Best restaurants near me in Mystic Island, NJ

408 restaurants available nearby

1. Tuckers Tavern

4.4

Price: Moderate

• American • Long Beach Island

Booked 26 times today

A Beach Haven local favorite inspired by the best American Taverns and British Pubs, featuring a local coastal menu, raw bar, and an ever-changing selection of craft beers. For reservations over 8, please call the restaurant. The Buoy Bar rooftop is open weather permitting during the season and Outdoor seating is first-come, first-serve.

2. Smithville Inn

4.7

Exceptional(4394)

Price: Expensive

• American • Galloway

Booked 32 times today

Old world charm meets new world hospitality in this lovely lakeside landmark. A longtime locals favorite serving award winning classic continental cuisine with a modern flair. The restaurant, resurrected from an uncertain future in 1997 by the combined efforts of the Coppola & Bushar families, has since reclaimed its spot among the favorite dining locations in the Atlantic City area.

A photo of Stefano's Restaurant restaurant

3. Stefano's Restaurant

4.9

Exceptional(2841)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Long Beach Island

Booked 21 times today

CURRENT RESERVATION POLICY:-RESERVATIONS ARE ONLY AVAILABLE 2 WEEKS IN ADVANCE.-WE DO NOT ACCOMMODATE PARTIES LARGER THAN 8.-DINERS OF ALL AGES MUST BE ACCOUNTED FOR WITHIN RESERVATIONS.CANCELLATIONS:-MUST BE CANCELLED BEFORE NOON THE DAY OF RESERVATION.-$10 PER PARTY MEMBER WILL BE CHARGED FOR A CANCELLATION AFTER 12PM. Stefano’s Restaurant offers a fine dining experience for over 30yr on Long Beach Island, New Jersey. Our contemporary Italian and Coastal Cuisine will awaken your taste buds and surprise your palate with unique and innovative dishes. Our menu offers selected dished that have been perfected through time. Stefano’s is an experience in fine dining that will leave a lasting memory.

4. Daddy O

4.5

Awesome(1110)

Price: Expensive

• American • Long Beach Island

Booked 15 times today

Daddy O is a modern and chic yet comfortable boutique 22 room hotel on Long Beach Boulevard with a casual bistro and bar seating and a stylish dining room. Dine indoors or on the outdoor garden patio and bar or enjoy sushi and specialty cocktails on the rooftop deck. Our chefs prepare modern interpretations of American classics served by a friendly staff. We welcome walk-ins for large parties or intimate dining. Join us for a drink or casual meal at the bar which features weekend entertainment and a festive happy hour.

5. The Gables

4.8

Exceptional(2294)

Price: Very Expensive

• Contemporary American • Long Beach Island

Booked 19 times today

The Gables offers exclusively a 3-course pre-fixe menu starting at 120 per person plus tax & tip. Menu changes weekly. Please note, supplemental charges apply to select menu items. We offer a lovely selection of red and white wines by the bottle from Bellview Winery. Wear designer socks when dining at The Gables, our Beach Haven, NJ restaurant. They may well be knocked off by the imaginative seasonal fare at our 2007-08 Zagat rated 26 "Exceptional to Perfection"This historic Victorian Jersey Shore inn is open nightly for dinner during the summer season, and Thursday through Sunday from Fall to Spring. We also host memorable private parties and weddings in this most romantic of settings.Prime Parking: Tesla and EV charging stations available for guests upon request.

A photo of Isola Italian Trattoria restaurant

6. Isola Italian Trattoria

4.7

Exceptional(322)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • North Beach Haven

Booked 25 times today

Benvenuto! We are a trattoria on Long Beach Island, thrilled to serve guests the most fresh and authentic Italian cuisine! We all take a lot of pride and are passionate about delivering the best experience possible.Please note, when booking reservations with us, it is imperative that you include children/infants into the guest count for your reservation. Failure to do so can result in us being unable to accommodate your reservation due to small restaurant and not having larger tables available at all times.We look forward to serving you soon!

7. Engleside Inn

4.6

Exceptional(1706)

Price: Expensive

• American • Beach Haven

Booked 25 times today

The Engleside Inn, located in Beach Haven, New Jersey, not only provides its guests with excellent lodging, but it also contains the Leeward Room for fine dining. This on-site restaurant has made a name for itself over the years as one of the finest in the Long Beach islands area. There is also a bar in this restaurant within the Engleside Inn where guests can select from an excellent list of wines and liquors. Premium steaks are a big part of the draw at the Leeward Room at the Engleside Inn. You can find many other examples of fine American cuisine on the menu, such as the scallops encrusted with wasabi or the chicken breast glazed in ginger.

A photo of Howard's Seafood Restaurant restaurant

8. Howard's Seafood Restaurant

4.5

Awesome(1297)

Price: Very Expensive

• Seafood • Beach Haven

Booked 22 times today

What started as just a counter and a few tables has grown into a place where generations come together to celebrate summer at the Jersey Shore! Famous for the Original French Fried Lobster and award winning chowder, Howard's has been serving Long Beach Island visitors and locals since 1950! Staying true to our family roots while keeping up with culinary trends. Fresh seafood and harbor side dining go hand in hand when you’re on Long Beach Island. At Howard’s, we combine our love of seafood with a charming ambiance to make for a delicious and memorable dining experience. After a long day at the beach, come by and relax, and enjoy the tradition of Howard’s Restaurant.MENU HIGHLIGHTS:*The Original French Fried Lobster*Award Winning Clam Chowder*Orange-Miso Glazed Scallops *Pecan Flounder

9. Capitano

4.0

Excellent(122)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Beach Haven

Booked 21 times today

At Capitano Italian Coastal Kitchen, we bring the flavors of the Italian coast to Beach Haven, New Jersey. Our passion for authentic Italian classics and fresh seafood has been a culinary dream years in the making. Our chefs meticulously craft each dish with the finest ingredients to ensure a memorable dining experience.We are BYOB.Please Note: Due to the nature of our kitchen, we regret to inform our guests that we are unable to accommodate shellfish allergies. While we take great care in preparing our dishes, cross-contamination with shellfish products is possible. We apologize for any inconvenience this may cause and appreciate your understanding.

A photo of Hell's Kitchen - Caesars Atlantic City restaurant

10. Hell's Kitchen - Caesars Atlantic City

4.6

Exceptional(3114)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Atlantic City

Booked 54 times today

Hell’s Kitchen Atlantic City pulls themes from all of Gordon Ramsay’s ventures incorporating the Hell’s Kitchen show, his signature items, his fiery personality, and his overall brand to deliver a unique new restaurant. Open for dinner and drinks, Hell’s Kitchen is a bustling, large, and breathtaking space with a stunning mix of Hell’s Kitchen experiences, and modern décor. Its stunning interior will offer guests a premium experience with a stunning pitchfork chandelier feature that ties both levels of the restaurant together. Talented Chef’s hand selected from the Gordon Ramsay team will offer culinary delights. The menu will be a culmination of all things Gordon serving his signature dishes, memorable show items, and nationally trending food items. Kitchen take overs will be held and you’ll never know which celebrity Chef or previous Hell’s Kitchen contestant may stop by and prepare the meal of your life.