I had the hog fish entree it was excellent I had never tried this before but I will definitely try it again My wife had the seared salmon with pistachio dill pesto her meal was excellent also . the next time we are in Florida this will be one of our stops
Excellent dinner. The Limoncello martinis were fantastic.
Beautifully decorated the food was exceptional and the service was exceptional as well. We will definitely be back!
We went here to dinner on a Friday night. At 6:30 the place was very busy, however the service and the food were very good.
Exceptional as always. True neighborhood gem with ambiance and great price/value for early birds and happy hour. Never been disappointed.
We throughly enjoyed our dining experience
John, our server was great!
Ystic Fish has a.ways been my favorite resterant. The service is excellent. The food is terrific. I recommend it to all my friends.
Outstanding early bird meal. My filet was perfect, tender and exactly how I ordered it. My husbands salmon was just as perfect. I would definitely return!! Price pointr was exceptionally low given the quality and tast of their food.
OMG! Fabulous. I had never been but it was great. The food was wonderful, great portions, Just loved it. Give it a try!
We will be back.
Delicious birthday dinner! Our waitress April surprised me with a sweet birthday desert!
This place is the best in the area. I have eaten there probably a 100 times and have never had a bad meal. The staff is great and the food is unbelievable. Steve one of the bar tenders makes awesome Martini's and the Hogfish and Bermuda Fish Chowder are simply the best anywhere. Tremendous value and superb ownership makes this a must for any person in the area.
Its consistently good.
I need to be more adventurous on the menu as I always order the hogfish !!!
Never had a poor meal here
Loud guests standing next to adjoining table limited our conversation. The food as usual was excellent.
We shared the asian beef short ribs with the wasabe. Tasted great! My wife had the daily special shrimp and scallops on pasta with a creamy red sauce. I had the panco crusted hogfish. Both were great. Good wine list! I would go there again and again!
Mystic Fish never disappoints! When I am in the area, I always make a point to eat here. Your early dining menu offers many selections at an excellent value. I also love your online reservation system.
Great meal, ambiance and service. Jill was very knowledgeable and attentive. Hogfish and Seabass were supurb! Loved the smaller sized desserts - perfect ending to a delicious meal.
Always look forward to; and enjoy our visits. Servers are the best.
In the top 5 of Tampa Bay area
Always cordiaal and professional service, with a thought out menu, and food always served hot!
Excellent meal served by friendly and knowledgeable server. Special occasion of mom's 99th bday. Care given to her and her walker, meal and a complimentary bday dessert. Never felt rushed to leave. Appreciated that reservations were offered and accepted.
Live out of town, visit whenever in town!
Amazing restaurant. Very good food and consistent!
We found the menu offered many good choices, the presentation of the meal was very nice and the food itself was delicious. Four of us were out to dinner. Two of us got the same meal and the other two had different choices. We all thought our entrees were exceptional. The meals are not overpriced and the server was very friendly and helpful. I will definitely be going back there!
While The Mystic Fish is primarily a seafood restaurant, they also carry lots of other menu items and this is our 3rd visit we've never had a bad meal. My partner had a petit tenderloin I had beef short ribs, both excellent. The place is always busy but service is excellent and friendly.
Always excellent. Try their best to exceed expectations. We reserved a specific table and it was waiting for us!!
As always Doug Bebell and staff provided a wonderful meal. Mystic Fish is our local go to restaurant when we want a special meal out or have company we'd like to entertain. We know we will always receive a quality meal and great service. Even if we are just being lazy and don't want a full meal, the small plates are really good and provide lots of variety. His octopus is outstanding and has become a favorite. Mystic Fish is also very involved with community activities and a great support to our local YMCA, which is another factor contributing to our loyalty.
In 14 years of going to Mystic Fish, we have never been disappointed.
A favourite haunt as ?Snowbirds from January to late April. Always a great meal. Thanks Thomas for your special attention to our hearing impaired Aunt. You made her evening special.
Great local place to enjoy a great meal.
Our server John was excellent. He did not rush us and answered every question we had about the menu.
Our meals were seafood and were properly cooked to just flaky and not over done. My entree, Black Grouper, was too salty for my taste. Presentations and sides were very good.
We all enjoyed the dining experience.
We would have preferred a table to a booth but were told by the hostess that all tables for four were unavailable although we saw open tables on the other side of the half wall.
Our guest is 85 and had recently gotten out of the hospital. A chair would have been easier for him to maneuver.
One of my favorite restaurants in Tampa area. The only bad thing is the noise level. You cannot hear others talking at your table. You practically have to scream. They should work on acoustics.
The hog fish was delicious! It was the best entree I have had anywhere in a long time. Completely enjoyed dinner
Always great meals and service here. Hogfish is the best.
Every entrée was superb: hogfish, ribs, crab cakes, and scallops. Server was knowledgeable, just the right sense of pacing.
Our favorite neighborhood resturant. Great early bird dinner from 4:30 - 5:15.
We loved it, had several small plates, great salads, excellence dinner. We love the small bar and will be a regular.
My friend and I loved this restaurant for the interesting menu and great service!
It is one of my favorite places to get scallops. The chef does them perfectly every time. And where else can you get a crab martini but at Mystic Fish.
Reliably excellent! Tapas is fun food for guests. Had an issue with more guests than expected, and the staff found room for us all just a bit later.
As always the hogfish was great! I love the small deserts. You can have several without feeling like your over indulging.