Mitchell's is becoming a favorite for us when visiting Columbus! Great food and great service! It was a bit noisy when we were there and the tables are a bit close together as we could make conversation with the couples sitting on either side of us! But when all is said and done...we had a great evening out!
The overall ambiance was nice, but we were seated in a terrible location. The food was good, but not extraordinary. I will say the service was good. It was a busy night and I felt like the server was still attentive to us.
I love this place! So glad I had my bachelorette dinner here. I recommend this place to everyone!
Great time love the food... Berry bubbles must try also crab cake...
Fabulous! Excellent service and wonderful food.
They need to do a better job with their table assignments. On more than 1 occasion, we feel like we are sitting on top of another table.
They are obviously trying to maximize their numbers during peak times but you have more room at a Ponderosa than the Ocean Club which isn’t good.
Was a very enjoyable experience. I went with my girlfriend to have a fancy date night and we had a wonderful time. They even set us in one of those large circular tables for like a group of 6 or 8 so we had the whole table to ourselves. The food was excellent and the staff was friendly. Would definitely recommend for a fine dining date night.
Excellent food. Server kept forgetting what we ordered. Was pleasant nonetheless but we kept having to remind her about our bread, drink, what we had ordered. We’ve eaten at ocean club and we love the food the ambiance and the service. Tonight, it appeared our server needed a little more training.
The waitstaff were superb and the menu was excellent. We both had wonderful steaks and split the mac and cheese.
This restaurant was typical with the Mitchell’s brand. I was expecting a lot more seafood on the menu and was disappointed there was not much. We could have went to the steakhouse in Polaris for the same food at a cheaper cost. Paid for the area versus food. I would not go there again for dinner.
Amazing food, but the prices weren't synonymous with the ambience (too loud and tables crowded together).
As always The Ocean Club delivers!! Justin is a great waiter and we look forward to our next trip back.
Absolutely fantastic...best restaurant in Columbus, hands-down. We had the bone-in filet (with an exceptional truffle butter) and lobster tail, and it was excellent. The service was outstanding, and even the cocktails and dessert were exceptional.
Food and service were amazing, as always. The passion fruit martini was delicious and not too sweet. The beef sliders were cooked perfectly and had nice flavor. The Gouda tater tots are one of our favorites, and they were a treat with our filet and salmon meals. The only downside was the number of bones in the salmon. Warm butter cake will always be one of our favorite sweet ending, yet we look forward to trying the peanut butter pie during our next visit.
Bill, our server, was friendly, knowledgeable, and charming.
My husband and I went to Mitchell’s Ocean Club for our first anniversary. The restaurant was lovely and the service was incredible. My steak, however was only okay. I ordered the ribeye and it was full of gristle and all I could taste was the butter they put on it when it came out of the broiler. For the price I was not pleased. I ate very little of it and I am making my husband a frittata with very expensive steak this morning. Our sides and drinks were great, my husband enjoyed his steak, everything else was perfect.
Ryan was our waiter and was great, best service we’ve had recently. Food was perfect, we have zero complaints.
My wife and I went for a belated Valentine’s Day dinner and the service and food were excellent! Great date night with very nice ambiance! The wait staff were extremely understanding regarding our timeline and didn’t rush us along at all, but the pace of service never made it seem like we were lacking. Everything came out at the perfect time, almost like magic!
The prices are a little steep, especially compared to other Mitchell’s restaurants. Although Ocean Club is now owned by Ocean Prime, Not Cameron Mitchell, so that makes some sense as the menu doesn’t seem to have changed since the last time we went (2 yrs ago or so) AND the fact that they had all of the usual Mitchell’s side dishes and were able to make the standard Mitchell’s non-menu cocktails.
One hour late to be seated from our reservation time
Great service from Trion (approximate spelling). Also liked the low noise level in the back room.
Everything was amazing! Me and my girlfriend will definitely go back. Can’t wait til then!
Such a nice place and the food was magnificent. Absolutely loved it.
Wonderful food, in a beautiful setting with outstanding service. Even on a busy holiday we don’t feel rushed and we’re able to enjoy a truly memorable evening.
This wasn't our first visit and won't be our last inspite of the less than five-star experience. Everything on our visit was exceptional except one entrée - surf and turf. The over-seasoned 8 oz filet was undercooked (more rare than medium) and the lobster tail was also over-seasoned. In full disclosure, I did not bring the issue to our servers attention until after dinner with an inquiry about seasoning options when ordering on our next visit (never had to do this on prior visits). Our appetizers, sides, and other entrée were the usual high Ocean Club standards. If interested in the surf and turf, I highly recommend discussing seasoning options with your server. It's simply too expensive to leave the restaurant disappointed.
Valentine’s Day with my sweetheart!
Again the experience was fantastic! Our waiter was very attentive as needed and he set a warm, relaxing atmosphere. Our appetizer and main entrees were excellent and served in a timely manner. Our table was located in the far rear room that was quiet which provided a setting for great conversation without raising our voices-but still maintained our privacy.
Thanks again for a great dining experience!
Simply one of the best restaurants in the Columbus area. Top quality food prepared excellently and served by a very attentive staff. If you have not dined there; then, you need to go there soon.
It was our first time here and we chose Valentine's Day to try it out. It was lovely and the space is much, much larger than it appears on the outside. The ambience and atmosphere was very lovely, very "posh" as my English husband would say. The cocktails and food (french onion soup, steaks, lobster, asparagus, whipped potatoes, sorbets) were out of this world --- I loved the Black Orchid cocktail and had 3! Our server was so nice and so knowledgeable about everyone on the menu and answered all of our questions very ably. It IS pricey so we would only go there for special occasions but it was wonderful and I hope to go back again soon!
Fantastic service, food and total experience was first rate
We are never disappointed with the Ocean Club.
The service, ambiance and food consistently pleases our special dates.
We especially enjoy the quiet rooms off the main dining area.
The Chilean sea bass was fantastic!