoy a beautiful evening. We had the asparagus, brussel sprouts, calamari and taco small plates and would order all again.
Best restaurant on the island!!! The food is fabulous!!
Pasta sucked tonight.
Amazing time. Our server (Jules or Jewel) was very sweet and knowledgeable of the menu. Sat outside on a cooler night so it was perfect for people-watching while eating great food. Will definitely return the next time I’m in Key West. Get the Soul Mama Seafood Soup!
This place is simply wonderful!
Our waiter, Brian, was perfect by setting the pace with our handcrafted cocktails followed by salads, pasta and finally the bread pudding dessert with vanilla gelato.
Very cool vibe, you'll need reservations as we saw some people being turned away. We definitely will be back.
Very good food and service. The pork tacos were the best thing I had all week. Scallop with rissoto was very good as we'll. A little pricy but well worth it. great experience from top to bottom. Highly recommended!
We dined at here on the recommendation of Grand Vin Wine Bar. We were seated on the front porch which was very enjoyable. We had the roasted beet salad, filet au poivre, filet lasagna, and dessert of their version of key lime pie accompanied by grapefruit sorbet, orange and grapefruit slices. Their version of key lime pie is presented as a slim rectangular slice with a carmelized top without merengue. Everything was very delicious and the service was impeccable! I would highly recommend this restaurant if you are looking for a very special dinner.
Everything was delicious! Especially the asparagus and the scallops. It was our favorite meal in Key West over our weeklong stay. Our waitperson, Laura was attentive and helpful while giving us space to enjoy our meal. The only minor flaw was the cheapy furniture but it’s Key West.
We had a wonderful meal on the side porch. It was nice to be outside but a little removed from the street. Our food was excellent. We had a vegetarian/no dairy diner with us, and they accommodated that very well. I would recommend to friends!
Great food in a wonderful setting outdoors...highly recommended
We have been returning to this restaurant for 12 years. The menu has developed but the quality has stayed consistently high. This is always a high point of a Key West visit. Try the whole fish or the scallops!!
Fabulous meal, we ate the tapas and had plenty to eat with 2.5 entrees each...The Cheese platter they serve for dessert would have been much more appreciated as a first course! OMG the French brie was some of the best I have ever tasted! Octopus was tender, duck was superb and plentiful, beet salad was divine, brussel sprouts were not cooked enough for my taste, I would ordered something different on that one item. But everything else was divine! Don't miss it!
Jenny our waitress was amazing! Words can't express how impressed we were with her service...top notch!
Nine one five has amazing food and a great menu with lots of options! There were vegetarian options and the serve told me I could tweak many of the meals to be vegetarian! The restaurant is beautiful and has nice outdoor seating perfect for people watching on Duval st. Our serve was great and I would 100% go back!
We come to town every year and stay a week at a time. During that week we visit Nine One Five at least twice.
Always delicious. Great service. Justin was a great waiter. One of our favs in KW
We had a lovely time. Everything was good; the asparagus and butternut squash were delicious. We highly recommend this charming place!
Excellent in all ways. You can ask to do tapas style even with the main entrees. Perfect for 2 couples
The best filet on the island! Fabulous entrees. Will definitely return.
My wife and I had a lovely time at 915 - it was easily the most memorable and best dining experience of anyplace we ate at throughout the Keys. Excellent food, good vegetarian options, and perfect service. Would definitely recommend - but make sure you get reservations.
Great birthday party!
Reservations for 8:30. Seated at 9 with no apology. Seated inside between kitchen and service bar. Really noisy and unpleasant. Drink prices exorbitant. Calamari small and overdone Other small plates just average. Really disappointed as 915 came highly recommended.
Amazing. Aaron is the best!!!!
Nice selection of wine, very nice menu selections. I had scallops with risotto - the scallops were perfectly cooked along with the risotto.
Amazing meal. Our waiter was a joy and the food was exceptional. We can highly recommend this place!!
Peter was an excellent server !
My wife and I had always loved 9 1 5, ever since it opened. Food is inventive and genuine and carefully prepared. After a 10 year hiatus , we returned to Key West and it is still one of the best.
Food wasn’t brought out in a timely manner. I asked for my dish to be made spicy and was told that wasn’t possible, but they could bring me crushed red pepper. After our food was dropped off I asked for the crushed red pepper. I had to ask 3 times and over 30 minutes later it was brought to me. My boyfriend had finished his food by this time and my food was ice cold. They then took away the Brussels sprouts I was still eating. Not a good experience at all. Sad really, it could have been amazing. Obviously caught them on a bad night
Not up to expectations
Delicious we had calamari ahi tuna tartar(outstanding)half portions of shrimp fettuccine And half lobster ravioli bottle of wine everything was great reasonable we went very early and were able to sit on the porch on a beautiful evening highly recommend
This was my Birthday. We had stopped in two days prior for dinner as well and enjoyed so much that we scheduled again
Excellent alfresco dining experience, friendly outstanding service, great food, great drinks, great scenery overlooking Duval St. Highly recommend this restaurant. Will absolutely dine there again on our next visit to Key West