Mr. B's - A Bartolotta Steakhouse - Brookfield - Indoor Main Dining Room Only
Mr. B's is a classic Italian steakhouse featuring an array of prime cuts that are cooked to perfection in a custom 1100-degree wood-burning oven. The preparation gives the steaks a caramelized, buttery crust, creating a flavor and texture that makes for one of the best steaks you've ever had. In addition to steaks, the menu at Mr. B's offers fresh seafood and a wide variety of entrees, appetizers and desserts.
Marinated Wood Oven Roasted Top Sirloin with Haystack Onions, Mushrooms and Aioli on a Sciortino's Roll
Filet and Salmon
Lobster Mac N' Cheese
Maine Lobster Tossed with Cavatappi Pasta, House-made Cheese Sauce, and Topped with Herbed Breadcrumbs
I will not be going back.
The food at Mr. B's has been iffy for the last few years, but we went back last night to try it again. The steaks did get a bit better, although the rest of the food was underwhelming. It was the actual dining experience that has officially turned me off from any Bartolotta's restaurant for the foreseeable future.
Just read the recent one star reviews from previous guests and that is pretty much on point. I have been to quite a few formal steakhouses during COVID, and I absolutely appreciate the precautions and rules restaurants need to put into place, but the ones Mr. B's had in place made the entire evening extremely awkward and uncomfortable. The atmosphere made me feel like Mr. B's would rather we just not be there. If a restaurant does not want patrons, then just shut down or do take out only. For the price you pay versus the quality of food and the way uncomfortable way you are treated, I would recommend taking your money elsewhere. There are plenty of other steakhouses in the area that have done a MUCH better job pre and post COVID.
They met all safety concerns. First dinner out in over 6 months. I highly recommend it.
Doing a good job with Covid protocol. They won’t approach your table unless you have your mask on. That can be a little cumbersome in the beginning but they’re doing a good job with precautions.
I have now tried Mr. B's several times in the hope the first time was a fluke. This is not a premier steakhouse. There are many better options in Southeast Wisconsin. I ordered a ribeye - counting on good marbling. VERY disappointed in the piece of steak I received.
We have not been to many restaurants since March when Covid hit. Mr. B’s did a great job of making us feel comfortable at their establishment with QR code menus if we wanted or sanitized after every use regular menus. The food was outstanding and service was very good. The staff gave us information on the restrictions and how everything should work. I would go back again and hope to soon.
Conscientious care was taken to prevent the spread of COVID-19. Our temperatures were taken as we entered the restaurant. Masks must be worn while engaged with staff and moving around the facility. The food was excellent and worth the money spent.
PLEASE ADD PRIME MEATS. MR. B'S HAS BEEN MY LOCATION TO FIND THE BEST STEAKS.
Had a very nice experience. Restaurant and staff took precautions to ensure customers were safe but still able to enjoy the elegant dining experience that Mr B’s provides.
I look forward to our next visit.
Added $8 cleaning service fee without asking. Food was just ok. I have had better steak at Outback. Way over priced!
Have eaten here many times & it’s always an outstanding dining experience. Food is excellent. Service is excellent. There were certain limitations due to the pandemic, but they do everything they can possibly do to make it safe for you. Highly recommend!
Always love going to this place but this time was a little different due to COVID. They are very strict with their precautions which I understand but takes away from your dinner that you need to put your mask on every time they come to your table. Overall, the food and service were amazing and always enjoy the fireplace.
We always love the Bartolotta’s, but during COVID it’s very different. I don’t mind wearing a mask or having our temperature taken at the doorway but you also have to have a mask on when the servers check on you. They will even wait to give you your food until your mask is on. I felt like they really rushed us. They gave us our check quickly and didn’t have much time for us. We were in there no more than 30 minutes. My husband and I came in to use the coupon they gave us for my birthday and had drinks and desserts. It seemed like they were unhappy that we came just for that. I haven’t noticed that at other restaurants before. We still spent around $50 and left a nice tip. We want to support local businesses, but felt like the service was average at best because of how we felt we were treated. I’m sure they would treat you just fine if you got a full meal, but we didn’t really like the atmosphere of constantly putting your mask on and off. It’s a little anxiety inducing and difficult to relax and fully enjoy the experience. On a positive note the desserts and drinks were fabulous!
We were trying to find a place to celebrate our anniversary that was doing things as safely as possible during COVID. We made an excellent choice! Tables are spaced out well, the staff is masked at all times and provided you are willing to follow the protocols in place, to be respectful of all involved, it is a lovely experience! Same outstanding food to enjoy, same exceptional service delivered and done in as safe a way as possible. It was an extremely enjoyable experience. Highly recommend Mr. B’s in this unusual time.
We have dined here many times over the years. There Covid safety rules are way to over the top. Mask on everytime someone gets within 10ft of your table!
It was not a relaxing evening at all. Steak was great but I could't wait to eat and get out of there.
There are many good steak choices in Waukesha county area. I won't be back to this one for a long time.
A wonderful dining experience offered in a way that is both responsible and respectful. Those looking for a fine dining experience about which they can feel very comfortable in the midst of our epic pandemic will be very pleased with Mr. B's.
A DELIGHTFUL EVENING WITH GOOD FOOD AND ATTENTIVE SERVICE.
AN ENJOYABLE EXPERIENCE.
great food and atmosphere. service was excellant!!
Try their porterhouse! Its one of the best! Will definitely go back!
Great service and great food as always. I've never been disappointed here.
Very good food, everything prepared as requested. Service was outstanding.
Wonderful evening with much attention to Covid responsibility which made us feel safe and allowed us to enjoy the evening even more.
Very pleasant time. It’s a little cumbersome to put your mask up every time someone approaches the table, especially while your actually eating, but everyone was wonderful to deal with and we very much enjoyed our dinner.
Great food. Great service. Great atmosphere. Love it.
It was combined for our Anniversary and Birthdays as you errr closed due to COVID.
Amazing food, amazing service! We had a great time celebrating our anniversary. Thank your Mr. B's for fantastic service, we can't wait to come back.
Ridiculous mask rules. Ruined our evening. Food was meh. Service was rushed because they said you could stay longer than 1.5 hours. Just awful.
Stay away. Go to Waukesha County restaurants that actually care.
We have enjoyed Mr. B's food for many years. A bit pricey but always good food.and service. Glass of Caymus Cabernet overpriced.
Their reaction to covid-19 and masks is a bit ridiculous. Even though the entire staff is wearing masks and tables are spread out they demanded customers wear masks every time a server visited the table (avg. 6-8 times per meal) which made it impossible to enjoy the meal. Very disruptive.
Food as always, was exceptional! Service was top notch and attentive, but the fact that you had to put your mask on when the servers interacted with you was a bit "inconvenient" I will be extremely glad when this Covid business is over!
Great service! The waiters were phenomenal! Can’t wait to come back!
Great service and we appreciated the extra attention to ensure a safe environment without compromising atmosphere and the dining experience. The food was outstanding. We will certainly be back.
Bartolotta's has a strict mask wearing policy which I look for these days. Additionally they take your temp before you are allowed to enter. My wife and I ordered the porterhouse for 2, which was excellent. Our potato dishes, the carrots, the soup and the dessert were also excellent. The service was top-notch.
It was so nice to a delicious dinner. We felt safe with all the safety precautions in place during this Covid pandemic.
COVID preparation was amazing. Very safe. Food was delicious
Nancy and Jeff worked our table. They are the finest servers in the restaurant industry. The food was excellent as it always is. We are returning for another dinner in two weeks.
First, their Brandy Ol'Fashioned's were among my top three best ever.
Best scallops ever.
Very good Filets; cooked exactly to order.
Top notch Creme Brule.
Excellent Covid 19 safety protocols...very politely handled from entering to exiting.
I have noticed some restaurants aren't up to par since the pandemic and to some extent it might be understandable... but Mr. B's was everything we have loved it for in the past. A great experience and no disappointments. Superb food and professional wait staff. They are doing more than most to keep patrons and employees safe with use of masks, distancing, and barriers. Our temps were taken before entering the building. We had guests who hadn't been there before and they were very favorably impressed with all aspects of the evening. There was not an item that wasn't oohed and ahhed over. We all had steaks and they were all cooked to our preferences. The best restaurant meal I have had in over a year and a thoroughly enjoyable evening.
I was very disappointed with the rib eye steak. The marbling of the meat was not optimal in my opinion.
The seafood bisque was very good but I went here for the steak.
Mr. B's - A Bartolotta Steakhouse - Brookfield - Indoor Main Dining Room Only is rated 4.5 stars by 4235 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.