Best American Restaurants in Edgartown

The Terrace at the Charlotte InnThe Terrace at the Charlotte Inn
(244)
$$$$
American | Edgartown, Cape Cod and the Islands
Outermost InnOutermost Inn
(10)
$$$$
American | Vineyard Haven, Cape Cod and the Islands
Stomping Grounds GrilleStomping Grounds Grille
(75)
$$$$
American | Sandwich Village, Cape Cod and the Islands
Booked 1 time today
Ross' GrillRoss' Grill
(427)
$$$$
American | Provincetown, Cape Cod and the Islands
Booked 1 time today
Victor'sVictor's
(630)
$$$$
American | Provincetown, Cape Cod and the Islands
Belfry Inn and BistroBelfry Inn and Bistro
(663)
$$$$
American | Sandwich Village, Cape Cod and the Islands
Booked 1 time today
The Aquinnah Shop RestaurantThe Aquinnah Shop Restaurant
(11)
$$$$
American | Vineyard Haven, Cape Cod and the Islands
Mooncussers TavernMooncussers Tavern
(503)
$$$$
American | Harwich Port, Cape Cod and the Islands
Brant Point Grill at the White ElephantBrant Point Grill at the White Elephant
(594)
$$$$
American | Nantucket, Cape Cod and the Islands
Quick's Hole TavernQuick's Hole Tavern
(75)
$$$$
American | Falmouth, Massachusetts, Cape Cod and the Islands
The Club at New SeaburyThe Club at New Seabury
(7)
$$$$
American | Mashpee, Cape Cod and the Islands

Best Italian Restaurants in Edgartown

Alberto's RistoranteAlberto's Ristorante
(1007)
$$$$
Italian | Hyannis, Cape Cod and the Islands
Booked 4 times today
Osteria la CivettaOsteria la Civetta
(394)
$$$$
Italian | Falmouth, Massachusetts, Cape Cod and the Islands
Booked 3 times today
Siena RestaurantSiena Restaurant
(648)
$$$$
Italian | Mashpee, Cape Cod and the Islands
Giulia RestaurantGiulia Restaurant
(791)
$$$$
Italian | Cambridge, Boston
Booked 24 times today
SorellinaSorellina
(3238)
$$$$
Italian | Back Bay, Boston
Booked 65 times today
Il CapriccioIl Capriccio
(2546)
$$$$
Italian | Waltham, Boston Suburbs
Booked 25 times today
Toscano RestaurantToscano Restaurant
(2006)
$$$$
Italian | Beacon Hill, Boston
Booked 33 times today
Rossetti Restaurant of LynnRossetti Restaurant of Lynn
(907)
$$$$
Italian | Lynn, Boston Suburbs
Booked 5 times today
Bar MezzanaBar Mezzana
(206)
$$$$
Italian | South End, Boston
Booked 53 times today
Pane e Vino ProvidencePane e Vino Providence
(2108)
$$$$
Italian | Providence, Rhode Island
Booked 23 times today
Camille's RestaurantCamille's Restaurant
(1522)
$$$$
Italian | Providence, Rhode Island
Booked 25 times today
Mamma MariaMamma Maria
(3564)
$$$$
Italian | North End, Boston
Booked 54 times today
Davio's - BostonDavio's - Boston
(1688)
$$$$
Italian | Back Bay, Boston
Booked 27 times today
L'AndanaL'Andana
(4326)
$$$$
Italian | Burlington, Massachusetts, Boston Suburbs
Booked 20 times today
Primo - RocklandPrimo - Rockland
(2249)
$$$$
Italian | Rockland, Maine, Maine
PrezzaPrezza
(1512)
$$$$
Italian | North End, Boston
Booked 17 times today
Trattoria Romana In WakefieldTrattoria Romana In Wakefield
(1695)
$$$$
Italian | Wakefield, Rhode Island, Rhode Island
Booked 5 times today

Popular restaurants in New England

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in New England

Les Sablons
(322)
$$$$
Contemporary French | Cambridge
Article 24
(148)
$$$$
American | Brighton
Harvest
(247)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Cambridge
View all New England restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Edgartown restaurants.

Edgartown Restaurants

The Terrace at the Charlotte InnThe Terrace at the Charlotte Inn
244 reviews
$$$$
American | Edgartown, Cape Cod and the Islands

I booked this place for our first wedding anniversary and the food from the appetizers to the main course till the desert that came out was exquisite. The staff was super friendly and the chef did an amazing job with my fillet mignon. Would definitely recommend to anyone visiting Martha’s Vineyard More

OpenTable Diner -
The Grill on MainThe Grill on Main
5 reviews
$$$$
American | Edgartown, Cape Cod and the Islands

You can’t beat their 2. For 1 entrees. They make the overpriced main dishes affordable More

OpenTable Diner -
Lighthouse GrillLighthouse Grill
101 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Edgartown, Cape Cod and the Islands

Our server, Chris, was very personable and attentive. The food was wonderful. We will definitely be returning in the future. More

OpenTable Diner -

Discover Edgartown

As a town on Martha's Vineyard surrounded by the ocean, Edgartown's dining scene revolves around the sea. You can enjoy traditional seafood dishes like New England clam chowder, whole lobsters, or fillets of fresh cod at either an upscale restaurant or a quaint seafood shack. You can also try something more unconventional by ordering a take-out clam bake to bring with you to the beach. While Edgartown might be known for its seafood offerings, this town has options for everyone. For those in the mood for something creative, try one of the New American spots. For something classic, opt for a burger at a grill or diner. You can even stop at Edgartown's own brewery for a taste of a local beer with your dinner.