Best restaurant in Atlanta!

Absolutely addicting. The ambience is beautiful, the service is spectacular, and the food is the closest you'll get to perfection. Will go again and again again.

30 anniversary

What a wonderful memory I was able to share with my guy. Thanks

The service was superb. Alex took great care of my wife and me as we celebrated our anniversary. Great atmosphere and found. Not too salty or too much butter like some similar steakhouses.

My husband and I had a wonderful experience. The food was phenomenal! Service was top notch. It’s a great place for date night. We look forward to going there again for another date night.

Great staff!

Always a pleasure to dine here. The food is excellent and always as ordered. Especially enjoy the onion slice with tomato and the Brooklyn dressing. Steaks are cooked as ordered and are excellent.

I took my spouse here for his birthday and everything was amazing. It was a tad bit pricey but was really worth every penny. Everything was delicious. I did not even need to ask for salt or pepper because everything was right on point and full of flavor.

Good was good as always, my steak needed fixing for the first time in the dozen times that Iv been there - they quickly fixed the issue and boom! Great stuff

Excellent !!!!! Jeff and Drew were fabulous! Thank you for a wonderful evening.

Great food, great ambiance, great service! Thank you.

I came here dinner for Valentine’s Day and I throughly enjoyed myself. The food was remarkable and the service was impeccable . I would most definitely be returning for another meal.

The food was burnt.

First time experience, and they ran out of the 2 dinner course.. at 8pm on a Sunday February 14th Valentine Day

Crabs and the lobster tail...

Shouldve double up on inventory for days like that wife was super disappointed..

She end up regurgitating the food that she did eat .

The beef was way too salty. The crab cakes were amazing! The alcoholic drinks are overpriced. The wait time to get food after we placed our order was right at an hour to get part of the order( not the entire order). We also had to remind our server to give us the complimentary chocolate covered strawberries at the end of dinner. Overall it was a nice experience but it could’ve been better.

One of the best bone-in ribeyes in Atlanta! Love the old school music too.

Had reservations for Valentines Day. Excellent service, and food. Steaks cooked perfect. Only issue was the Brussel sprouts came out cold and it was so few of them. They heated the and brought the back out with no problem. Portion size was small. Cheesy mashed potatoes were underwhelming. They’re clearly made from frozen potatoes. Attentive wait staff but he didn’t offer any dessert recommendations or even mention a dessert menu at the end of our dinner. They turn the tables over fast and the wait staff seemed rushed. Picking up my unfinished drinks is a pet peeve of many restaurant goers including me, wait staff did it twice.
Overall, steaks were excellent, sides were just okay. Nothing to write home about.

My new fav! Ribeye was superb! Drinks off the hook! Can't wait to return.

Was great experience would go again

This was me and my fiancé first time at this restaurant and I was very pleased. Every member of staff was helpful and assisting each other. The food was amazing.

This was an excellent choice for Valentine’s Day... The food was delicious and the staff was amazing... We will definitely be dining here again

This was our first time at New York Prime and it was amazing! Our waiter was awesome and the food was delicious! We will definitely be back. Such a great time, it made our Valentine's Day perfect.

Awesome experience. The waiter was very knowledgeable and confident. Steak cooked to perfection!

Our server Leo was awesome. I would recommend him to anyone

First time having brunch at New York Prime. My family ordered from the brunch menu and I had the regular menu. All of the food came out hot and delicious. The girls are ready to go back.

The food was great, the waiter was great. The overall experience was very great. I will definitely be returning. The only negative comment i have is how cold the restaurant was and one patron who was a little intoxicated being overally load.

I loved this restaurant! The food was amazing, the meat truly speaks for itself! We sat outside and was surprised at how well the heat maintained inside of the tent so well. The cheesy mashe potatoes were hit and extremely smooth and cheesy. The lamb chop was so succulent and juicy! I will be coming back!

The Tomahawk was a little overdone.
ordered medium came out medium well but tasty none the less

Food was delivered and atmosphere was nice and I would definitely go back

The food was fantastic, as was the service (Nick).

The nose level was through the roof, though, which detracted from the ambiance. Also, it was very cold outside, and the access door to the outside patio was opened and closed frequently, to serve those sitting outside. This allowed cold drafts to pour through the restaurant all night long.

This is the first time I have had to enjoy a pricey steak while wearing a heavy jacket.

Everything was amazing. I can’t say enough good things about this restaurant

Horrible experience. Steak came out rare ordered medium. Brussels sprouts had a sticker on the sprout that was from a utensil or something other than food. Gross. Manager did not come by our table to check on dinner as we ate and we were only told we would be taken care of next time. No thanks.

Our waiter Nick was the best. We loved it.. The whole setting was great and the food was excellent.... Definitely will be back

Everything was awesome. The service, the food and the staff is over attentive! The food was worth every dime

Our server Kaleb and everyone else that assisted him was were wonderful! Very attentive and made great suggestions. I got the 6 lb lobster with stuffing and what a treat it was!

Reservation was for 9pm. We were only seated at 10pm and at 11pm we had still not received our food. In the end we just walked out. I have never walked out of a restaurant before.

I called ahead to change my reservation time the restaurant told me 8:45pm was available my original reservation was 8. We get there on time was told we’d be seated shortly an hour and 15 minutes later I got a text to be seated. We waited an additional 15 minutes before anyone greeted us we waited another 15 before they came back to take our order! By 11 I asked the waiter how long before our food arrives he said he didn’t know there were 5 tables ahead of ours I asked the waiter to cancel our order and we left without eating!

My server Kyle was beyond amazing!! Great food, ambience and service.

Seated 45 minutes after reservation time. Had another event planned after dinner. Seated. Took another 45 minutes to get a status on the food. Walked out before anything came. No communication. Waiter had no clue about food. I’ll give them that it was the night before Valentine’s Day, but for the amount they are charging and the “ratings” it was abhorrent. Host did chase us down on the way out to give us his card to call us. Honestly, I’m sure the free appetizer would have tasted great, but overall, will not go back.