Really like Montauk. Great service by Chelsea. Food was delicious. Crab cakes and calamari to start. I ordered the red snapper and it was great in presentation and flavor. Hostess was nice when we asked to change the table. Great experience overall.
Loved everything but the noise level- hard to carry on a conversation
Overall a lovely dinner and good service.
We enjoyed the food very much. We had salmon and ceviche and they were excellent. The server and hostess both were very helpful
Mussels and calamari were excellent. N.Y. Strip was not well marbeled and even our medium rare steak was chewy and flavorless. Caesar was nothing special. Salmon entry was very good. Service excellent as well as all staff.
I would stick with seafood! Worth a visit.
First timer back with the new owners. Menu seemed a bit lacking but food was great. I hope they continue the wonderful Montauk tradition!
My wife and I have had dinner at Montauk Seafood Grill in Vail several times. This time with business associates, it was very disappointing. Slow, mediocre, and loud.
Great food and excellent service, a bit noisier than would be ideal - overall an excellent choice while in Vail
The waiter was absolutely rude and abrupt. He rushed through the Order. Would routinely walk away before we could ask for additional service. He poured water sloppily and wet the chair of our female guest. I was about to ask for a different waiter. He seemed preoccupied rushed and angry throughout the entire meal. It was a large check for a party of 4 and I refused to tip him more then $25. The Maitre D was very pleasant and knew one of our guests and comped us our deserts but that did not minimize the discomfort of having such horrible service.
Expensive and uninspired -had hopes new owner would reinvigorate but so far not.