Instantly increase your points with dining rewards
See availability for bonus point tables
Sun 7:30PM - 9:00PM
Mon 8:30PM - 9:00PM
Tue 8:00PM - 9:00PM
Wed - Thu 8:30PM - 9:00PM
Fri - Sat 9:00PM - 10:00PM
Exceptional meal service and ambiance
The whole experience was terrifying c.
As usual, a wonderful meal and terrific service from this amazing restaurant!
I went for a romantic Valentine’s Day dinner and ended up leaving engaged.
Always saw this place was full of customers especially in the summer so we took a chance for my wife's birthday. Although small, the interior decor was quite pleasant in wood style. Being off season it appeared most customer now were "regulars" as each table greeted one another on this evening. The food was excellently prepared and presented, my only problem was with the side combo of french fries and fried onion. To little fries and they were buried under the onions. So you had to eat through the onions to find the fries. No dessert, only expresso for coffee which was very smooth. Will have to make a return to see how the service fares when it is a packed house in the summer. Very thing was excellent this time......
Consistently good! lively atmosphere excellent service
Friendly greeting, prompt seating. Our waitress Lori was attentive and provided super service. We followed her recommendations and were most pleased. Restaurant Week menu had been extended ; good value for a delicious 3 course meal. The restaurant is warm and cozy , but seating is tight.
Great food and service as always. One of my favorite restaurants.
Manhattan clan chowder tasted like it came out of a can, baked clams were tasteless, and the shrimp portion was stingy.
Food was good. Waitstaff were delightful and helpful. Had we not been there before , we would have left as soon as we encountered the hostess. She was short and rather nasty with us. Fortunately, we had no contact with her once we were finally seated. We each had something different and all enjoyed.
Was great. I’ve been getting reactions to fish. My waitress and the cook made me. A Vegetarian dinner. It was delicious. Thank you
Food was superb. Server suggested great dishes. Preparation for courses took too long. Runners have language barriers.
Service from the hostess to the wait staff was fabulous; friendly and attentive without being overbearing. We had mussels and filet of sole. All was delicious.
The food, as usual, was excellent. The service was slooooow. It's consistently slow. The porterhouse for 2 is overpriced.
Very very good. Fresh food, served nicely
Have been gong here for yeas and the food is consistently good.
I had the swordfish special and it was outstanding.
Great food, great service!
We were celebrating our anniversary and we were very pleased with the food and service we received.
the menu allows for all types of diets . As a group we are always dieting and they will accommodate our requests
We have been there twice and the food, both times was wonderful.
The oysters were fresh and delicious. I had the halibut and it was perfectly cooked. The swordfish and black bass that my family had were also very well received!
We come here frequently and it’s never disappointing.
The fish was very dry
Always great food. Best swordfish around
The same staff has been working here since I started coming 15 years ago. That says a lot. Consistently great food and service.
The oyster raw n rickafella was great ,lobster 2 lbs at regular price on mon( usually 2 for 1) on Xas eve no complain
Steak is great as compare with other steak house
Nautilus never disappoints. The asian fried calamari appetizer is out of this world, best fried calamari around. The halibut special is absolutely delicious. The bronzini, sole and surf and turf were sure fire hits this time. The portions are generous. The caesar salad is light and tangy. The asparagus crab bisque was creamy, but not too heavy.
The staff makes you feel like family. They are friendly and attentive without being intrusive.
This is our go to for special occasion dinners as well as for a mid week treat as the early bird and steak night specials can't be beat!!
Excellent seafood at moderate prices. The tiramisu was a disappointment. Would definitely recommend the Nautilus Cafe and will go again.
Excellent and consistent . We love going there for lunch and the early bird specials are great
The martinis are to die for. The food is fresh and delicious.
The food is consistently delicious here. The seafood is always fresh.
We go back again and again because we love the ambience. If you can’t get a reservation, sit at the bar!
Great food. Friendly and helpful staff. We love coming here and do come often.,
in our opinion this is one of the best retaurants on LI
we have been many times
THis time I had Halibut with lobsterpieces an sause =superb-best version of halibut I hav ever had
my wifeand sole and it was great
desert was a moose cake very good
we have had staek, roast beef and lobster all great
I go every year for my birthday for the lobster. It got very expensive this year.
There was a table next to us with a 2 year old that would not stop screaming. This family was either related or very good friends with the staff as they did nothing about the screaming or the extremely loud videos the child was watching on the mothers phone.
Another group actually moved their table because of the child.
The management should pay attention to the paying customers to make sure everyone is comfortable.
Do not know if I will return to this restaurant again.
Food was terrific. Noisy because it is not a large place and it was crowded. Server could have been more attentive.
The food is always great and the choices were excellent
Been to Nautilus many times. We meet our friends for lunch every few months, and this is our meeting place
Brian, the waiter is always friendly and courteous.
Had the prix fixed menu. We each got different dishes and all were delicious. My DH and I had fried oysters, my gf had caprese salad and her DH had the crab and asparagus soup. My DH had prime rib, my g f had the banking, and my friends husband and I had tuna. All were very tasty. Portions are a decent size and potatoes and broccoli are served family style
Dessert, wine and coffee were good too
Can’t wait to return after the new year
Great seafood. really knows how to prepare fish. Had the local Bay Scallops, died and went to heaven.
Can't wait to go back.
My husband and I decided to visit Freeport for the Electric Boat Parade and were looking for a place to dine. The Nautilus was on Trip Advisor’s Top Ten Restaurants in Freeport, so we made reservations on this past Saturday night prior to the boat parade. We arrived early and waited at the bar to have a table with a view of the boats and Woodcleft Canal. Chuck, the bar tender, was personable and friendly. Once seated we were pleasantly informed that we could get the Early Bird Dinner which was salad or soup, a side dish and dessert and coffee included with any entree. My husband and I both ordered from their specials and were delighted with our choices. I had the Peconic Bay scallops and my husband had haddock with shrimp and clams. Our waitress was also personable and friendly. We were very pleased with every aspect of our dining experience and will definitely return.
It was our first time there. Good food, good service, good pricing. Everything was enjoyable. The Hostess has a good sense of humor. We will be back.