Our new private dining room offers individual or community-style table options for up to 35 guests. Offering our full dinner menu and 4 prix fixe menus to accommodate a minimum of 25 guests. Exclusive access to the main dining room is also available for luncheons from 11:30 a.m. No room fees.View Private Dining Details
This was my second visit to NY Prime. I may go back another time but not on a special day. This was father's day and we found it too noisy and cramped. The food was good but not great as it was the first visit (Easter Sunday).
Pricey, but best steak ever!!
Sides are a little lack luster
Apple pie was amazing
Hands down, best restaurant in Myrtle Beach. Far better than other chain high-end steakhouses
Celebrated our anniversary here. Good food, service was phenomenal. They made our table extra special because they knew it was our anniversary. Open concept dining room with tables close together would make it difficult to have a private conversation.
The steaks and sides were excellent - some of the best I’ve ever had. Ambience was a little weird... the service aims to be high class (and the prices support this). My husband had to send back his Sazerac (the bartenders decided that an absinthe rinse was more of an absinthe pour and I could smell the anise from across the table) and had to remind the waiter to bring the glass of wine he’d requested with his main course. Otherwise, the service was fine. I couldn’t help but feel we’d gone back in time a bit as there was not a single female server (nor did I notice any servers of color), just white men. I can’t remember the last time I was in a restaurant with such little diversity among the staff.
As for atmosphere, it was odd to be seated in a “fancy” steak house near a bar with two televisions, surrounded by other diners who ranged from resort casual (which seems appropriate given the setting) to, quite frankly, a little slovenly (shorts and baseball caps). I was also disappointed that cigar smoking was allowed inside, albeit limited to the bar. I wouldn’t have enjoyed that under normal circumstances, but as a pregnant woman, I’m particularly sensitive to that odor.
Excellent food and service..... Highly recommend for business or personal with family and friends
You never can go wrong with the steaks here. They are tremendous! We go here every year when we're here and the only disappointment was the bread - it just seemed a little dry or stale, although who cares when you're eating prime steak!
We went for our 5 year anniversary and they had decorated the table with heart confetti, candle and bottle of wine. The wait staff was great and the food was amazing!
As usual, our meal was great! Lee E did a great job taking care of our group of 7. Food was excellent. Loved the baked shrimp appetizer. Also, the banana cream pie remains one of my all time favorite desserts. Food and service here never disappoint!
Our experience was everything that we imagined it would be! Fantastic
We were in Myrtle Beach for a family members wedding vow renewal. We selected New York Prime steakhouse after surfing the web. The food and staff were excellent. We will definitely be back.
This was our third year celebrating our anniversary at New York Prime, MB. The service is superb, and the Sea Bass keeps bringing us back. This time my steak was a little more charred on the outside vice seared, but still quite good. We had a loud obnoxious group right beside our table. So I asked our waiter to see if they could move us. They did so right away, making our meal much more enjoyable. Thanks to our waiter, and the manager for rectifying the situation so quickly. We will be back.
Service and food was great. The thick cut bacon was a great starter, and the Cheese mash potatoes was a good choice for a side.
Birthday Dinner for my husband with our best friends. Requested Stefan as our waiter. He was the best. Our favorite restaurant, food and service is always above excellent.
I'm a vegetarian, so cannot comment on the steak (although my dining partner gave his steak a rave review). The sides and salads were amazing. Most are served family size and the portions are quite generous. The cheesy potatoes and creamed spinach are a must, and the french fries & onion rings are fantastic.
Excellent Food and Service. I would highly recommend.
Recommended by friend. Would compare to Fleming’s. Good food music a little loud price a little high. Not an everyday place to eat
We enjoyed a wonderful anniversary dinner with our family during our Myrtle Beach vacation at New York Prime. My husband and I fell in love with this steak house on our first visit to Myrtle Beach in 2016. We vowed to come back each time we vacationed here. Service was extremely friendly and helpful. We were a group of 10 and seating was ample and comfortable. My husband and I agree that NY Prime has the best steak we’ve ever had... and we’re always in search of a good steak in the NY/NJ area. Our family enjoyed the delicious lump crab and garlic shrimp apps. We had the asparagus, mushrooms, and cheesy potatoes to share as sides. We also had coffee and the NY cheesecake for dessert. DELICIOUS and highly recommended.
The service was outstanding! The ambiance was very nice, quite and chill. The other patrons were very friendly. The food however was on the average side for the cost. My wife and I are steak house lovers and have dined all over the country the flavor profile wasn't quite what we expected but the meat was very tender
Great food and service. A nice place to celebrate special occasions.
We absolutely are never disappointed with New York Prime Myrtle Beach. Service, food, wine is top notch. Highly recommend!
Service was relaxed but excellent, never felt rushed. Knowledgeable sommelier. Had my favorite pinot noir as a house glass. Food remarkably delicious and quantity more than sufficient. Have plates and sides for 2 , so don't mind splitting. All said it is expensive and only you can decide if it is worth the splurge.
We had a great meal....drinks, food and service were fantastic. Steven was so attentive to our needs and took care of us very well. This is a great steak restaurant but the Chilean Sea Bass was absolutely the best I have ever had at any seafood restaurant. Bravo!!
Best steak and fine dining in the Myrtle Beach area.
I have celiac and was celebrating my boy friends birthday. Chris was our waiter. Love love love him!!! He was a walking book of knowledge when it came to your menu. He walked me through everything That were my options. He made sure I was safe and kept coming back to check on us. He made our night complete. Perfect asset to your restaurant!!!
Awesome Experience. We found New York Prime while visiting Myrtle Beach on vacation. We went one night and enjoyed it so much that we came back 2 days later for our anniversary.
Steak was cooked to perfection. Our waiter, Stephan, was tremendous. He made the evening. Always a great place for a special occasion. My favorite in Myrtle Beach.
Fav place to eat when we come to Myrtle Beach!
Best restaurant I've been to in a while..... Steaks were perfect
My wife and I were searching for a great date night dinner spot for our vacation, and we were not disappointed. The atmosphere was fantastic, and the steaks were even better!! We’ll definitely be back!
Great service and food. Our waiter was fantastic! The steaks were great. The wine list was good enough. Dining here will not disappoint.
It was a great dinner, came from a family recommendation. Our waiter Lee was superb, and very friendly and helpful explaining the choices as it was our first time there. Baked shrimp appetizer was incredible and Lee worked with us to put together a wonderful surf and turf selection. Steak was fantastic, and I wish I could cook fish as good as ours was. Looking forward to our next visit.
This is a go-to steakhouse! Excellent service, food, and ambiance!
Mother’s Day brunch has become our tradition and today was enjoyable. Steak, eggs and seafood crepes were excellent. Waiter forgot my mimosa and valet car retrieval was a little slow. It is a little overpriced by overall a great experience.
The food and service was awesome
My favorite steakhouse anywhere. Food is great, service is amazing, and the atmosphere is tremendous. They decorated the table for my wife's birthday and everything was perfect, as always. Do not miss this place. Evertime we are in Myrtle Beach, we always come to NY Prime.
Awesome wine list. GREAT food. Service was perfect and beyond my expectations.
Fantastic!! Food portions are very large and can be shared.
The food was nothing special and expensive to boot. I have no problem spending $ for great meal but I left unwowed. The steak was cooked beautifully but I did not like the charred outside. The sides (which are seperate from the meat) were ehh. The service was great except my dessert was brought out way before my husbands. Best part of the meal were the espresso martinis. I would not recommended this place or return.