Mystic Fish is our go to for all special occasions. My husband and I absolutely love this place. We always ask if the bison filet is available because there is nothing that can compare. It is pricey but worth every penny. I love that the appetizers and desserts are smaller so that you can get both and eat your meal too. Mystic Fish will always be my choice for any special occasion because I have yet to find anything that compares.
Anniversary dinner; off a plane right to mystic fish one of our favorites in the Tampa area. Food is always wonderful and service over the top without being intrusive. For dessert brought creme brûlée and chocolate mousse on the house. Nice touch.
We were celebrating with friends and Mystic Fish never lets you down.
The service and knowledgeable staff are a great feature of this restaurant.
As no Hofish was available for our party to enjoy the alternative suggested was excellent.
Five Stars again for Mystic Fish.
We always can count on very fresh fish! It’s served with some of the most unique sauces created by the chef!
We enjoy the ambiance as well. Outstanding service too!
We visit about 3 times a month. We have eaten a variety of items on the menu. Always excellent.
We hadn’t been in a while and plan to come back again soon. Food/wine/dessert was delicious
The food and service were both 5 star superlative. The route to the bathroom was a little crowded but that didnt matter much. Decor was very well done. Aquariums were beautiful and how appropriate for a fish restaurant!
Yummy seafood, butter is divine, flourless choc cake and creme brulee bday dessert (gratis!) ...a wonderful end to a delicious meal.
The 6oz filet that I was charged for, was a 4oz filet and I believe it was cut out of another type of meat...it did not taste like a filet and had began to shrink.... a true tenderloin filet has no fat, so a Medium Rare, would be the same size as it was going on the grill. I can not believe the integrity of some companies, handing out $3 a pound beef...probably teres major, and charging for a $9 a pound beef tenderloin. If I am wrong, correct me, but I have been a corporate chef for 20 years and the quality/taste speaks for itself. Our server only offered bread once, forgot extra dressings and was very slow to refill any beverages and it was 45 minutes for our entrees.... We drove an hour and a half to meet friends there. Was not worth the trip at all.
Creative preparation and presentation of dishes. Favorites are typically their seafood offerings. I have dined at this restaurant many times and have never been disappointed.
Never had a disappointing meal here. Beats all others . Service is super. Quality abounds. Exceptional display of food on plates. Reg Austin and wife, Gladys Cliff
Great time even though our salads were still frozen.
Always enjoy our night out at Mystic Fish!
As usual, the food was delicious. The hogfish is excellent with a wonderful sauce. My husband had shrimp and scallops on linguine with a great sauce. Our waiter, John, was very good. He even ran out to the parking lot to return the credit card my husband had forgotten. It's the restaurant we usually take our guests to.
Great service and great food.
Brian the server was very attentive
We have dined with you on two prior occasions and enjoyed the meal very much. We brought friends visiting from out of the area and they said when they return we must eat here again.
Excellent service - many great food choices - reasonable prices. Thanks
Birthday dinner was spectacular as always. Mellissa our server was great and the food was spot on!
Mystic Fish never fails. It always has the best food, service and value. I highly recommend even if you have to drive an hour...well worth it.
Excellent food ... excellent value. Sorry it took us so many years to discover this great restaurant. Will definitely come back next winter if I'm down again.
BTW my rack of Lamb was superb and hubby raved for the next couple of days about his short ribs.
This place is simply awesome, if you haven't had there Hog Fish or Bermuda Fish Chowder you are missing something large in your life.
Great menu. Small plates and standards! Love the smaller portion desserts.
Great fresh fish and we love the paella. good drinks too
Terrific as usual.
We had our spirits down when we saw a restaurant is in a strip. Mall. This was immediately forgotten when we got inside. Excellent ambience. Great cocktails. Must have Small dishes: octopus, artichoke hearts with crab, lobster snail style. Had Chilean seabus for main - was excellent. Serie was extremely efficient and friendly, with good advice on choices. Definitely a place to visit while in the area.
The food and service is exceptional. Highly recommend the Mystic Fish!
We always have a good meal here. A constant winner. Boullibase is a awesome time after time.
Always great food and service. You can never go wrong...such a great variety to choose from . As a health conscious person, the food is not over seasoned and you can taste the real flavor of the item. Portion sizes are spot on for me which leaves me felling completely satisfied. We absolutely recommend this place😊
We had vegans, sometimes if they cannot find something them can order a baked potato or plain lettuce salad.
It would be nice if you had those.
We eat here frequently. Food is consistently good. However this was the first time we found the atmosphere very distracting. Several noisy tables. This made for a very disappointing environment. Service attentive but a little slow. Maybe this noisy crowd was because it was a Friday. Normally we eat on Sundays.
I love Mystic Fish. The salmon is my favorite. Great service and management
Mystic Fish is our favorite restaurant. The food is consistently great! Highly recommend this neighborhood gem.
Delicious food and noteworthy interior design. Waitstaff was attentive, knowledgeable and very professional. Restaurant owner was on site, checking in on tables to ensure dining experience was memorable. Surpassed our expectations. Would definitely recommend Mystic Fish
This is my in-laws favorite restaurant so we try to take them there every time we visit Florida. However last year when we went, the place was so cold it was miserable. This time I went prepared with fleece and scarf. Surprise, surprise they no longer keep it at walk-in freezer temperature. The fish is very fresh and the presentations are excellent. Would highly recommend this restaurant.
As always Mystic Fish was great. My favorite place to eat in Palm Harbor.
Excellent cuisine. The seafood is so good that we have yet to try any meat or poultry dinners. The preparation is unique and I have yet to be even mildly disappointed in the dinner serving. Creative, healthy and very accommodating t my wife's gluten free dietary restrictions.
Knowledgeable, friendly wait staff (Drew) who was very attentive to our needs. Even though the restaurant was crowded, Drew made us feel like her only customer.
While there are other good seafood restaurants in the Central gulf Coast area there is only one Mystic Fish.
So impressed that we’re going back again before we leave Florida! Highly recommended
Our table of four enjoyed a wonderful meal. As always all the servers and wait staff are terrific. A great place to come for any occassion
Wonderful meal. Great for both seafood and meat dishes. Wait staff is very attentive. Go to this restaurant if you can.