Very good food and service. The atmosphere was very comfortable and nautical. I recommend this restaurant.
The staff and food were amazing .. they were genuine passionate about the food and were able to explain and recommend very well.. the scallops and hog fish were exceptional!
Everyone enjoyed their meal our waiter Brian was excellent!
Excellent as usual.
Have dined here dozens of times over the course of 12 years and we are never disappointed
Our server Brian was top notch
The fish is fresh and well prepared
Had the crab cakes for the first time and they too were outstanding
Portions are substantial
So glad Mystic Fish opens at 4:30 on Sundays, because it's our go-to place for pre-concert dinner on the way to hear the Florida Orchestra at Ruth Eckerd Hall. My friend and I both thoroughly enjoyed our meals, and the happy hour wine prices were an added bonus. Tim was an attentive and knowledgeable server, who made us feel 'unrushed' and valued as customers.
I recommend Mystic Fish to anyone who will listen. It's been our favorite restaurant for almost 20 years!
Love this restaurant....food is always consistent!
Pleasant family-like environment with well intended yet not well trained servers. They mean well and try their best. Ours needed to be reminder to bring my wife silverware, after she forgot to bring me a knife and I borrowed my wife's. I requested that a 2014 Napa Cab Sauv for decanting, the waitress decanted the wine, but never presented it for tasting prior to decanting. Overall it's very pleasant experience providing your expectations are not too high. I think they would do better if they did not accept so many seatings between 6:30 to 7:30.
Saturday night we went with friends and it was our first time. I/we were pleasantly surprised. Food was awesome, waitress very attentive and didn't wait long for food. We will be going back for sure. Grilled scallops just out of this world. Nice night.
In general the food was very good. Unfortunately, the chicken breast on my caesar salad was quite dry.
We were greeted by the hostess and seated right on time for our reservation. The restaurant is charming with fish tanks and beautiful decor. Our waiter was attentive and made sure we always had water and whatever anyone wanted. The food was served in a timely fashion and everything was hot and delicious. We will definitely continue to go back!
The food is always outstanding. Never had a sub-standard meal.
Always have at least one meal here when we are in the area. Food and drinks are outstanding. The early dinner specials are a great value.
Nice restaurant with an original, interesting menu. Friendly staff and good service. Will definitely be back.
The staff and management made us feel wonderful on our special day...our 42nd wedding anniversary! Mystic Fish has been and will continue be our favorite restaurant for my wife and me as well as our “go to” place when we entertain family and/or friends.
Good food, great service. I like that the Caesar salad comes with anchovies and I asked for extra. I had ribeye and it was cooked as requested. My fiancée had shrimp and scallops over linguini and she liked it.
Wonderful dinner. Waiter was great an very on time
Excellent service, food, attention to detail. Great coffee!!! Would highly recommend. The duck was very good as were the lobster tails. A dessert was provided for free to help us celebrate our special date. Love this restaurant!
Excellent as always
Reservation was for 6:45 PM. We were there on time. We were seated at 7:10 PM. It was Mother's Day so they were busy, but we sat outside for 25 minutes waiting for the table. Place is great, everybody is friendly, food is delicious, service was good. Never had to wait like this before. Been there quite a few and will go again.
Delicious, creative, and high quality dining! This is our favorie restaurant for a wonderful meal. Everything about Mystic Fish is special. We love the decor too!
We love the Mystic Fish. Varied menu with tempting specials. Love the Bison filet or the panko crusted Snapper. The desserts are perfect size and price. Never encountered poor wait staff.
Great Mother’s Day lunch! Service was top notch, food and ambiance was very good. Well done!
We had a very pleasant Mother’s Day lunch here and we usually don’t like to eat out on holidays because it can be a lesser experience than restaurants are usually capable of. We were very happy with everything at Mystic Fish. As always, service was excellent and our meals were exceptional. We started with delicious oysters that were extremely fresh, progressed to strawberry, avocado salad and Caesar salads, then to lobster rolls that were loaded with large chunks of tender lobster. We had just had lobster rolls at another local restaurant recently and the difference was remarkable. I would love for Mystic Fish to offer Sunday brunch. <3
Awesome meal! After getting a lot of recommendations, we went for Mother's Day lunch. Food was outstanding, cocktails were great, and the atmosphere was perfect! Our server Jill was the BEST EVER!!!! I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone for a special occasion, we will definitely be back many times!
Fish was prepared to perfection for different fish meals. Vegetables were so good.
The dinner was heavenly! We started with grilled octopus, a first for the both of us and it was out of this world! For dinner we had the Chilean sea bass which was amazing, and the shrimp and scallops linguine. The scallops were cooked perfectly and it was really a fantastic meal all around. We will definitely go back!
It was very good, Joel was a delight service was excellent
The food was outstanding. We had the octopus appetizer and it was tender and perfect. The black grouper was divine. One of the best meals I've had in the Clearwater area.
The food is always fabulous and the service is excellent.
Wonderful restaurant. Creative menu. Have never had a bad or mediocre meal here. Our favorite in the area.
A friendly welcome at the door, solid service and food that was amazing in flavor and quality. The grouper I had was best in my life.
Seems like the ownership really cares. They are always checking to be sure everything is right. And it was amazing.
Brought friends for first time visit. They definitely will be back!
I loved the sea bass and my sides were also good. Mashed potato and green beans; great hard roll and avocado butter was nice. The desserts are small and tasty, nice not to be soooo large. I will be going to Mystic Fish again soon.
Always a great place to dine with outstanding food, service and selections.
We absolutely love Mystic Fish. Never a bad meal!!!
Mystic Fish is a new favorite! Three of us met to celebrate a special birthday on a Friday night for a late evening dinner. We loved it! We enjoyed a perfect dinner and every entrée we chose was a worthy selection. The service was phenomenal and we'll be back again soon!
Tbis was a business meeting that, as always, led first time patrons, the opportunity to
enjoy Mystic Fish and plan on returning. The restaurant offers a dining experience.
This was my second time there. Great food and wonderful service .
We’ve eaten at Mystic Fish 3 times - the food is delicious every time. We’ve had different waiters each time & they are attentive & helpful by answering our questions. Would highly recommend.