This is my favorite restaurant in Buckhead. The owner and the staff are incredible. This is the place to go to enjoy an evening of fun and food.
Too noisy and too dark-waiter had to use a flashlight so we could read the menu. With open tables they put a group of 8 right behind us which made our business meeting a struggle. The food was fantastic.
The food and service were both outstanding. What wrecked the experience is they allow cigar smoking in the bar. While we requested a table far away from the bar, the cigar stench permeated the entire restaurant. We will
not be returning. We would NOT recommend this place. Too many other outstanding steak houses to attend instead.
If you are like me, you go to a high end steakhouse for an excellent steak and good service. In that regard, you will not be dissapointed at New York Prime.
The restaurant was definitely lively. The live music was good. I think it would be a good place to entertain for business.
Make certain you know how to find the restaurant. Don't expect to punch it in your navigation system and just get there.
Excellent service from the moment we parked at valet. Food was superb, and the staff made my fiancé feel extra special for his birthday dinner.
the lobster is amazing but very expensive. Reserve this place for a Special Occasion!
Wonderful food (the best steaks ever) with sides that were delicious with plenty to share! Also, the very best cheesecake I think we have ever had!!!
New York Prime in Buckhead is one of the best restaurants in America!!!!! The service, food, environment and ability to smoke a cigar makes it one of a kind.
Picked this spot for my son's birthday with a few friends (table of 7). I knew they allowed smoking in the bar area, but had no idea that the bar area is practically half the restaurant. So we were greeted by choking cigar and cigarette smoke and our clothes reeked of it when we got home. However, the biggest fail was the fact that, despite a virtually empty restaurant, five of six of our steaks were completely overcooked (i.e., some brown in the middle)! We had to send back nearly every one - and this is a steak place! Ironically, the steak fries were undercooked and hard. The other sides (asparagus, mashed potatoes, creamed spinach) were solid and the desserts pretty good, and they tried to make it right by comping the desserts, but overall this place was mediocre at best. Had to get up twice to find a staffer to ask a question, and this place is tiny. There are numerous very good steakhouses in Atlanta - don't bother traipsing through parking decks and office buildings trying to find this one. Instead go to Rathbuns, Capital Grille, the Palm, Kaiser or STK. All of them put a dress on this sad place.
New York Prime continues to be my favorite restaurant in Atlanta. You won’t find better steak or lobster anywhere. The service is exceptional. NYP is always our first choice when dining out as a couple or with friends.
It was great. Our first time there and service and food was outstanding. Will return soon.
DO NOT MISS IT !!
The best Steakhouse in Atlanta hands down!!!
Go Go Go!
The meals here are consistently excellent. Service was very good. They usually have live music on the weekends. Good dinner appropriate music.
This is our special steak dinner place every year when we come to Buckhead for a conference - if I lived nearby I would visit New York Prime every week... The service is the best you will ever have anywhere... There are as many as 7 servers working on your table at a time - everything is always perfect! Great steaks - great seafood!
I love this restaurant and will come again. Our server was very good, knew the menu and corrected any problems we had.
We went for Valentine's Day, which is a usually a disaster at most restaurants. New York Prime didn't have a "special" menu, just the same excellent food and prime steaks they have on any other day. Service was attentive, because instead of trying to run as many people through the restaurant as possible, they focused on taking care of their customers. Live music was casual and lovely, steak was cooked perfectly to temperature, and this place provided the best Valentine's Day experience myself and my date ever had.
We sat in the corner of the bar and the lighting was a bit too bright and they were not able to dim the lights.
Other than that, great experience as always!
Fantastic Steak , great experience , enjoyed the entire evening ,
Very personalized service from the owner and staff
Aside from the all the smokers in the restaurant (the host seated us as far as possible from the bar (smokers), the service & food were outstanding. My steak was over cooked, but immediately replaced with a perfectly prepared cut. Service couldn’t have been any better & the quality of food was top notch!
Compared to fine dining steakhouses in Atlanta this would be Top 2 ranking #1 with excellent overall dining experience.
PLACE WAS AWESOME! THEY GOT US IN WITH LAST MINUTE RESEVERVATIONS. FOOD WAS GREAT. THE SERVICE WAS EXCEPTIONAL THE WAITER WAS VERY ENGAGED AND ORGINIZED
We usually think of New York Prime as a great place to take business associates. You can always count on great food and service to entertain clients. Last weekend we decided to go there on a date night. We had a wonderful time with the expected great food and service. However the Saturday night crowd was very upbeat and festive. We had a great time. Our waiter was the best! This will now be a new date night favorite too.
Great service from Jamal. Outstanding local steakhouse. Bring your cigar to the bar
New York Prime is consistently outstanding in every respect. Whether you’re having beef or fish or lobster, everything is impeccably prepared with service to match. It was especially nice to find a special reserve wine by the glass list this time, too! The Bordeaux was well worth it.
NYP isn’t the least expensive place to go, but if you want a special meal at a place where people take pride in making “special ordinary”, this is the place!
Nice restaurant and good food, excellent service. The smoke bothers me and my husband. We didn't know they allow smoking in the restaurant.
You have to walk through the smoking bar area to the host to be seated and the smoke from the bar area was in the dining room
My husband and I had an amazing time ! I would recommend this restaurant to all of my friends.
Love the resturant first time there they have the freshest food available and the best quality if you go there you go for quality any one can sling some food together buy it's the quality that counts
We had filet and ribeye. The steaks were cooked perfectly. The service was awesome. I definitely recommend for special occasions. I enjoyed the live music.
Some of the best food I have ever eaten. Steak was really tender and juicy. Cheese Mash Potatoes were the best I have ever eaten. The service was really great and everyone was real friendly. Will be going back as much as possible.
Service was outstanding! Smoking and Cigar smoking at the bar was a turn off. We sat as far away from the bar as we could, but still went home smelling like smoke. Steak was somewhat charred on the exterior, but a nice cut of meat.
Absolute top notch service with extremely high end dining! Excellent restaurant to impress clients & employees. Gotta love this place.
Great restaurant with incredible food quality. The chopped steak is the best. Bobby Donolan is a master.
Always the best in town.
Consistent as always; outstanding bar staff; warm welcoming and superb food. Enjoyed the Oysters and the Chopped Steak on this outing. The Chopped Salad with anchovies is the best in Atlanta. As the old saying the ads would say---"Try it, you'll like it"!
If you do not smoke you will not enjoy this restaurant. It is very smoky and we had the seats as far away as we could get. When home I had to leave my clothes out as they smelled of smoke. Our waitress was extremely nice as were the other servers. When we arrived there was no one to tell us what to do or where to go. We waited a bit and then got a waitress to help us. If the Matre 'd is not available someone should keep an eye on new arrivals.
When we were here, it was a Sunday evening so it was pretty quiet. Everything about this establishment is perfect with the exception of a smoky cigar bar! It is the first thing that hits you upon entering the restaurant. The steaks were all done perfectly and were delicious. The service is top notch as well.
The only negative for us is the cigar bar. We will probably not be returning due to the odor.
I booked this reservation for my mom and dad as a gift and did not know that the bar was a cigarette/cigar smoking bar and they were seated right next to it and had to leave the restaraunt there was so much smoke they could not eat there. I wish somewhere on the website it would’ve told me that it was a smoking restaraunt.