Montauk Seafood Grill
All reservations require credit card information only kept on file in the event guests no-show or cancel within 24 hours. In the case of cancellations we only ask for as much communication as possible to avoid a $25/per person cancellation charge. Email us at firstname.lastname@example.org or leave a voicemail if needed to let us know 970-476-2601.
Reservations are taken for inside dining rooms only. Patio tables are ONLY available on a first come, first served basis. Patio diners cannot be guaranteed a table inside if inclement weather is in the area.
For parties greater than six please call us at the restaurant during business hours or send an email to email@example.com
Where the oceans meet the mountains.
Est. 1987, serving FRESH seafood from all corners of the globe & high quality Colorado steaks.
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Wonderful. The simple but pleasant atmosphere. The food was excellent all around, each course. Our anniversary and the manager Rob did a few special things for us: champagne, flowers, a note on the table. The best of all was Chelsea, our server. We wanted to adopt her.
Our favorite restaurant when we are in town! Kudos!!!
Always the best halibut ever! The service is impeccable
The quality of the food was outstanding along with the service.
All of the hosts and waiters/waitresses were very friendly and helpful. We actually went back three different nights during our stay. My wife and I shared the Tower as a full meal one night! We also ordered the Halibut, New York steak and the wedge salad.
We had an outstanding meal for my 60th. Couldn’t have been better!
Amazing Food. Always consistent. Service is excellent, and atmosphere, especially on the patio, is terrific. Our favorite restaurant in Vail
We had an outstanding meal at Montauk Grill! Our favorite restaurant in Vail.
Everything had such intense flavor. Not spicy, just rich but not overdone. Loved everything we ordered.
Both my wife and I were extremely pleased with our meals. They were well prepared. My halibut was perfectly cooked. My wife had seared tuna, which I thought was a bit too seared, but she was very happy with it. We shared a single dessert that was of ample size for the two of us. We would definitely return if in the area again.
Drinks were great! Meals were fantastic! Atmosphere and music were perfect! We had a top notch experience. Will be back for sure!
Crusted Halibut and Grilled Scallops were DELISH! Sand pie and Key Lime pie were yummy! Kate, our server was delightful and very good!
excellent meal - food was first rate - service was attentive
Outstanding food. Blackened scallops were amazing
We have been going to Montauk's for many years and the seafood lovers in my family are always thrilled with the fresh from the sea offerings, especially the king crab legs! The steak lovers likewise are never disappointed and last night's NY Strip was perfect!
The food was amazing. Unfortunately, our server made us feel rushed and like an inconvenience. The other servers in the restaurant seemed open and friendly. Compared to the other restaurants in Vail, we were saddened to receive this kind of service at a restaurant with such excellent food.
Waiter wasn’t friendly, food was mediocre at best.
Birthday celebration to remember- staff was so kind and threw in Champaigne and dessert! Started with oysters. They along with the evening’s Salmon special was fabulous. Sides and wedge salad tasty too. Will come back!!
I grew up fishing on the east coast and the freshness of Montauk's food made me believe it had been caught that day. Service was attentive and it was an awesome meal.
Service is always top notch at Montauk. I know it is a seafood place but the steaks are some of the best in town. Perfectly cooked with amazing sides to choose from. Always on our list when we visit Vail.
The service was extremely slow
Wonderful food and service, as always!
This place is as good as it gets, period! Our new Vail fave.
Amazing dinner, highly recommend. Will be back!
Food was outstanding. Service rushed and was for a special occasion and didn’t feel anything extra was done.
Felt because they saw us show up with kids we were relegated to a less than good spot. Food was outstanding and would go back felt a little disappointed in how much I spent vs treatment
The food was terrific, and our server was very atentive and friendly.
The crab legs were awesome and it was so much food. The service was great as well. Would definitely recommend for a nice dinner in Vail!
We returned to Montauk Seafood Grill over Memorial Day Weekend after they had re-opened for the summer season, and it was another fabulous experience! We had oysters, grilled scallop dinner, a chef special crab cake dinner and the mud pie dessert and everything was awesome. Super fresh, amazing flavors and delicious!
We had a very enjoyable evening. Our menu choices were excellent and service was perfect.
It was a special occasion for us and Montauk exceed our expectations. Chelsea was a fabulous server and next time we have another special occasion we will definitely be back.
Great food. Great service. Thanks to all the staff.
Fresh fresh seafood for sure! The oysters were exceptional & the beautiful salad with crab...so good! That's all we had room for along with the wine but I will definitely go back to try more when I'm there.
Great service and great food. Would be willing to call it one of the best landlocked seafood places I’ve been to.
Great service ! Food was fantastic, everyone at this restaurant was lovely ! Noise level a bit high and seating next to family with small kids was rough , however overall we had the best time !!!!
We had a great dinner at Montauk Seafood Grill. It was actually the best restaurant/meal of our entire week in Vail. From the appetizer to the desserts, everything was fresh, delicious and well made. The waitress was very friendly and catered to all our needs. The ambience was great. They did a very good job spacing tables to keep people distant due to COVID. I highly recommend this restaurant.
I had a herb crusted pan seared halibut with a salad and whipped potatoes. It was delicious. Service was excellent.
A place that I always want to visit when I am in Vail
Great restaurant and great food the service good I love the
I thoroughly enjoyed my meal at Montauk Seafood Grill. I want to go back there and try other menu items.
Always a favorite when visiting Vail!
Montauk Seafood Grill offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (970) 476-2601.
Montauk Seafood Grill is rated 4.8 stars by 1324 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.