New Sheridan Chop House
While I entered the birthday occasion for my 15 year old son, I also spoke with the hostess on the phone prior to our arrival about it, no attention was paid whatsoever to his birthday. I thought it would be a nice surprise but —-nothing. We did enjoy the food however.
We found ourselves at the New Sheridan several times. We made a reservation for one of our nights in Telluride and were not disappointed. The atmosphere is lovely, the service was flawless and everything was prepared perfectly.
One evening we had dinner and my Vegetarian partner enjoyed the Veggie pasta and vegetable sides and my fillet was prepared to perfection. We had brunch on our "rest" day from skiing and everything was wonderful.
There is a bar next to the restaurant that is lively and fun.
There is no doubt that the next time we are in Telluride we will visit the New Sheridan again.
the Chop House is pricey (same as any good quality steak or chop house) but worth every cent!
Great food! Not many choices for our little guy but otherwise a good dinner.
Just be prepared to open you wallet. Best food in town
Greatest restaurant in Telluride! The bison is to die for
Tables by the windows can be cold. Especially in the corner.
Steak was over done. Shouldnt happen at a steakhouse. Minus 1 star.
A very good steakhouse. Not in the league of the best steakhouses I have been to, but close. Great choice while in Telluride.
Everything was amazing
Birthday dinner with my Lady. As always, we were treated excellent. The thai chili mussels were amazing! The bison was spot on! The waiter brought out dessert for my Girlfriend and made her feel really special
The staff are real pros. Friendly and engaging. We visit Telluride for a week once and year and we always dine here at least once. Always exceptional experience. . Love this place! Fantastic tasteful food and prepared and presented with perfection in a very comfortable setting.
Outstanding food. Service professional. They do not rush you. Beautiful setting. One of our favorites in Telluride
Excellent food! Service a little slow but I think that was due to 2 large parties sitting at the same time. Noise level was fine. Excellent wine selection. We had steak, salmon, and pasta. All were delicious! I will be returning next time we are in Telluride.
Amazing as always❤️
Excellent across the board!! Best Creme brûlée in Teluride!!!!
We loved the atmosphere and the service was excellent. Out food was the best we had over the hole trip. We enjoyed is so much that we went back for breakfast the next morning. Still the service was great and the breakfast was out of this world. Highly recommended !
Fantastic food and great service. Friendly staff and helpful when you need them. Our favorite in Telluride!
Favorite restaurant in Telluride, always great.
Absolutely superb. They gave us a gorgeous corner hideaway table, right at street view. Service was impeccable. Food tops. Highly recommended.
Food was good (small portions, ala carte) too expensive! Desert for 2 was disappointing (especially for Valentine's Day) and cost as much as a meal. Without drinks, our bill was over $300 before tip.
Fantastic service and incredible food! Steak Tartare is a MUST!!
We feel so well taken care at The Chop House. The food and service are great, and the wine list is extensive from reasonable priced to high end vintages. We always reserve a night here on our trips to Telluride.
Great place but expect to wait to be seated. Small bar in front packed three deep but it was fun. French Onion soup and Tar Tar were better than most. The duck two ways was excellent. The linguini not as good. My guest wolfed down the Ribeye fast so I’m thinking it a sure fire winner. Staff was great.
overall a great experience - however, we felt that a number of the items were very overpriced
Booth - cramped for four
Brussel sprouts - exceptional
Mac 'n cheese - exceptional
Garlic French fries - very good
Mushroom soup - very good
Elk - good. Real Colorado elk is better
Steak - good. Very good flavor, tough.
Wine list - complete and only slightly over-priced
Service - very, very good
Great restaurant! Excellent service!
Absolutely amazing !!! Couldn’t ask for better all around !!!
We choose to dine here every time we are visiting Telluride. The good is amazing, the ambiance is wonderful and the service has never disappointed. One of the very best Telluride has to offer!
Always a favorite spot when visiting Telluride! The staff is so very attentive and the food is fabulous.
It's always a pleasure to dine at the New Sheridan Chop House. The food and the ambiance are second only to the service.
Very good but not Great food...Somewhat disappointed in the elk loin chop dinner since it was very tough even though it was cooked medium rare. Very nice atmosphere
Great place with high quality staff.
One of favorite Telluride spots. Very good as usual.
Excellent food and service at one of our “go-to” favorites in Telluride, especially when we want good steak and irresistible truffle fries. But this time, one of our group of four tried the hamachi yellowtail tuna, served seared & rare, with ponzu sauce, and it was really delicious. Also outstanding was the cherry topped cheesecake. We always love the atmosphere, cocktails, ambiance and noise level at this restaurant, which is generally pleasantly lively & busy, but not so loud you can’t enjoy conversations.
The food was wonderful!!! We have been visiting this restaurant for many years while on vacation and we are always very pleased with our choice!!!
Si no es por el pan, habría sido perfecta.
GREAT dinner! We enjoyed the delicious food, wonderful service and the ambiance! The steaks were amazing. Service was flawless. Wonderful wine list. We could find no fault!!!
17 years together. We were treated to a special Anniversary evening. Staff paid us special attention. Fabulous table for two with privacy. Food was out of this world !!!!
Fabulous ambiance and service. Very expensive but it was our last dinner on vacation so we felt a splurge was in order! I'd definately return for a last night dinner again!
Excellent food, service and ambiance for a special occasion!