MoonShine - Modern Supper Club
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Contactless payment available
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
The place was closed due to hurricane Ida. Everything is automated. My reservation, my confirmation and reminder to a place that isn't open. It didn't even say they were closed on Google. Please be a responsible restaurant owner and update your information. Natural disasters happen and people will understand if you just say you're closed due to a natural disaster.
It is closed!!!! We showed up for our reservation and lights out, doors locked. Very disappointing and ruined our Saturday night date night plans. We even paid a babysitter. The restaurant should have stopped open table from making reservations.
It’s CLOSED. Like shuttered Why Open Table still has them accepting reservations have no idea. Also even got reminder notices to pls show up and confirm again your reservation. Just crazy
this restaurant has been effected from the hurricane ida, however there was not indication of that on their website, google or open table. highly disappointed!
Service and food food are phenomenal! We had a 12 people reservation for a surprise 40th birthday party, and the staff was amazing. We strongly recommend the restaurant and will be back ourselves.
For what we got, the food was pricey and not consistently good. I had the hanger steak which was good but didn’t blow me away. My wife got the sashimi bowl and it was excessively oily and the tuna was not very good quality. Specifically, it was pretty tough, and for the amount of tuna, we could have gotten much better quality at a lower price at our local japanese restaurant. From an ambiance perspective, we were seated very close to the open kitchen and while I was okay with a little extra noise, I’d suggest keeping the cursing down. My 10 year old was with us and I don’t need her learning any more cursing than she already has. Also, an occasional loud F-bomb doesn’t contribute to a relaxed atmosphere.
Very nice restaurant and ambiance seemed cool for drinks at bar but despite that the service while extremely polite and kind but slow. The food was overwhelmingly bland. No taste and the dessert seemed as if it was out of a carton and I’m fridge for days. We went for the price fix dinner and would not recommend unfortunately.
The ambiance was great for a date. The food, drinks, and deserts give the diner many great options. The only thing that surpasses the food and drinks is the quality and attentiveness of the staff. The service here is first rate.
The recommendations on menu choices were perfect! I never ever order chicken but the jerk chicken was unbelievable along with everything on the plate mango chutney, avocado, plantains, lime creama and did I mention the chicken magnificent!!
Very, very bland food. Service good. Won’t be back - literally none of the food tasted good. Bummer.
Cocktails lovely, service attentive and friendly. The food was goodish. Dish composition and options were very good, they just lacked some finer execution.
Shorts ribs tasty, jus too greasy but, not far away from a belting plate.
Mushroom pizza again good size, but the mushrooms chewy…..
Calamari again tasty and tender, too much sauce made several pieces unnecessarily soggy, but I stress a good dish.
Deffo has potential to be a good spot.
The drinks were a little slow in getting to the table, otherwise, the food and service was great. Would recommend.
Sat at the bar. Bartender was very friendly and the service was good. The food left a lot to be desired.
Fantastic brunch club 3-course option! Great choices, everything was delicious from appetizers to dessert. Excellent attentive server and staff. Already looking forward to going back again.
Our waiter was great, our food came out quickly and the food was amazing. We both looked at each other and said we'd come back.
All four of us ordered from the Prix Fixe menu. Everything was delicious. We chose to eat outside at tables on the sidewalk, which is not particularly scenic, but safer during the pandemic. The drinks were interesting and tasty. The service was attentive, refilling water glasses, removing plates, bringing food. We highly recommend Moonshine Supper Club.
Out of the three of us, no one enjoyed their own or each other’s entrees. The only good things were the ricotta app and the basil watermelon cocktail. Our server was sooo nice but would disappear forever so our service was insanely slow.
Eclectic and interesting menu. Attentive, but rotating wait staff. Relaxed. Good vibe.
Went to celebrate my wife’s birthday. Great cocktail selection and all the food we tried was great. When a place offers such a large variety of cuisine you think something won’t be up to par. However, every dish was really better than the next. Only thing to improve was time for food. We sat for awhile waiting at times for food ordered. It was ok because we were not in a rush and had good drinks.
A cool vibe but the food was underwhelming. Tacos a bit dry. Calamari was OK. Salad was OK. A good selection of drinks and solid service.
I was introduced to Moonshine through a friend and enjoyed it each time that I've been. The staff is usually friendly and attentive to the guests. This time was weird though. Our server might have ditched us but we were not mad because Deej (our new favorite hostess and best friend in our head) came in and saved the whole experience. She was extremely helpful, knowledgeable and just a pure delight. She made recommendations and choices that were spot on and actually delicious. What started out as a sour visit ended on a sweet note. We literally had to call a manager over to let her know how awesome she was. One of my friends even said she'd call ahead next time to request to be hosted by Deej in the future. Overall, Moonshine is a vibe and definitely one of the spots to grab your friends for a quick hangout with cute cocktails and delicious bites! 😊
Waitress seemed annoyed by our questions. When asking something simple like… how is the jerk chicken, is it good/would you recommend? She responded with… I haven’t had other jerk chicken outside of here so I can’t compare. 🤷🏽♀️ You are the “guide” for this experience! Learn more about the menu and let people ask all the questions they want so they can get have the best experience possible.
Service is excellent
Food and wine were very good
This restaurant is a friendly, trendy, great niche place to dine and enjoy a calm atmosphere.
This place is pretty cool. Very chill atmosphere with a grown & sexy crowd and music to match. I didn't care for all the "oldies" tunes, but that was a minor drawback from an overall pleasant experience.
Pardon my ignorance, but I actually found it very astonishing to find a place like this in Millburn...who knew?!
Moonshine is a local favorite. This time we made a reservation for four but the hostess tried to seat us in the bar and then made it seem like a big deal when we insisted on the dining room (which is why we had made the reservation). The calamari appetizer and hummus appetizer were excellent, along with the cocktails. The fire roasted hangar steak was perfectly cooked but all the accompaniments were strangely bland - not a tingle to the Serrano pepper creamed corn, no bite to the ancho chili pommes, no burn to the blistered cherry tomatoes.
My family and I had a great time dining at Moonshine. The food was delicious. Our server was prompt, courteous, and attentive. We will definitely be dining there soon.
Drinks and food were amazing. Server was friendly and attentive.
It was ok.... definitely not as upscale as pre COVID. I MEAN servers in shorts. Tanks and converse sneakers?
Won't feel bad walking in with shorts and sneakers next time... should have saved a dry cleaning bill
Food was great. They did however run out of some of the menu items.
Great spot, loved the vibe, music, food and drinks
The service was great! The food was delicious! Overall- everything was fantastic! I would totally recommend this place to anyone!
We sat in the bar side because It was much cooler there. The crispy sticky calamari was excellent and melted In Your mouth. Our cocktails were incredible and they were super cold in chilled glasses. The hanger steak was tender and cooked perfectly. The dinner music was excellent and then a DJ came on about 10pm. Played great classic hip hop/ reggae etc. It was perfect to enjoy more drinks relax in the big comfortable chairs and really enjoy my company.
Very calm, relaxing intimate place. Great experience. Definitely going back.
Always a great experience here. The food is fantastic, service attentive - really glad I introduced my son and parents to this place. It used to be my go-to for drinks and cocktails with friends, but definitely worthy of being called a family restaurant too!
The menu at Moonshine never disappoints! Delicious food and great service.
Excellent for and the service is outstanding, only negative is the chairs fir outside eating are not as comfortable as one would like but I will definitely go again. Gabby and Chris were fantastic servers.
The Manager didn’t come great my friends & I. But greeted everyone else at different tables. We where there first ones there well we where the last ones to get our drinks, food & appetizers. Nice place but not sure if I would return.
Menu has good variety, but would love to see a few more signature cocktails on the menu as I felt those were limited. Accommodating in terms of table, but the service from drinks to app to meals was slow and one dish came out wrong when it finally did. We were in the back corner of the bar area so not sure if that contributed.
Tasty food, kids even like it.
Will be going back.
You can order delivery directly from MoonShine - Modern Supper Club using the Order Online button. MoonShine - Modern Supper Club also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (973) 218-6042.
MoonShine - Modern Supper Club is rated 4 stars by 1001 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.