New York Prime Steakhouse - Myrtle Beach
Book your next event with us
This was our first visit to New York Prime and we will definitely be back! We went on Valentine’s Day and had a 9:30 reservation. We got there around 9:05 and we’re seated by 9:10. Staff was friendly, service was excellent, and the food was AMAZING. We sat in the little room to the back on the right. The ambiance was nice and there was plenty of space. We weren’t crammed in and it was very comfortable. Our waitor was EXCELLLENT. I can’t remember his name, but he was absolutely wonderful. He knew the menu very well and you could tell that he enjoyed his job. Overall, I give our experience a 10/10 and we will definitely be back soon!!
Attentive service, extraordinary steaks and authentic NYC steakhouse atmosphere.
Great environment with outstanding service! Perfect for our date night!
We go to New York Prime for special occasions like Birthdays and Anniversaries. The service is impeccable and the steaks melt in your mouth!!
Very nice dinner . Started with an old fashioned and my wife had a glass of wine . We ordered the oysters Rockefeller as an appetizer. Our Steaks were perfectly cooked as ordered, very flavorful. I ordered the NY strip and the wife had the petite filet , shared the chopped salad and had Brussels on the side . It is very difficult to get a good strip these days but mine was excellent. Yes it was expensive but our meal rivaled any steakhouse experience anywhere.!
We live in the area, but had never eaten here before. It was incredible. Very high end. Everything tasted delicious and the service was outstanding.
Amazing food and exceptional service as always
One of our favorite places! Food and service are always consistent and top notch. Steven was our server and Nicole took care of us at the bar. They were both extremely friendly and did a wonderful job. Already looking forward to next time!
Overall the food was quite good. I really enjoyed the seafood bisque and homemade bread. Desserts were delicious as well. The steaks were good, but not great. They employee a technique where they char the outside, which sounds yummy, but wasnt for me. The tables were very close together so all I could hear was my neighbors conversations and not my own.
Just Excellent! Great food, portions are great and so is the service
I always have very high expectations at NY Prime. As usual, I was not disappointed.
Fantastic food and service!
NY Prime is the best of the best Steakhouses!
Fabulous food and service!
Chris was our head waiter and he was wonderful! Great personality and wonderful service.
Very good steakhouse! Has the most outstanding service you could ever ask for. We always order the porterhouse for two and some salads, sides, etc. Will be back and would recommend to anyone who enjoys an upscale steakhouse.
This is our favorite place over anywhere in the US! The food was excellent. Robert was excellent service. Always excellent
Great food and service
Would rate this restaurant outstanding but the fact they allow smoking in the bar, which is right next to the dining area, ruined it for us. We were sitting next to the bar and a man lit up a cigar in the bar and it was awful. Fortunately we were nearly finished with our meal when that happened. Otherwise it’s great.
Outstanding (as usual) ... absolutely love this place ... great food and great service with attention to detail ... great staff from valet to service ... steaks are out of this world as is the sea bass.
Excellent evening with my two daughters. Want to comment that Mike was very good and added to the overall experience. The steak was absolutely perfect and it was Mike's assistance that allowed my younger daughters to partake of the steak without the usual "char" which really made them change their mind as they had eaten at the restaurant before and did not like that cooking style. Keep up the good work! Thanks, Rich
Outstanding as always. Second year in a row we’ve had Christmas dinner there. We will be back next year again.
I know it is a great steakhouse, my only suggestion is maybe a few more seafood choices, otherwise excellent
Just be aware that the side dishes are HUGE! They are meant to be shared so if the waiter doesn’t say that explicitly, you’ve been forewarned. My wife’s baked potato was 16oz. We should have shared it but I ordered a combo of steak fries and onion rings for myself. It was at least a pound total. The steaks are primo.
Totally enjoyed, as usual !!!
Our favorite restaurant in Myrtle Beach and we try and go there whenever possible and especially for special occasions. Our thanks to the Management, the Chefs and especially the Serving Staff for making each visit fabulous.
Wayne and Diana Bromwell
Great meal and impeccable service by Paul!
The best Food!
Great food and service. At times a bit noisy. Steaks (bone-in ribeye and fillet) were excellent. Can't find many restaurants that can "really" do a Pittsburg char. Most restaurants say they can but ultimately fail to deliver. Not the case with NY Prime! Always a great meal and time dining. Will come back.
Really appreciated the decorated table for my husbands birthday! Service was exquisite and steaks were good as always.
As always...New York Prime was absolutely outstanding!
New York Prime offered exceptional service and mediocre dining. Everyone on staff, from the valet attendant to the server, was well versed in exceptional service, manners, and knew the menu thoroughly. The food, however, was not on par with expectations. My husband ordered the New York Strip, cooked medium. The steak was cooked nicely, charred on top and pink center. The cut was not seasoned at all. There was no salt, herbs, or butter on the meat. The flavor was poor. I ordered the entree size baked shrimp, which had decent flavor and was a generous portion. The sides, asparagus with hollandaise and cheese mashed potatoes, were of average taste. Nothing brought to the table was impressive in flavor and certainly didn't justify the menu price. While the ambiance was enjoyable and our server was very attentive, we will visit Halls Chophouse in Charleston for our next fine dining experience.
Another fantastic expereince on all aspects! Menu insert concerning the availability of prime steaks both informative and a good idea!
One of the best steakhouses anywhere
Great service and great food!!! We love to go there for special occasions.
Absolutely delicious!!! Enjoyed it very much! Staff made it very special as we were celebrating our 20th wedding anniversary. They placed sprinkles on the table and made us a card. It was nice.
Great as always. My customers had a wonderful time.
As always Chris the server was outstanding