Bring the restaurant to you. Order and pay for food directly on OpenTable.
New York Prime Steakhouse - Buckhead
Restaurant and Bar Non-Smoking | Upscale casual dress code | Located in Monarch Tower with complimentary valet parking. Directions: Lenox Road upper ramp between The Whitley hotel and Phipps Plaza; Recommended driving directions: Google Maps or Waze.
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
A New York Tale
1792 Small Batch bourbon, amaro, maple syrup, lemon
Cheese Mashed Potatoes
Jumbo lump, mustard sauce
Great food and service. Our server was excellent
The server and food were great. Our issue was with the hostess who gave our table away after we had a reservation. And after waiting an additional 30 minutes to be seated my husband asked what the issue Was and she accused him of threatening her. She was very unprofessional and had we not been black I’m confident she wouldn’t have behaved that way
Great service. Food outstanding
Very reasonable pricing.
It was a nice restaurant we will return
Best steak in Atlanta!
We had a lovely time. Anytime spent with my sweet hubby is a great time. Nick, our server, was helpful and very knowledgeable about the menu. Inside seemed a bit busy. Outside was cozy and low key. We sat near a group celebrating a momentous occasion and kind of joined in their celebration. Fancy Friday was a hit. We’ll be back.
Service was perfect and the food was incredible. They also have a great selection of scotch. Will be our go to anytime we are in Atlanta
The porterhouse steak was the best ever. Our friends had the big filet and the bone in rib eye which they said was melt in your mouth. This restaurant ever disappoints.
Amazing I got the sea bass and my husband got a steak. Everything was cooked to perfection
This my first time visiting New York Prime Steakhouse. Overall it was a really good experience. The service was great. We ordered the oysters, carpaccio and bacon for apps. They all were very good. Everyone in my party ordered a steak and they were cooked perfectly medium rare. Our server told us they all would have a "Pittsburg" char on them. They all did have a charred crust but everyone's steak tasted burnt and was not very pleasing to us. We all cut the char off and enjoyed them anyway. Drinks and desserts were great as well. Except for the burnt tasting char on the steaks we all really enjoyed our dinner.
Had many amazing steaks around Atlanta yet for some reason had never eaten at Prime. What a mistake…. He food was excellent and the steak in right there in the top 3. Loved the ambiance. Will definitely return
It was wonderful! The food was amazing and our server Leonitis was AMAZING! The cheese mashed potatoes was the best we’ve ever had! We will be back!
It was expensive yet totally outstanding. It was my husband’s birthday celebration. Both the food and service were excellent.
Recently held a private event for our anniversary and everything was TOPNOTCH! The planning, food, service, ambience and overall experience was perfect top to bottom. We had a party of 24 every detail was attended to timely. Baked Shrimp, Bacon and Oyster were favorites among appetizers. The twin lobsters were huge and wow - the porterhouse! None of our guest had ever eaten there before and all said they would return. Great experience!
The food was less than ideal. The service for a busy night was chaotic, although the servers were polite there were many errors in plain site. Kitchen response was slow, perhaps they were swamped & the quality of the food was well below par.
The experience was magnificent at New York Prime everything was delicious! Our server was the bomb and he was very informative. The atmosphere was exactly how I pictured it.
My friend’s Birthday!! It was GREAT!!!
What a great steakhouse. The atmosphere is lively. Our server, Lawrence was top notch. We shared a steak and several half portion sides which is really a nice option. The sommelier and wine list were top notch. The steak is typically charred on the outside and is cooked to perfection. Onion rings done perfectly. The Brussels sprouts were the best I’ve ever had. Highly recommend this steak house when in Atlanta.
We went there for my wife’s birthday. Everybody there was very professional courteous the meal was outstanding I told my wife once we left there I would read that steak that I had in the top three I’ve ever had in my life. Highly recommend will be back there next month for sure
Amazing experience. The food was exceptional!
Loved the restaurant. Food was very good. Waitstaff was best I have ever seen or experienced. Andrew was our primary, will ask for him by name!
Excellent food, phenomenal service! I highly recommend New York Prime!
I booked dinner reservations for my boyfriend’s birthday and he was met with a welcoming “Happy Birthday” from the hostess and waitress. Unfortunately, the experience did not meet expectations and was very disappointing from that point on. Our Oyster Rockefeller (4) had clusters of coarse sea salt stuck in the melted cheese and was inedible. We both had to spit it out. We sent it back to the kitchen for a replacement order without any salt. It was removed from the bill however we were only given (2) oysters. I asked the waitress why we didn’t get a full order and she told me it was taken care of and that the two oysters were complimentary. I found that petty, but tried to move on with the night. Out entrees we’re brought to the table and the Brussel sprouts were burned to a crisp. The restaurant is so dim inside that I had to shine my cellphone flashlight onto the food to see that it was burned after already consuming it. We sent that back as well for a replacement order. Before we were brought the bill, the waitress asked if we wanted to see the dessert menu and I was blown away. After a lackluster evening, weren’t offered a complimentary dessert for the birthday dinner that was ruined. Our waitress was quick about resolving these issues and with providing a helpful cocktail recommendation, but I was disappointed that the manager never came to speak with us especially knowing the guest of honor was celebrating his birthday and had never been to New York Prime before. It’s a shame because I had a great experience when I visited in 2019. I suppose things aren’t held to the same standard anymore and I will not be returning nor recommending.
Great food and wine, wonderful atmosphere and the best Oyster Rockefeller in Atlanta! Alicia ~
Music was exceptionally loud and the food was mediocre. The waiter was great.
The experience was awesome. The reservation wait time was minimal. I dined on a Saturday evening so the space was rather lively. I plan to patronize again but on a week day. The energy was great and my server was phenomenal!
always very consistent with outstanding food and service.
Steak was Great and all the food!
Perfect selection for our 5th anniversary. Can’t wait to go back.
My husband and I decided that once a month we will get out of the house and have a dining experience. This month choice was NY Prime. From the beginning to the end I throughly enjoyed this restaurant. We were immediately greeted at the door taken to our table without a wait.
The restaurant was not full @6p but many of the diners were there after work. There were a few of us that were dining early.
We had steak, asparagus, corn, mushrooms and cheesecake for dessert. The portions of the sides were large enough for 2 people. If you get the right size steak you can share that too.
Thank you NY Prime for a great dining experience. We will be back
This was our first time going to NY Prime and it was fantastic! The servers were wonderful and the food was amazing....they have the best crab cakes and the butter cake was to die for!
Our waiter was friendly and welcoming. He was knowledgeable about the food and menu and gave us great suggestions. This was our first time visiting Prime and we we very happy with our experience. Unfortunately we don’t remember his name ( tall, young, white male)
Awesome dinner,portion size very generous. Waiter attentive and knowledgeable
Wonderful time from drinks at the bar to our delicious meal.
This place was absolutely amazing. My husband and I went for date night and we enjoyed ourselves. The food was so good.
It was wonderful. The waiter was top notch and food was excellent
Hands-down the best steakhouse in Atlanta!
The music was ridiculously loud...70'80's rock and roll with a New York Library dark wood setting. Should have been cool jazz or more Coffe House genre for a more romantic or quiet business setting. Food was WAY OVERPRICED versus quality
You can order delivery directly from New York Prime Steakhouse - Buckhead using the Order Online button. New York Prime Steakhouse - Buckhead also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (404) 846-0644.
New York Prime Steakhouse - Buckhead is rated 4.8 stars by 2009 OpenTable diners.
New York Prime Steakhouse - Buckhead does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://centraarchy.com/purchase-gift-cards/?restaurant=new-york-prime.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.