It was nice
Wished the they had a better selections of drinks. Other than that, the food and the live band was amazing.
I wanted to bring my boyfriend there to treat him on Valentine’s and he loved it. The food was pricey but delicious. Thanks to the gentleman with the glasses I have had a great experience
Our table wasn’t ready on time. It took us 45 minutes to get water. We ordere chicken wings for the table and they were brought with no extra plates for sharing. We were given a dirty crab cracker after having to ask for it more than once (the waiter actually took it off someone else’s table and handed it to my friend). When we complained to the manager we were given a lot of excuses and a free bottle of champagne as if that was supposed to make up for it. And then, to add insult to injury, we were charged automatically a 18% gratuity for our party of 5. Really terrible experience and we went for my friend’s birthday. I would not recfommend this place and hope to never go back.
All staff was wonderful especially Shanette. Some of the food was very salty. I could not eat the Chinese fried chicken and it did not come with any sides . The portion of the salmon and the sides was very small. When I walked into the place I fell in love with the place. My daughter an American and my son in law to be born in Jamaica wil l soon be married in Jamaica and needed a place to have some thing in New York for family and friends . I thought this would be the perfect place but the food had too many defaults. I am back looking for another venue.
My reservation was for 9:00 pm I was running late I called to inform them.? I got there by 9:15pm. We waited for about 20:00 minuets to be seated don’t know why because the restaurant was fairly empty. The hostess took us to a table for two that was directly next to the stage, a live band was scheduled for the night. I told her that I would prefer not to be seated so close to the stage because of the noise, she explained to me that it would be a fifteen minutes wait to get another table, didn’t understand why because again the restaurant was fairly empty. The hostess seemed to be annoyed with my choice to change tables. I was pretty annoyed also. We got another table right away. My other complaint is that the restaurant was very cold, I was also very disappointed with the food and drinks. Our waiter Rob though was very pleasant and attentive.
By far the worst experience I’ve had at any restaurant. The high price of this restaurant does not meet the quality service. The food was good but it took forever to get. The waiter was overwhelmed because the second waiter took the night off. They have a metal detectors when you come into the place. Definitely not worth the price. I will never go back there. Better off going to the Cheesecake Factory or Applebee’s.
The llace is a nice ambiance i went on saturday and they had a band playing which was great. But the service from start to finish would discourage me from coming back. Staff is not at all friendly. To puy things in perepect i had a 9pm reservation and our food came out at 11:30pm and the food was cold! The staff was unapologetic and not at all accomdating.
If rhe syaff was friendlier and the food came out at least warm then id rate it much higher. Once my food was warm it was actually tasty but the vibe i got from the staff in all honestlt ruined my whole experience
The Waiter was very tentative. The Manager requested to hang our coats. The alcohol drinks were very good. The band was excellent. The food was well seasoned and was delicious. Price was reasonable. Had a wonderful time.
Food was good, but I was surprised that the Jamaican Festival Dumplings wasn't as good as it could be, but I will try it again. I have had Festival Dumplings for breakfast in Jamaica and that was all I needed to it.
I've been to Milk River three time previously. I was always a fan of their service but this last time I was disappointed. My group were the only ones in the restaurant. I asked to speak with the manager because their card reader was down and none of my friends had cash(including me). I asked to speak with the manager. The waitress tells the manager I want to talk to her and the manager looks at me looks back and the waitress and then says something to her. The waitress notifies me she'll be with me in a moment. The manager looks at me and proceeds to walk around the kitchen. Stopping to look back at me every few steps. Mind you THERE ARE ZERO CUSTOMERS IN THERE BESIDES ME AND MY TWO FRIENDS. I become frustrated and walk to the bathroom to meet my friends. I come back out the bathroom and the manager still has not left the kitchen. I become super frustrated. Finally after ten minutes she slowly walks out the kitchen to answer my question. She looks me in my face and says "I didn't know you were waiting to speak with me". I asked her why no one notified us before or even during our meal that the card machine wasn't working. We could've found other solutions beforehand. She goes to the machine and swipes it and it goes through. I'm not sure what the issue was when the waitress did it however I was glad it was resolved. None the less the service was mediocre and I was deeply upset by the managers actions. I believe it was very unprofessional for her to purposely ignore me as if I was not a paying customer. I was also the ONLY customer. Maybe if her attitude was better it would be more full every night. I have also heard this restaurant had been shot up. Is this part of the problem?
Great food and the band was amazing playing soulful Caribbean music. Restaurant is pretty large so makes it good for a large party.
I had the oxtail, it was cooked just right with just the right amount of spice to it. Portions are small so I suggest getting some appetizers for starters.
Very poor service. Although we made a reservation well in advance, we waited over one hour to be seated. The food portions were small and not worth the price. There are better Caribbean restaurants in NYC. Don't waste your time.
Service could be better. We had to while quite a while before our server came to our table. The waitstaff needs more training on how to handle guests - they are a little rough around the edges.
We went on a down night (Tuesday) so didn't get the live music experience so I think this place is really overall a 5. Food, drinks and staff were great. Bar is inviting, comfy dining area and bathrooms clean and spacious. Will come back for live music(Th-Sunday).
The ambiance was awesome! Finally a West Indian restaurant that caters for all. The oxtail was quite tasty and the service was delightful. Finding parking was easier than I thought. The live band was quite entertaining. I certainly enjoyed my time there and woukd not hesitate to visit again
Had great table service from the waitress. Was knowledgeable and very helpful. My only problem is the gratuity is taken and not given. My waitress earned her tip but what if she didn't.
This was our third time visiting Milk River. The food and drinks were excellent. Our server was very helpful in making menu suggestions. The only thing I had an issue was that I had two different charges on my card. I just called my card company to inform them. I hope this was just an error and not a normal practice, since it was first time it happened to me. Overall, it's a very nice place.
The drinks were great as well as the service from our waiter for a group of 8. This was our 2nd visit and we were a bit disappointed as the Jerk lamb chops have been removed from the menu and we never got to try them as they ran out the first visit. The food could use a bit more flare and flavor. The mac and cheese was better this visit.
Not my first time here. However, the menu continues to be overly priced and small quantities. The live band is too loud to the point you cannot hear yourself speak. The decor is always representative of Bk..love that. Overall a good spot to club and drink.
Second visit. Brunch was better than my first dinner visit. Chicken was excellent. Waffle was skimpy. Tasty salmon. Unfortunately the portions are small and you leave hungry.
Caribbean food in Brooklyn with an excellent ambiance and service. I do plan to visit again in the future.
The food was excellent. The service was great. Only thing was the lighting. It could of been a little more brighter. Other wise I have no complaints.
This is the third time I've dined at Milk River. I will only return for drinks and to listen to the band. It started out great, but deteriorated. It took a long time for the waitress to bring our main dish after having appetizers. Once the dish arrived, there were no utensils. We asked one staff member and he forgot. He finally remembered and told another staff member. It took anywhere from 15 to 20 minutes before the utensils arrived. The food is extremely salty (including the appetizers). Everyone in my party agreed. The band was great and the Sorrel was really tasty. It had a nice kick. Every time I've dined at Milk River, the service was bad. This is over the years. It has not improved at all. Beautiful venue, but not recommended for food and service. I feel like I wasted my money.
I came here for dinner to celebrate my 22nd birthday. Luckily i found parking about two blocks away which wasn't bad. The inside of Milk Rive is nicely decorated, however the menu is much more limited as compared to online. I ordered the milk wings (sweet and spicy) and a side of mac and cheese. The mac & cheese here is really good! There were performers the night that i went so the ambiance was kind've noisy which made it hard to hear my guest and talk, but nice overall. Our server wasn't as attentive as he could have been but it wasn't terrible. I have not yet gotten to try the lounge area but I will def give it a chance for next time!
Nothing but good things to say. First off, I made the reservation not an hour before and everything went smoothly. We were greeted warmly on the walk in. Our waiter was very kind, timely and efficient. Food was DELICIOUS. We were there for brunch, we had the chicken and waffles, and shrimp and grits. I highly recommemd both. We both had the Brooklyn Iced Tea, something similar to a Long Island Iced Tea. Great drink. I just wish they had a desert menu. I'm not sure if it was because it was during brunch, but there were no deserts available.. Tunes spinning in the back. Loud enough to vybe to, low enough for you to enjoy your conversation. Ambiance was great.
This downtown Brooklyn location probably won't last long after the word gets out that the food is over-priced and just okay. Also, the live-band music that was played during dinner was so loud that my dinner party had to scream to hear each other when the band was not screaming at the top of their lungs. 3 apps, 2 sides, and a few (scant) drinks will be put a $100+ bill hurtin' on you, and with some complimentary ear-ringing and voice-loss to boot!...Notwithstanding, this dinner price-gouging, the venue will still force you to pay cover for the social/nightlife side of the venue. I then proceeded to laugh and leave this establishment.
Enjoy! Well, not really, but you know what I mean.
Our server, Janae, was UNBELIEVABLE! She had a wealth of knowledge when it came to the menu and drink options. She tried her absolute BEST to ensure that we enjoyed the food and had a great experience. The food is creatively put together and named appropriately but the taste... Meh.
I would recommend this place if you want to have a great time, great conversation, and some great drinks. Order Cocktails and appetizers. Not the shrimp, though... they have heads and arms... yikes!
Poor service. Very little food for outrageous prices
The food wasn't good at all, and it was really loud I couldn't even hear the waiter when I was trying to order..overall I had a bad experience..never again!
Was very empty around 6:30 on Tuesday but by the time we were done more people came in. The food was really good though I think overpriced. They didn't have a couple items on the already small menu.
We celebrated the birthday of a girlfriend of mine at Milk River recently. We were anticipating the food wondering what it would be like? We were all pleasantly surprised to find that the food was fantastic! Even more, we were well entertained by the smooth vibes and rhythms from the Friday night band. A great place for family and friends to get together. Looking forward to my next visit to Milk River.
I dined with my husband for v day the food was over priced and salty. The staff was excellent and we both enjoyed the drinks. It was a pre fixed menu, so I'm going to try milk river again to see what their regular menu is like.
I had a terrible experience on Valentine's Day. When I arrived they asked if I booked through Open Table and when I said yes they explained that due to an error on Open Table's end, people who reserved online were not aware that they had a mandatory special menu at $75/person. I was floored when I heard that because that was way too expensive. Unfortunately, I am not from Brooklyn and didn't know where else to eat so stayed. It felt nasty and down right dishonest that they pulled this scam on folks. They didn't tell us until we arrived about the special menu. However, I called to tell them I was running a few minute late and that I had booked online and at that time on the phone no one explained to me the special menu.
People were leaving and I heard those who chose to stay complaining about this scam Milk River pulled. I do visit Brooklyn on occasion and have friends there. I will never return or recommend anyone dine here.
This was a very calculated move knowing that many other restaurants were booked on Valentine's Day. It's bad business and makes Open Table look bad if what they are saying about the glitch is true.
Dinner was the worst, the waiter seem annoyed when called
The restaurant is very nice inside. The staff was great but the food was just average. If you have a restaurant and service the group of people from which your food is supposed to be derived from, you must do better. I could not recommend this restaurant because of the taste of the food.
The food does not taste the same from when I first went there in 2014
Service was very slow. Didn't allow us to sit at the table until every single guest arrived or you had to speak with the manager to change the reservation and it was only two guests that were running late. They didn't have a lot of items that were on the menu. The drinks were okay.
the food was good overall. but the kitchen needs to serve what is on the menu. being there a few times but each time ; i have to order something different from what i want.
I've wanted to try this place for quite some time. I should've taken the reviews into more consideration. The ambiance of the restaurant was really nice. A relaxed feeling. There was a live band that was playing which made it impossible to have a conversation without yelling at the top of your lungs. When looking at the menu, I thought it would be more of a variety especially being a Jamaican restaurant. Very lack luster. I ended up getting the salmon which was delicious. The service was poor. It wasn't even a busy night but our waitress always seemed to be missing. She barely came back to check up on us or to refill any drinks. We only grabbed her attention when she noticed one of the bus boys was bagging our food. When we received the bill we saw why she didn't really work, the gratuity was automatically added to the bill. Mind you it was only my friend and myself. We will not be back to dine at this place.