One of the best meals I've ever had. The lamb presentation is the best on the island and the cioppino was to die for! Great cocktails and wine too. And if you get the strawberry dessert, you get a whole show with it! Definitely worth every penny! Can't wait to go back!
Beautiful setting overlooking the grounds of the Fairmount in Maui at sunset. Service was disappointing, our first waiter was uniformed and inept; had to request a reolacement. Food was mediocore; the oysters were small and the taste was overwhelmed by a sauce as was the sea bass.
Food was great as usual. Had the daily fish special. Must have been short staffed as the service was unusually slow all night.
Excellent food and service. Waiters were very attentive. Dessert—flaming strawberries—was a real treat. Entrees were excellent and were fairly large. Highly recommend.
Our favorite restaurant on Maui.
The food was good and the atmosphere was incredible. The service was also good. Highly recommend!
Table service was super. Hostess was rude (2/16 dinner)—needs customer service training. Dinner was good, just not great. Dealing with the hostess left a bad taste in my mouth.
For me this one of my favourite places to dine!!! Seriously amazing next level Food. And we have fine dined all around the world! I highly recommend it. They made us feel special as it was our anniversary.
Absolutely! Thee best place ever! To come and celebrate birthdays with ypur family or just the two of you.. I came here for my son's birthday in January and they were a winner that I had to come back for my Birthday.. thank you Nicks Team! Excellent service, food, quality your food was so delicious ❤
The food and happy hour was great. The value of happy hour is very good. However the service was HORRIBLE. In other the bar and restaurant . Stale, slow, they didn’t cater to the needs of the table, only what worked for the servers themselves. There was one little guy in the bar that was amazing with us and my baby. But he was not our server. If he was i would have given a better review. Overall we will not be back because for what you pay and the location you should be getting a memorable experience. Which it was not.
BUYER BEWARE. My husband and I dined here and had a relatively nice experience. After we left, we looked more closely at our bill and saw we were charged fir a gin drink we did not order. I called the restaurant the next morning and explained the situation and asked that they call us. No call. My husband said not to worry but fir me it’s the principle. Lack of integrity. So if you go, pay close attention to your bill. You just may be buying the next tables $14+ cocktails.
Nick’s is one of our favorite places to dine, however, our last experience for our Valentines dinner was very disappointing.
When we first arrived and checked in, they took patrons who arrived after us and seated them, then they sat us at the very first table at the entrance where we endured incoming patrons checking in. We heard the hostess tell patrons that they are booked and hold their credit cards so obviously why would they not show up? It was a little upsetting to hear that and we were actually treated in that manner because we already gave our credit card for our dinner, the service was bad. Also my entree was so spicy that it was hard to complete and enjoy. It seemed like they didn’t care about servicing their tables and patrons because it was a set menu and it was already covered by our credit card for payment.
We usually always try to go to Nick’s once a year and it was one of our favorite places to dine but we have never experienced it so bad. I would also think that you would want to treat residents with better service too because you could get repeat returns and also we tell so much others of our dining experience.
We dine at a lot of fine dining places and now we are not sure if we would put Nick’s as one of our favorite places to dine. I think even if you were overwhelmed because of a special occasion dining that you still would have treated your patrons better.
Our servers, Bill and Guy, were fantastic! We have been eating a Nick's for the last 5 years and the food was the best...as always!
Simply fantastic service from everybody. Very attentive the whole evening. Best service in all Maui. Great wine list and perfect food. We will go back again and again - they have worked hard to make it a gem - one that stands out from all the others in the area. Great work - thank you.
Excellent service e and
In an experience resort, Nick’s promised great food and failed to deliver. The servers tag teamed us to move us along and not relax and talk. The Caesar salad was average (but not in price), and the bouillabaisse had three small clams, three prawns, a small “lobster” tail, and little else besides heavy pasta, a huge piece of bread, and a very salty tomato base. We skipped desert. The coffee was fair.
Great setting,service and food would definitely recommend this place
Great food along with outstanding service. Two members were gluten free and the kitchen accommodated. Other than being quite pricey we had no complaints
We thought the service was great..... the manager and servers were very helpful and friendly. The food was a bit overly complicated and rich which was further exaggerated by the prices.
“Good. Get out.”. Actual words spoken to us at a dinner gone wrong. Not sure how it all went wrong- but the waiter who spoke those words was responsible. Something was wrong with a partially consumed mai tai - which was replaced.
But the waiter obviously thought that was our major concern. It was his lack of concern over our entire meal. There was never a question asked about the appetizers- which were fine or the entrees until more the 75% was consumed.
Do you ask hows everything when the meal is almost consumed?
We had wanted a glass of wine with dinner, handed a menu - and no one returned to take our order until our meal was completed. Is that the time you grab the wine order ?
What’s sad is that everyone in the support staff was excellent. When our waiter finally returned- we expressed our concerns. He didn’t like what he heard - and when we requested the check he felt it had something to do with the mai Tai’s. When he learned it was about his lack of service he said “ fine - get out”.
The check was brought to us by another server - who said the manager took the mai Tai’s off our bill. This had nothing to do with mai Tai’s - but with the complete incompetence of the head waiter who was rude and disrespectful for whatever reason.
Maybe there were other issues at play - who knows. Great hotel - but their dinning options need to really be examined.