Nearby points of interest
Nearby points of interest
About Mill Pond Steakhouse
The Mill Pond Steak House is the only up-scaled steakhouse in the midlands. We offer the best Certified Angus Beef that is aged for 40 plus days before it is served to the guest. We have a well developed and seasoned staff that is committed to your dining needs. It starts from the time you pick up the phone to make a reservation to the time you are welcomed at the front door and lasts forever. When you arrive to the Mill Pond Steakhouse in Boykin, SC you take a step back in time. The restaurant is composed of three historic buildings established in the early 19th century. The kitchen was the old Post office, the bar was the old General Store and the main dining room was another General Store relocated to its present location. From the heart pine floors to the reclaimed lumber that was once walls of several cabins in Boykin, you realize that you are surrounded by history. Mill Pond Steak House offers rustic elegance with southern hospitality and a one of a kind dining experience.
Rembert, SC 29128
Hours of Operation:
Dinner: Tuesday - Saturday: 5:00pm - 10:00pm
$31 to $50
AMEX, Discover, MasterCard, Visa
We will cater; rehearsal dinners, birthday parties, cocktail parties, and wedding receptions.
Private Party Facilities:
Semi-private facilities available for bridal or business luncheons; AV equipment is available.
Private Party Contact:
Alan Voigt: (803) 425-8825
Banquet, Bar Dining, Bar/Lounge, Beer, BYO Wine, Corkage Fee, Fireplace, Full Bar, Non-Smoking, Outdoor dining, Private Room, Takeout, View, Wheelchair Access, Wine
Mill Pond Steakhouse Ratings and Reviews
My poor review may be the result of just a bad night that had been overbooked, but by the time we arrived and were seated the crowd was thinning significantly, so I am at a loss to explain why such a friendly staff were so incompetent. First of all, we sat down 20 minutes after our reservation waiting for a table to be set. The guests had already left but no one set it up for the next customer. Once we sat down, wine was served immediately and then radio silence for then next half hour , no bread or butter. I think we managed to place our order. But literally one hour after our reservation we had not been served a crumb of food. I had to find someone and speak sharply to them to get anyone to give us bread. When it finally came (cornbread) it was clearly underdone, so while fresh out of the oven, wasn't fully baked. When the food arrived everything was lukewarm including the salmon and the crab cakes. my steak was the only good thing we got (except for the $14 glass of wine which was very good). The salmon was undercooked although my husband specifically asked for it to be done well and as I said, room temp. Crab cakes also not hot and underwhelming taste-wise. WAiter forgot the spoon for the family style veggies , promised to get one and never returned. Never saw the waiter after that moment except for the presentation of the check. Had to flag down the hostess to get the salmon redone. Had high hopes for this one as the local rep is that it is the only special place in town. I'd only recommend this to people who plan to order steak and warning them of my pretty miserable experience with the service.
This is by far the best steakhouse in South Carolina and that includes Ruth Chris, Morton's and Hall's of Charleston. I've been to them all. We had the 22 ounce aged beef rib eye. It was cooked to perfection and would melt in your mouth. Just what you would expect from Clyde and his staff. Service is a strength at the Mill Pond. Josh was our waiter and before you could think of a need, he was already there. Mary Ann does a great job providing fine dinning at its best! I and my wife highly recommend you experience the Boykin Mill Pond Steakhouse.
Our food was very good, but not better than similar items at Rick Erwin’s or High Cotton—and more expensive. I was especially disappointed to discover that the “specials” of the day, described by our server, were significantly more expensive than similar items on the menu. Ask for the price of the specials in advance if value is important to you. We were trying to stay within our $100 budget for two, and went over by 50%. We got two entrees, shared a side, one water and one tea, and our total with 18% tip was $150. Our wait staff was very good and the place is extra special for a romantic date or important group meal. We will go back, but I will be wary of the specials.
For an a la carte steak house, it was acceptable. The hostess and staff were extremely friendly even though they were understaffed leading to delayed reservations. The value for the food left some room to be desired as it didn't feel like the plating or taste were up to their pricing. Go if you need a convenient and local date night or special occasion with decent ambiance.
The drive to this remote setting is well worth it. Come hungry. Portions on almost all menu items makes them shareable. Both of our steaks were perfectly cooked. We shared their very tasty chopped salad and usually are more adventurous but large steaks were on the way. Plenty of side dishes to choose from. We have eaten here many times and the atmosphere can range from quiet/romantic to loud/energetic. Since the restaurant is well suited to large tables large parties are not unusual so if quiet/romantic is what you are looking for it would be worth checking on large party reservations before booking your table.We will be returning on a regular basis.
The food was great and the staff was very attentive and friendly. Although the pond is drained currently, the view was still pleasant and the setting intimate. Unfortunately we had the bad luck of having our anniversary dinner the same night a rambunctious, overly loud and annoying party also took place. They were so loud that a simple conversation was almost impossible and any sense of quite intimacy was drained with every hoot and holler from their table.
This is a wonderful restaurant and one of those off the beaten path finds! Yes, it is a drive but so worth it.
Highly recommend a reservation. More than likely you won't get a table without one. This is a dress up kind of place so don't plan on wearing a T-shirt. Khakis and a polo shirt for men would be fine but you will see people in dress shirts and ties.
When you drive up you will question why someone recommended the place to you but I promise you it is well worth it! Definitely don't judge a book by its cover.
I recommend trying the dry rub/aged Ribeye and save room for dessert! It is all served ala carte but the portions are big. We had 3 people and only needed 1 side.
This was such a wonderful find. We were staying in Camden and had had this recommendation from Katherine and Bruce at The Bloomsbury Inn for a nice steak dinner.. Very quaint and charming little place. We thoroughly enjoyed. We stopped out on the patio while we waited for our table to be readied and loved looking over the historic pond and watching the sun settle down over the trees.
Our dining experience was deliciously pleasant! We had great service with Jon and he was very helpful in guiding us through ordering and choices we were considering. We both had small filets ..I had the bacon wrapped special with a rich mushroom demi-glace. The sides are definitely big enough to share. The warm mixed berry cobbler served with home-made vanilla-bean ice cream was the perfect finish to the meal! (Order it before meal..it takes some time to bake..and is well worth the extra calories !)
Overall - HIGH MARKS - for great food, attentive service and delightful evening.
We started with wine by the glass - Riesling and Pinot Noir. We had the baked Brie for the five of us to share. We moved on to small garden salads and the entrees. Two of us shared a Queen cut filet , one of us had the bone in ribeye. Another two had the queen cut filet - one for each. We finished with two cobblers, peach and mixed berry -to share amongst us according to our preferences. We finished with coffee and had a thoroughly wonderful time. My filet was really special and done perfectly and seasoned well. Everybody raved about the meal. The service was very professional and pleasantly done. The ambience was perfect. Worth every penny!
We had heard that Mill Pond is a great steakhouse and decided to go to celebrate family birthdays. We had a nice leisurely dinner, almost too leisurely, as we were almost the last to leave. Even though we ordered the recommended fruit cobbler ahead of time, we still had to wait. Our meal was very good, although a bit more pricey than we were prepared for. We were aware of the price of the steaks and the ala carte sides but were still a bit surprised at the $100 Per person cost.
Please sign in to record your input. Thanks!
Report this review as inappropriate?
If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate.