Nick's Fishmarket Maui
New Year's Eve$140.00 per person
Dec 31, 2021 onlyCelebrate New Year's Eve at Nick's Fishmarket! Chef Maka has created an exclusive, delectable four course prix fixe menu featuring all of our favorites, including starters Ahi Sashimi & Oysters on the half shell, main courses such as Rack of Lamb, a Surf & Turf combo of Spiny Lobster and Filet Mignon, and a variety of fresh Hawaiian seafood, and the amazing flambeed Strawberries Panzini for dessert. As our singular New Year's Eve menu, this will only be available on this day, so book your reservations as soon as possible. We look forward to celebrating with you!
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Macadamia Nut Crusted, Kaffir Jasmine Rice, Baby Bok Choy, Coconut-Chili-Lime Vinaigrette
Logan's Fresh Hawaiian Fish
Filet of Fresh Island Fish Grilled or Breaded House Tartar Sauce
Moroccan Spiced Salmon*
"Forbidden" Rice, Spinach, Shiitake Mushrooms, Mango Chutney, Avocado Relish
The food was ok and the service was fine but I definitely prefer Mama’s Fish House.
On vacation staying just a few blocks away. Great food nice ambience and service was fantastic.
Extremely poor service. The food quality was not commensurate with the price. Our worst dining experience in Maui.
You cannot beat the food at Nick’s! Generally, the service there is great, but last night it was poor. Won’t stop me from returning, but hopeful I’ll have a different waiter.
Awesome dinner awesome ambiance!
Excellent service and fantastic food. Very accommodating for special requirements and fish was very fresh and perfectly cooked. I had the Seared Ahi tuna and my guest had Salmon. Both were cooked perfectly. Waiter was attentive and able to accommodate an excellent glass of wine for my preference. I would highly recommend!
Honestly, I’m not sure this dinner could have been more perfect. We had the ahi, the fresh catch, and the mahi mahi, as well as the creme brûlée. Everything was delicious, our waiter was attentive and the ambiance was lovely.
This was absolutely the best meal we had in Maui thus far! Ahi over mushroom risotto, catch of the day, and the Filet! Creme brulee and bananas foster! SO DELICIOUS! 5 STARS for sure!!!
We went for our 25th wedding anniversary. The view is absolutely spectacular the food was delicious but not worth the cost. The weather was very kind but had a very flat personality. He seemed a little overwhelmed which he’s human. But for the cost I would not come back again
Perfect celebration night for our honeymoon! Staff was phenomenal, drinks were delicious, and food was fantastic! Highly recommend for a fancy date night.
Nice atmosphere. Food is good but nothing outstanding over other similar restaurants.
The ambiance was really good esp since the weather was so mice that day. The food is overpriced and the portions were meager. The quality isnt something outstanding if you compare it to the dollar amount.
Such a great dining experience between the food the service and the ambiance. Cheston was great. Sunset was amazing!
We had reservations and sadly we were just placed back by the bar area. I asked the hostess if we could sit in the other section (outdoor area) and she told me that all those tables are taken and wouldn’t be open for two hours. Right after that I saw her seat a few other couples in that area. :( The food was good but not great.
Every course was delicious!
All around amazing experience!!!!
What a beautiful setting! We took a walk along the walking path in the beachside of the restaurant prior to being seated. Dinner from start to finish was wonderful. I personally had the Moroccan spiced salmon. Perfectly cooked and great flavors.
One of the best meals on the island!
We love Nick’s! The Mahi Mahi was so delicious!
Nick’s Fish Market provided the perfect atmosphere and the most amazing food for our anniversary dinner! Cyrus did an excellent job taking care of us.
Food, service and ambiance were all fantastic. Highly recommend
I was so excited to go to nick’s. The ambience is beautiful . However, I ordered the fish piccata and was disappointed, it was over cooked and dry.
It was super expensive and the food was a little underwhelming.
Nickʻs Fishmarket is a favorite venue for this kamaʻaina reviewer. I attend both personal and business events at the restaurant on a regular basis. It has outstanding servers, food, and views. Last evening, however, we had a personal four-person table dinner reservation. We were placed at a table between the bar and kitchen entrance. There were no views as the table faced a large pillar and opened shutter doors that blocked a majority of the views to the west. There was a lot of foot traffic, noise, and no breeze. I recommend that this table location be eliminated as it is subpar for this high-end restaurant. Fortunately, our server (Bill) was outstanding and the food, as always, top-drawer. That made the experience acceptable overall. That being said, I highly recommend Nickʻs.
Fish special delicious. Lamb delicious. Service always terrific. Wonderful dinner.
The service was excellent and the salmon was out of this world good. We were originally seated behind a pole on the patio but when I asked to be moved they said no problem. The mai tai was good and had an enjoyable evening. The grounds are beautiful
Everything was fabulous. This is our favorite restaurant on the island
Jack, our waiter, was awesome!! We had a great time!
Simply the best meal I’ve ever had out. Not pretentious or trying hard to impress. Just creative dishes with unexpected blends and flavors. Our server was Cheston, a 5 year veteran of Nick’s wait staff. He was superb. You can’t miss at Nick’s.
The food was amazing! I had the rack of lamb. Yummmmm
Husband had the Lobster with Mac n Cheese. Very tasty too. Only complaint is that the restaurant is too close to the family pool. So we had to sit and listen to screaming kids.
Always an amazing meal at Nicks! Best service on the island!
Over priced. Food just so so. I would not return l.
Not enough staff, poor service, decent food, but at prices that warranted much better service and food .
To expensive and the food very regular.
Excellent experience. Amazing restaurant and food just delicious
Honeymoon dinner. Food great
Not what it once was. Hard to track down server.
After 5 days in Maui of planned celebratory meals, Nick’s Fishmarket stood above all of the others in taste, service, value and overall experience! We would highly recommend Nicks.
This is the second time I’ve eaten at Nick’s . Service was good but slow. Very very hot both times. The air is dead in the restaurant even though open. Need more fans to get air moving. Servers are nice but service is slow. Good ambience.
From appetizers all the way to dessert, our experience was excellent!
Nick's Fishmarket Maui is rated 4.6 stars by 2735 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.