Took 1 1/2 hrs to get salad. Wait staff poorly trained.
Blackened halibut tacos were great!
Been there for special occasions, family dinners and girls' night out. A true fish and seafood restaurant with an abundance of choices and generous portions. The food is fresh, nicely prepared and and customized requests are always honored. The staff is attentive and welcoming. Nightly specials are especially creative and delicious. A bit pricey, but worth it!
Food was not as well seasoned as usual but certainly good quality. Seated originally in booth by cooking stations — too warm. So we were moved to back dining room. They seated 9 behind us and the noise was deafening. This experience did not measure up to our usual ones.
Service was excellent.
An all around family favorite we have enjoyed for years. They have never disappointed us with the food or service
Delicious. Very accommodating. Food took awhile. Will be back either way. Always good!
My wife an I had been to Morgans one other time and On both occasions we found the food to be exceptional. We both tried the Haddock (Grilled and Pan fried); both presentations were superb. We'll definitely go back when we are in the Rye, N.Y area!!!
Morgan's is always a winner: great fresh food and a good variety in a comfortable setting with friendly wait staff. This visit was no different: food, wine and service were right on point. The menu has so many choices, it's easier to give up and order one of the specials (sea trout and veggies--- perfectly cooked.) I never feel rushed here and it's not so noisy you can't enjoy the table conversation. Can't miss .
Salads, soup, and fish were all great - halibut for myself and my husband, cod for my daughter and lobster for my son. The restaurant was fairly empty and yet the wait staff didn't come around often enough for us to get more than a second drink - our only complaint. We would've had 3 drinks had the wait staff been more on top of things, but other than that, an enjoyable evening was had by all.
Always a good meal in a fun, lively environment. Wish they had their brunch menu available.
Went for lunch with a group of 8. Have been before and enjoyed and please to say Morgan’s is consistent. Excellent seafood and service, a first class place. Village of Rye has a nice Main Street that’s great for walking afterwards.
Had a delicious birthday dinner at Morgan's, it was my first visit. The food was delicious, and the waitress was wonderful. We had some very fussy people at the table and she handled each request patiently and successfully. And everyone agreed the food was delicious. Will definitely be back again!
Difficult night at the restaurant because the computer system was down. Took a while for the staff to finally get to out table, but they tried to make it up. We'll be back.
Very accommodating and friendly. Food was fantastic, service was great! A bit pricy for a regular night out, but well worth an occasional splurge.
Everything was wonderful, the atmosphere, the food and the service. We felt like we could have easily been eating in a New England seafood place on the Cape. We'll definitely be back!!
I asked for a quiet place but I was told the back dinning room was not available. The main room, located at the entrance was busy and very noisy. Suggestion is the for special evenings with senior customers offer/reserve more areas.
Great menu and awesome recipes make this restaurant one of the best fish houses in all of Westchester. Good selection of wines with a decent neighborhood vibe make Morgan’s a place to go for any occasion.
Service was awful ! Wait staff poorly trained. No manager was present at all.
Food was mediocre at best ! Beer selection was limited.
Nice atmosphere !
Our initial interaction was at 7:30pm with the hostess that said without a reservation we'd be waiting 3 hours. So I used open table to make a 8:00pm reservation for 2 that worked (go figure), no problem. I called the restaurant right away to make sure they had that reservation and we were all set. The woman that answered confirmed out 8pm reservation and stated if we wanted to be 15 minutes late we could as they were running behind. Long story short... we were seated at 9:20pm. Never in a million years would I wait 1 hour and 20 minutes but on this night we had already had a few drinks at the bar down the street so it was comical that an upscale restaurant would actually make people wait that long with the hostess just repeating "next table is yours" over and over again. One table wasn't sat for 2 hours so we actually made out pretty well. LOL. Food was meh. It's edible but nothing to write home about.
Omg I had a first date here ; I made 730 reservations and arrived on time ; there were no empty tables jam packed and noisy . Went to the bar to grab drinks ; the Maitre d (female ) Saturday night , came over to offer us seats at this long table by the bar and we would have had to sit across from one another so we turned it down and asked her to please find us a table in the main restaurant ( bar area too noisy ) and come back to us . She NEVER came back . My date was fuming mad ; we ate at the bar and heard each other well because we were so close ; food was good ; can’t say I would g
Morgan's has been a regular for us and we have eaten there many times. My wife and I had a 7:15 reservation which was accepted by Morgan's, we did not get seated until 8:40. This was a Saturday night, and the place was packed. There was a very large party taking up the entire back room. The problem was that the one and apparently only table they were waiting to seat us at was occupied by a couple that did not leave until the manager went over and asked them to leave, after we told her how upset and angry we were. They did offer high tops but we did not want to be elbow to elbow with the other diners, and have the waiting crowd breathing down our neck. If you make a reservation at a fine dinning restaurant, you should not be asked to eat at the counter like it's fast food. The manager and serving staff did go out of their way to try and make up for the inordinate delay in being seated. They did comp. us on our drinks. We will not being going to Morgan's on a Saturday night again. I am sure based on the crowd, they will not be hurt by this. Just be aware that your reservation will mean nothing, if they have a big party and you are just a couple. We were upset by the treatment, even though they did try to make it up to us. The food as usual was very good.
My only issue was the reservation. My party and I were not seated close to an hour after my reservation. My table was close to entrance so there was a lot of traffic around us. It was a busy night so not much they can do on that end.
We were seated quickly.Food was very good.Halibut and gumbo main courses.
Powerful tobacco aroma at entrance door area.
Service was good, food portions generous.
Want to return to taste multiple appetizers.
Had an excellent Ballast Point sculpin IPA. (2) actually. Overall a comfortable charming dinner.
Nice nautical setting. Excellent fish tacos and delicious mussels. All fish is very fresh and well prepared. Service was prompt and server very accommodating. Anxious to return!
Had lunch with a friend and was craving seafood. Ate octopus and calamari bruschetta and mussels in white wine broth. Both dishes were extremely salty, rendering them unenjoyable. On the bruschetta the octopus was diced so finely that it totally got lost as one of the main ingredients it is supposed to be. The place is nice but I didn't get the great seafood I was expecting and will look elsewhere next time.
Great food! A bit of confusion taking my $25 Open Table Reward but resolved favorably after some explanation.
The lobster paella very good, as was the blackened swordfish and kale salad.
always delicious!! love eating there - never disappoints!
Great food - scallops were great and my husband had the fresh squid ink pasta.
Excellent service once again!! Always a positive dining experience.
Consistently delicious food and courteous service. A local favorite!
Great meal and great service Always a good time and great value
Tuesday $1.00 oyster night fabulous.
Can't wait to go back for more scallops appetizer.
My husband and I had dinner here for the first time. We were seated quickly and service was good. My husband enjoyed the minestrone soup but my calamari were just ok. Our entrees were excellent. I had the gumbo my husband the cod fish with potato croquets and broccolini. Next time we would ask not to sit in the booths across from kitchen. The banging of plates and pots was annoying.
Best waitor is rRichard. He was very attentive to our needs and checked up more regularly to see if we needed anything else..
This restaurant is a little over our budget, but we had a gift card, and it was a good opportunity to indulge. The food was absolutely delicious, and the service was friendly and prompt without being either rushed or intrusive. I asked for a quieter table, and my request was honored. I would go again for a special occasion.
Really excellent choice of fish - cooked all ways. Just incredibly busy! Service was quick though and the food was delicious. We remembered why we like it!
The food was delicious and the service was outstanding.
What a gem! Believe all of the great reviews. This spot has everything going for it...great casual, upscale atmosphere, warm and attentive service and amazing food.
We had a wonderful evening at Morgan’s Fish House. The Mahi Mahi was excellent and the Brussels Sprouts were very good although the bacon should have been freshly made. The most outstanding thing was the crushed cauliflower. Can’t rave enough about this side dish! I want the recipe.