New York Prime Steakhouse - Buckhead
Restaurant + Bar, Now Non-Smoking
Located in Monarch Tower. Complimentary valet available. Directions: Use the Lenox Rd ramp between Ritz-Carlton Buckhead and Phipps Plaza.
Still the best steak in Atlanta. There are other great choices, but if a perfect steak is what you are looking for, there is no better place.
Total dining experience was exceptional. Great staff and live singer provided a relaxing and enjoyable ambiance. The steaks were all cooked to perfection. Delicious sides and great wine selection. Would highly recommend for a fine dining experience
Everything was amazing from the moment we walked in until we left. The Maitre d' (didn't get his name) knew exactly how many was in our party once we gave a name. He presented me a birthday card from there wishing me happiness. Scott, our waiter was Phenomenal! Very accommodating. I ordered a Loading Bake Potato with my order and when my Fiance ordered one as well, he explained that the potato is huge (1lb actually) and suggested we share one. We was very impressed that he wanted us to enjoy our experience and was not worrying about selling to us to increase the bill. We will definitely be going back and not just for a special occasion.
Always good eating here food is great
Very nice place. Service was great. Food was good except that my steak was not as tender as I would have liked. My co-worker really enjoyed his steak though and did not have the same issue.
Excellent for large group birthday dinner. They were able to accommodate separate checks as well.
We had a business dinner at New York Prime, and everyone who joined was very pleased with the food and the service!
The best hands down...everything was amazing..the service...the food..the scenery ...it was awesome.
The food and drinks were amazing. Our waiter Jeff was very nice. He made great suggestions.
Celebrated Valentine's Day dinner and all I can say is SUPERB. Great food cooked to perfection and impeccable service from the staff. The live music was outstanding and well received. Definitly looking forward to going back.
The atmosphere at has changed a bit since the No Smoking ordinance took effect last month, but you still can't beat the food and service at New York Prime. There are a few new items on the menu; the Maryland crab cakes are phenomenal...enough to tempt a die hard meat eater away from his usual filet or strip steak. Still my favorite restaurant in Atlanta. My wife and I will be dining here for the third week in a row, this time with our out of town guests.
We love this restaurant. The overall professionalism by all staff is definitely worth the experience. The food was taste was worth the money.
It was great
Great place to eat. Steak was great and I will recommend to anyone when in Atlanta.
Always one of our favorite spots. Great food, great service, incredible ambiance. They did it right for Valentine's day!
What a great experience. Hubby and I celebrated Valentine’s Day here. We were seated right away and found the lively atmosphere quite enjoyable. The service is reminiscent of the good ole’ days and the food was quite good. We got started with the bisque which was so good. While our ribeye was a tad under where we like it the char on the outside and the flavor was so good. I’m used to crispy Brussels but these were Soft, decadent and delicious. We finished with their apple dessert which didn’t look like much but wound up being quite good. We’ll definitely be back.
Exceptional food and service. Steak prepared perfectly.
Dinner was spectacular. As always, my steak was prepared to perfection. And my wife’s sea bass was simply outstanding. It was flaky, well cooked throughout, and had the same great taste she’s always loved when dining there. Our prior experience on New Year’s Eve was an anomaly when the fish did not smell nor taste right. But NYP made things right and we once again enjoyed a memorable meal at our favorite Atlanta dining spot. And we have to admit that having Scott S as our server made the evening even more complete. He’s exemplary!
Very nice place to eat dinner. Will go again!
The service was beyond amazing, the whole staff!!! We arrive pretty close to the closing time. They welcomed us in with open arms and excitement. They did not appear to be closing or rushing us to get out of there we stayed way be on the time almost an hour and a half after they close and not once did they come to the table rush us or make us feel like any sort of inconvenience. I’ve noticed in restaurants nowadays if you come anywhere near the closing time the customer service plummets this was not the case here and I think that this is worthy of an excellent review
Made reservation b/c we wanted to have a nice steak and smoke some cigars...didn't realize you couldn't do that anymore as of 1/1/2020....although disappointed, food and service was still excellent and Bobby is always the greatest host!
Great food and service, well prepared and on time.
Was a great experience from the food, to the service, to the atmosphere. We will be back!!
Way too expensive but the quality was great.
Great bar service and really good steak!
Staff was really nice and welcoming
My wife birthday
There just aren't enough superlative adjectives to describe! The carpaccio is perfect, and the petite fillet is definitely my "go-to" choice. Our servers were Scott & Jim - they were a great team. We were a party of 8 & one of our guests got a cut of steak that was actually less than perfect. It was taken away and replaced in just a few moments. That was excellent service. If you have room, try the butter cake for dessert.
Best steak house in Atlanta.
Enjoyed a wonderful dinner with old friends. Impeccable service.
The restaurant is very difficult to locate. Front desk was not very helpful. When we finally arrived after 20 minutes of driving around. No hottest at front door she was in middle of restaurant. Server was very helpful, they forgot a few sides that we didn’t need but overall he was top notch
Had a great meal!! Super delicious!! Todd did a great job!! Yummy food!!
Another important client dinner at Prime and, as always, the fare and service was first-rate. Elegant but welcoming, my client (also a restaurant owner) was supremely impressed. Don't change anything...
Wonderful Experience! It was very busy so the waiter wasn’t able to check on us often, but the food was great and the atmosphere was wonderful. Definitely one of my favorite places to eat in Atlanta.
Very much improved experience now that cigar smoking is no longer allowed at the bar. May not be as good as Capital Grille or Bones, but it is a very enjoyable steak house now.
Todd our waiter has been one of the best ones we have had. Please send him to train the people from Chops restaurant that are so bad !!!! Thank u ....., best lobster ever❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
NY Prime food was excellent! our server was fantastic and anticipated our wants and needs.
We have decided to return with our spouses.
the noise level was too high, must be a way to reduce that!
It’s always a wonderful experience.