Nick's Fishmarket Maui
New Year's Eve$140.00 per person
Dec 31, 2021 onlyCelebrate New Year's Eve at Nick's Fishmarket! Chef Maka has created an exclusive, delectable four course prix fixe menu featuring all of our favorites, including starters Ahi Sashimi & Oysters on the half shell, main courses such as Rack of Lamb, a Surf & Turf combo of Spiny Lobster and Filet Mignon, and a variety of fresh Hawaiian seafood, and the amazing flambeed Strawberries Panzini for dessert. As our singular New Year's Eve menu, this will only be available on this day, so book your reservations as soon as possible. We look forward to celebrating with you!
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Macadamia Nut Crusted, Kaffir Jasmine Rice, Baby Bok Choy, Coconut-Chili-Lime Vinaigrette
Logan's Fresh Hawaiian Fish
Filet of Fresh Island Fish Grilled or Breaded House Tartar Sauce
Moroccan Spiced Salmon*
"Forbidden" Rice, Spinach, Shiitake Mushrooms, Mango Chutney, Avocado Relish
Our waiter Chris was wonderful, personable and his recommendations were on point.
We went for our 1 year anniversary dinner and found the Ahi and Shrimp Scampi delicious.
They even surprised us with a delicious dessert.
Highly recommend this restaurant.
Amazing meal, food was so delicious and the staff very attentive.
Was so good we booked a table for two nights later
We enjoyed dinner two nights in a row at Nicks. Reduced capacity for COVID avoidance makes the ambiance quieter than it might usually be but that is pleasant and, together with the setting, makes this a delightful venue. In Hawaii we tend to go for seafood and we were very pleased with the fish and shellfish (including WA oysters!) here. Sashimi and entree specials were all delicious and made great use of local ingredients. Prices are high so the value is only middling but you do get what you pay for.
Everything was tremendous. We had the best wait staff we've had in over a year.
Nicks is fabulous in every way! We love the fresh, delicious food, great service and beautiful ambiance.
It was ok nothing special.
Our Server- Chevis, made the evening so special for us! Food was delicious as always. All around fantastic evening!
Always great at Nick’s!
I really enjoyed the food and service. I chose well as i wanted our last dinner around sunset.
Im so glad we got a table with a view.:)
Great spot for a dinner date! Service was very good!
Very romantic and delicious food. Highly recommend. Great Service
Went to Nick’s while in Wailea. This restaurant feels a little dated in terms of food and ambiance. The food was ok, but rather odd pairings with the fish dishes (heavy mushroom risotto with seared ahi tuna). Service was nice though. With so many other options we probably won’t go back.
Good service. They had a valentine's day menu but it was a bit expensive per person for what you actually got.
So glad to be able to dine regularly at our favorite restaurant again.
Food and Service is Awesome. Great location. Wife and I would definitely go back.
Nicks may have had a bad night.
Nicks may not be all it’s cracked up to be.
Food just ok.
They knew it.
We came to celebrate my wife’s birthday, I did make that clear on the reservation. The hostesses recognized it, unfortunately that information was either not given to the server or he forgot. While we enjoyed the meal, my wife was a bit disappointed that no effort was made to add that little extra touch (birthday dessert, or even a candle in the dessert we ordered), considering the caliber of this restaurant.
The experience and service were fabulous! I expected the salmon to be more spicy - very good none the less.
Dessert and cocktails were fantastic and the view amazing
Cheston is a fabulous waiter and we will go eat there just to have him as a server.
The food was absolutely amazing! Don't miss out on the B&B Ahi as well as the kalua pork pot stickers. Server, Ikaika, was very informative about dishes and super welcoming!
The service was nothing short of perfect! Honestly amazing
A well thought out satisfying meal that stimulated my taste buds with its excellence. My wife and I are foodies and this is definitely a do over
Last night on Maui dinner. Fantastic food and service as always.
Beautiful night, dinner and service celebrating my retirement
Wonderful experience all the way around. Bill was a fabulous server. Fish was excellent!
Great food and ambience. I would recommend to anybody.
The food was wonderful. The Mahi mahi was particularly delicious. Second time I have enjoyed it. The service was first rate!
Chris from Haiku was our server and he was great!!!
REALLY good meal!! Service was awesome & ambiance was great!!
One of the best high end restaurants in Wailea.
This is our favorite place to eat this year on Maui! Excellent food, friendly staff and beautiful setting!
The food was very ordinary, nothing special. The service was outstanding. We thought
it must have been the Chef’s day off. The prices were extremely high for the fare served,
$47.00 for 3 medium size scallops on very boring risotto. The strawberry beet salad was
good. You desperately need a new menu, so ho hum.
Superb, from the “flair” on placing my napkin to the finale ending of Strawberries Flambé! We ordered the best made Manhattans up on the island, then had, as always, the best fried calamari I’ve ever had on Maui. We then shared the Maui Wowie salad which is incomparable! For entrees I had the scallops, prepared the best I’ve ever had in my life, and my husband ordered to appetizers for his entree, Kalua pork potstickers with a pineapple curry sauce and the crab cakes which are absolutely incredible! We ended with the Strawberries Flambéd in Grand Mariner and is served with a Creme fresh and chocolate sauce. Sublime, decadent and an incredible evening in a magnificent setting!!!
Fantastic food and special servers!
Absolutely Amazing....... Chris was hands down the most amazing, energetic, superlative server we've ever encountered. His positive energy and abundance of knowledge of his entire menu was impressive. He had fluidity through his transitions with each and every guest he accost. Chef Maka was amazing with his menu for the evening. Every dish from the Oysters, Black and Blue Ahi, Escargot Styled Scallops to the Beet and Maui Wowee salad, truly left you wanting more. Flavors were perfect and truly meshed well with each other. Our entrées in which were the Shrimp Scampi and Rack of Lamb were done to perfection as well. To end the evening.... Flaming strawberries, truly left us estatic and in awe. 5 star experience, 5 star food. Fantastic Job to Aaron, Doug, Chris and the rest of the Nick's Fish Market team.
One of the best service experiences I have had recently. My mahi-mahi was outstanding! The lamb chops delicious. Will come back
Very quiet in a setting that is truly inspiring. The menu was exceptional with a quality of service second to none.
An exceptional dining experience.
Nick's Fishmarket Maui is rated 4.7 stars by 2589 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.