Mill Pond House
Give us a call anytime, we look forward to having you as our guest.
Received the "Award of Excellence" from Wine Spectator in 2020.
*$35 wine corkage fee on 750ml. (great selection and fair prices on our wine list)
*$4pp cake cutting fee. All of our desserts are baked daily by our pastry chef. Please call If you would like us to make a personal cake for your special occasion.
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Valentine's Day Special Menus & More
Menu will feature a 3 course meal @ $60 per person (beverages, dessert, tax & gratuity not included). Please note there is an hour and a half limit on dining.
Wait service was lacking. Never checked how appetizers or dinner was once served. Took very long time to ask for drink refills. Didn’t go over specials.
Always a great meal with very attentive service. Tables nicely spaced presenting a very safe atmosphere and comfortable setting. We will most definitely return.
My husband and I had such a wonderful time. We were never rushed and we didn't have to wait. It was as if the waiter read our minds it was sooo perfect! We started with drinks, then an app to share...We moved on to the best lobster I have had in a while and he got a gorgeous 12oz filet mignon. Dessert and cappuccino were also wonderful. Highly recommend can't wait to go back and watch a sunset...
Amazing dinner and amazing service. Have been here many times and always enjoyed the food, service and location.
We are now making Mill Pond our tradition for anniversary dinners. Amazing food, service and setting!
Prefix was amazing for the money and food was outstanding
Always enjoy a dinner out at the Mill Pond! Great service and excellent food.
Awesome always loved this place! Food is great, service impeccable, drinks are perfect and the valet is a added bonus!
Was great, servers were attentive, place was clean and entire staff were nice.
Staff is exceptional and restaurant is well spaced for COVID requirements
Wonder Prix Fixe lunch! Food, service was fantastic! Will be back again soon.
It was a great night and everything went perfect. I loved the fact that the staff grabbed all the doors and open them for you; a nice touch having nothing to do with Covid. The food was delicious and the portions were plentiful. Great job and a happy new year, I’ll be back. A.F.M.
Wonderful as always! Such a great ambiance, food and wine excellent with attentive staff.
It was the first time my wife and I were there. We had reservations for New Year’s Eve. When we got there we were greeted and seated right away. We had a table out on the enclosed deck. The staff was very attentive and on top of everything! My wife had the potato crusted black Seabass. It was the best fish I ever tasted. Can’t wait to go back again!
I hope we get the same delicious food and great service. I would recommend this place to anybody!
New Year’s Eve. Mill Pond has been our go to restaurant for years. Date night, night out with friends, lunch & hosting private parties. Everyone from the management to the servers are friendly, knowledgeable and always accommodating. The food is consistently great and the atmosphere is wonderful.
We are always very selective when choosing a place to dine and exceptionally so, during the pandemic. We dine infrequently and early when there are less people. We had lunch on the terrace overlooking Centerport Bay. The restaurant has taken great care to make the diners feel comfortable while serving the great food they are known for. The pre-fixe lunch is still available for $28.95 three courses / appetizer, main and dessert. Some new items are available including a beet carpaccio salad which was excellent, the salmon and creme brûlée were my choice and i was not disappointed. Mill Pond may not be known for their sushi but we had the red dragon roll which rivaled any other restaurant specializing in the cuisine.
The staff made our experience comfortable-if you need to get out or take a ride do not hesitate to try Mill Pond House.
The best oysters in the world! Delicious crab cake, beautiful setting and generous drinks. Fabulous staff!
This place gets it I right, every time!
One dish was not cooked the cappuccino was cold and weak. The service was excellent maybe a better chef
Time here. We moved locally in May. Beautiful place. Amazing food. We will return.
Our Christmas Eve at Mill Pond House was legendary. Maurice always takes great care of us. The oysters were so fresh and the portherhouse still has us reminiscing of our night.
We had Christmas Eve dinner here and the food and service were great. We really enjoyed it.
Always 5 star experience
Great food. Great atmosphere, even during a pandemic.
Fabulous as usual
Great service and the best ribeye I've had in years.
Quiet night due to snowstorm but excellent all around as usual!
Had a beautiful dinner with friends to celebrate the holidays and Mill Pond did not disappoint. They have it decorated beautifully and have tables spaced to accommodate covid social distancing regulations.
Beautiful place, tastefully decorated. Amazing food selections, especially seafood. Definitely recommend.
Absolutely wonderful! Food and service was outstanding! And the holiday decorations were so beautiful.
Mentioned it was a birthday.
That is me just being petty. However, when you order a half duck you expect to get a breast. Not two overcooked drumsticks that I could have used to start a campfire. When you need to use a knife for short rib something has gone wrong.
On the positive side, the appetizers were quite good.
The rice balls were amongst the best I ever had. The use blue cheese and truffles were amazing.
The octopus salad was also exceptional.
If I knew that the entrees weren’t worthy to feed my dog I would have ordered every appetizer and given this establishment 5 Stars.
It’s not my intention to be cruel but if you expect people to pay $$$$ you better bring your A game on $$$$ entrees.
Service was very good as was the food. Have been to the restaurant serval times before and always had issues with the service in the past. Something changed and staff was attentive this time. Food was good had the lobster bisque and scallops. My wife had the octopus and cavaltelli with shrimp. Both were specials.
First time at the Mill Pond House and definitely won’t be the last. The food was exceptional and the restaurant is beautifully decorated for the holidays. Great bar as well!
Visited this restaurant during Covid time, and found all to be compliant except that it is very easy to bump into someone exiting while you are entering as the vestibule is very narrow. That being said, food was above average, the wine list was short but adequate and service was flawless. Also, there is a nice view of the inlet from the restaurant's out door porch
Food and service excellent
Fantastic setting and outdoor dining patio. Food was excellent and staff was great. Will go back again!
It was great. The pecan crusted pie was good. Jerry’s steak was great!
The food was wonderful as always! Staff was attentive and social distancing was well done. Much appreciated Thanksgiving meal during this strange year. Best of luck to all our restaurants!
The Mill Pond while on the pricey side is always a sure thing in my book. The wait staff is superb. The food is amazing and the ambience/ location is stunning. I have never had a bad meal here-ever and that is why it's my sure thing. ( it's proximity to my home also rates) Amzing for special occasions.
Mill Pond House offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (631) 261-7663.
Mill Pond House is rated 4.7 stars by 2312 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.